The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
32. In view of the above, the prayer of the petitioners cannot be allowed.
33. The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
S/L 2
06.10.2026
Court No.24
SD
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
WPA 28485 of 2026
Adarsha Patra & Ors.
Vs.
The Union of India & Ors.
Mr. Bikram Banerjee
Mr. Saikat Sutradhar
… for the Petitioners.
Ms. Chandreyi Alam
Mr. Subhajit Das
… for the Union of India.
Mr. Sahasrangshu Bhattacharjee, Ld. AGP
Mr. Suchindram Bhattacharjee
… for the State.
Mr. Lokenath Chatterjee,
Ms. Mary Datta
… for the WBUHS.
Mr. Debapriya Gupta
Mr. Sujoy Paul
… for the National Commission for Homeopathy.
1.
Affidavit of service filed in Court today be kept
with the records.
2.
The petitioners claim to have taken admission in
Kharagpur Homeopathic Medical College and Hospital
for pursuing Bachelor of Homeopathic Medicine and
Surgery in the academic year 2024-2025. The college
is allegedly affiliated to the West Bengal University of
Health Sciences since the session 2004-2005 and is
also
affiliated
to
the
National
Commission
for
Homeopathy.
3.
The petitioners took admission in the course
without
appearing
in
NEET.
According
to
the
petitioners, NEET ought to be conducted by the
Commission itself and not by any other authority.
The petitioners contend that the Commission ought
not to conduct NEET through outsourcing.
4.
Reliance has been placed on the order dated
November 27, 2025 passed by the coordinate Bench
of this Court in WPA 18346 of 2025 [Hrithik
Chandra Sarkar vs. The Union of India & Ors.]
wherein the Court permitted the candidates to pursue
their course without creating any equity in their
favour and their registration would be subject to the
result of the writ petition. Direction for filing affidavit
has been given.
5.
Reliance has also been placed on the order dated
April 9, 2026 passed in batch of writ petitions one of
which is WPA 13413 of 2025 [Sourin Jana vs. The
Union of India & Ors.] wherein similar direction has
been passed for registration of the candidate to
enable him to pursue the course without any equity
in their favour.
6.
It has been submitted that the aforesaid Sourin
Jana (supra) is of the same college and same batch of
the petitioners.
As Sourin Jana (supra) has been
permitted to continue the course, similarly the
petitioners may also be permitted to continue the
course after registration.
7.
It has been contended that similarly placed
candidates ought to be treated alike.
8.
Learned advocate representing the University
and the National Commission for Homoeopathy
oppose
the
submissions
and
prayers
of
the
petitioners.
9.
Learned advocate for the University relies on the
communication dated 26th April, 2017 made by the
Ministry of Ayurveda, Yoga & Naturopathy, Unani,
Siddha and Homoeopathy (AYUSH) to all the State
authorities clearly mentioning that admission in
AYUSH UG courses shall be compulsorily through
NEET merit list from the academic year 2018-2019.
10. Reliance has also been placed on the public
notice by the President, Homoeopathy Education
Board dated April 24, 2025 wherein it has been
notified that the National Testing Agency (NTA) is the
designated authority for National Commission for
Homoeopathy to conduct the National Eligibility-cumEntrance Test. The NEET examination conducted by
NTA shall be the uniform test for admission to
undergraduate
and
postgraduate
courses
of
Homoeopathy in all the medical institutions governed
by the Commission. The activities of the counselling
for admission shall be conducted by the respective
counselling authority, i.e., Central Government, State
Government or through their designated authority.
11. The University also relies upon the Notification
dated September 12, 2025 issued by the Additional
Secretary
(AYUSH),
Health
&
Family
Welfare
Department, Government of West Bengal mentioning
that admission of students will not be allowed in the
AYUSH Institutes of the State who are not selected
through NEET examination with immediate effect.
Copy of the notification dated September 12, 2025
was forwarded to all the Boards of the AYUSH
Institutes of the State with a direction to display the
notice in their Institutions’ website immediately and
keep the notice visible until further order.
Copy of
such notice was also to be displayed in the official
website of the West Bengal University of Health
Sciences.
12. Learned
advocate
Commission
for
representing
Homoeopathy
the
relies
National
on
the
information by the President, Medical Assessment
and Rating Board for Homoeopathy dated February
10, 2026 regarding imposition of penalty for failure to
maintain minimum essential standards of education.
13. The information clearly mentions that it has
been observed that colleges are not fully complying
with
the
minimum
essential
standards
which
adversely affect the quality of education. All colleges
have been directed to ensure strict compliance with
the minimum essential standards of education at all
times. Penalty for Non-NEET admission per student
has been proposed at rupees ten lakh.
14. The order passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
on April 29, 2026 in Special Leave to Appeal (C)
No(s).26816/2023
[Rani
Dullaiya
Smriti
Homeopathy Medical College vs. Union of India &
Ors.] has been relied wherein the Court specifically
held that it is difficult for the Court to accept the
submission canvassed on behalf of the petitioners
that
insofar
as
NEET
(UG)
Homoeopathy
is
concerned, there has to be a separate examination.
