The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
67. In the circumstances of this case, the Management's preliminary objection is that the industrial dispute referred to is illegal and without merit. For the reasons stated above, we are in agreement with the impugned judgment [Premium Transmission (P) Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 3340] . To keep the ongoing adjudication in line with the principles laid down by this Court, the Labour Court is directed to frame two issues, namely: (i) whether the contracts through which the employment is provided to the contract labour are sham and nominal, and (ii) whether, considering the nature of WRIC No. 40418 of 2026 work discharged by the workmen of the subject Union, the Management is the principal employer of the members of the respondent Union.” (b) The case set up by petitioner was of disengagement from service or termination from service and not a case of retrenchment, therefore, a finding that since petitioner has not worked for 240 days in a calendar year and worked for only 45 days, therefore, no industrial dispute could be referred, is unsustainable. Even if such dispute exist, it would be decided by Labour Court after an industrial dispute is referred.
8. In view of above discussion, impugned order dated 24.08.2026 is set aside and matter is remitted to Conciliation Officer, Jhansi to decide afresh after giving an opportunity to Employer also and for that a fresh notice be issued. Subsequently, preferably within a period of six months fresh order be passed.
9. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of. (Saurabh Shyam Shamshery,J.) October 6, 2026 High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD
WRIT - C No. - 40418 of 2026
Adarsh Arjariya
.....Petitioner(s)
Versus
State Of U.P. And 3 Others
.....Respondent(s)
Counsel for Petitioner(s)
Counsel for Respondent(s)
:
:
Nitesh Kumar, Shailendra
C.S.C.
Court No. - 36
HON'BLE SAURABH SHYAM SHAMSHERY, J.
1. It is the case of petitioner that he was appointed by Respondent-4, i.e.,
M/s M.G.O. Technology Pvt. Ltd. vide an appointed letter dated
06.02.2026 and in pursuance thereof he joined on 09.02.2026 and worked
for more than a month, however, no salary was paid as well as by an
email dated 24.03.2026 his services were discontinued by RespondentEmployer on ground that there were certain discrepancies / mismatch in
the name of petitioner in his documents and in joining letter.
2. In aforesaid circumstances, petitioner files a claim petition under
Section 2A of U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 before Assistant Labour
Commissioner, Jhansi for conciliation and in case the conciliation fails, an
industrial dispute be referred.
3. Sri Shailendra, learned counsel for petitioner submits that a notice was
issued to Employer, i.e., Respondent-4 by Conciliation Officer on
18.05.2026 fixing a date for appearance on 28.05.2026 and according to
him the Employer does not appear. Learned counsel submits that in
aforesaid circumstances Conciliation Officer by impugned order dated
24.08.2026 rejected claim petition and refused to refer any industrial
dispute. Learned counsel refers following part of impugned order:
WRIC No. 40418 of 2026
"पत्रावली का अवलोकन करने से ज्ञात हुआ कि आप द्वारा दिनांक 06.02.2026 से दिनांक
24.03.2026 तक डायरेक्टर, एम० जी० ओ० टेक्नालाजी प्रा० लि०, सी-2398, सी ब्लॉक
इन्दिरा नगर, लखनऊ के अन्तर्गत मात्र 01 माह 15 दिन ही कार्य किया गया है। औद्योगिक
विवाद अधिनियम 1947 की धारा 2 ए के अन्तर्गत विवाद ग्राहय करने हेतु कम से कम 240
दिन की हाजिरी होना अनिवार्य है। चूंकि आप द्वारा उक्त कम्पनी के अन्तर्गत कार्य करने में मात्र
01 माह 15 दिन की हाजिरी होने के कारण उक्त विवाद श्रम न्यायालय, झाँसी के समक्ष
सन्दर्भित किये जाने योग्य नहीं है अतः उक्त विवाद को खारिज करते हुए पत्रावली दाखिल
दफ्तर किये जाने के आदेश पारित किये जाते हैं।"
4. Learned counsel for petitioner refers contents of Section 2A of Act that
it also includes dismissal of an individual workman as well as that
Conciliation Officer cannot decide, whether petitioner falls within the
definition of ‘workman’ or not. In case of any such dispute, appropriate
authority would be the Labour Court after an industrial dispute is referred
since it can be decided only on basis of pleadings and evidence.
5. Learned counsel also submits that it was not a case of retrenchment,
therefore, a reason assigned in impugned order that petitioner was
required to work atleast 240 days in a calendar year to raise any industrial
dispute, cannot be sustained in the present case since it was a case of
disengagement.
6. I have considered aforesaid submissions and considering that impugned
order was passed ex parte, i.e., without hearing Employer, either due to
non-appearance or otherwise, therefore, the Court is of the view that
matter can be decided finally even without issuing notice to Employer,
i.e., Respondent-4, on basis of pleadings and material available on record.
7. After going through the record as well as considering above
submissions, the Court finds that impugned order cannot survive in eyes
of law due to following reasons:
WRIC No. 40418 of 2026
(a) In the given set of circumstances, if there was a dispute, whether
petitioner was a workman or not, appropriate authority to decide it, would
be the Labour Court after an industrial dispute is referred and not the
Conciliation Officer since such dispute has to be decided on basis of
evidence led by both parties including the nature of work of workman
concerned and for that the Court takes note of a recent judgment passed
by Supreme Court in the case of M/s Premium Transmission Private
Limited vs. The State of Maharashtra and others, (2026) 5 