15. To this the learned advocate for the petitioners
point
out
that
the
Special
Leave
Petition
(C)
No.9815/2026 over the same issue as in Rani
Dullaiya (supra) filed by the West Bengal University of
Health Sciences & Ors. challenging the order dated
February 18, 2026 passed by the Hon’ble Division
Bench of this Court in MAT 2215 of 2025 was heard
analogously but finally stood de-tagged.
16. According to the petitioners, de-tagging the SLP
of the State University implies that the order passed
in Rani Dullaiya (supra) cannot be made applicable in
this case. As long as the SLP remains pending,
interim relief ought to be granted in favour of the
petitioners. Not granting similar relief as in Sourin
Jana (supra) will amount to discrimination. The same
is contrary to Articles 12 and 14 of the Constitution.
17. The petitioners have paid considerable sum of
money for taking admission in the session 20242025. The college assured the petitioners that they
would be able to conclude their course without any
hindrance.
18. It has been argued that the notices and the
notification relied upon by the respondents were all
issued after the admission of the petitioners in the
course. The same ought not to be made applicable
upon the petitioners who took admission in the
session 2024-2025.
19. Upon hearing the submissions made on behalf of
the parties and on perusal of the materials on record,
it appears that specific directions have been passed
by the National Commission for Homoeopathy as well
as the West Bengal University of Health Sciences
directing all the AYUSH Institutes not to admit any
student without undergoing NEET.
20. In the instant case, admittedly, the petitioners
took admission without appearing in NEET.
After
taking admission, they presently pray for registration
of their candidature.
21. The stand of the petitioners that they are not
required to appear in NEET examination conducted
by any other authority but the Commission was not
accepted by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Rani
Dullaiya Smriti Homeopathy Medical College (supra),
22. The challenge before the Hon’ble Supreme Court
was that NEET examination has to be conducted by
the Homoeopathy Commission. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court accepted the submission made on behalf of the
Commission that a uniform NEET will be conducted
for
admission
to
the
undergraduate
course
in
Homoeopathy in all medical institutions governed
under Section 14 of the National Commission for
Homeopathy Act, 2020. The said examination is being
conducted through the designated authority which
includes the NTA. The syllabus for the examination
remains the same irrespective of any branch of
medicine.
23. The Court was pleased not to accept the
submission of the Homoeopathy college that there
has to be a separate examination for NEET UG for
Homoeopathy.
24. Though the Hon’ble Supreme Court was pleased
to de-tag the SLP filed by the West Bengal University
of Health Sciences from the matter of Rani Dullaiya
Smriti Homeopathy Medical College (supra) but the
binding precedent of the direction passed by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the said matter still
remains.
25. The judgment of the Hon’ble Division Bench
relied upon by the petitioners in the matter of Hrithik
Chandra Sarkar (supra) does not come to the aid of
the petitioners as the Hon’ble Division Bench was
merely pleased to remand the writ petition to the
learned Single Judge for deciding the writ petition on
merits.
26. As the Hon’ble Supreme Court has already
decided the issue as of now, this Court is not inclined
to accept any other view in the matter. The same is
particularly for the purpose of maintaining the
minimum essential standard in education.
The
authority has already taken note that the colleges are
not complying with the prescribed minimum essential
standards which is adversely affecting the quality of
education.
27. The college ought not to admit any candidate in
the course who did not clear NEET UG conducted by
the Commission through NTA.
28. The Commission is directed to take penal action
against
the
erring
colleges
who
are
admitting
students upon acceptance of huge amount of course
fee contrary to the provisions of law, the notifications
issued by the Commission and the University and
also contrary to the direction passed by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court.
29. The University is directed to conduct regular
inspections and surprise visits to ascertain as to
whether the colleges are taking steps strictly in terms
of the several notices issued by the Commission or
else the candidates who are being admitted in the
colleges will be the worst sufferers. Stringent action
ought to be taken against any erring college for
misleading the young minds and getting them
admitted in courses which will later not be registered
by the University and the candidates will be left in the
lurch.
30. Learned advocate for the petitioners earnestly
prays for showing sympathy upon the candidates so
that they do not lose their academic year.
31. The Court is of the considered opinion that by
showing sympathy to the candidates it will not be
proper to permit them to pursue the course as their
entry into the course was not in accordance with law.
Showing misplaced sympathy may cause harm to the
society at large when later on the candidates will start
medical practice and try to treat patients.
32. In view of the above, the prayer of the petitioners
cannot be allowed.
33. The writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
34. Parties to act on the basis of the server copy of
this order duly downloaded from the official website
of this Court.
35. Certified server copy of this order, if applied for,
be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all
requisite formalities.
(Amrita Sinha, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review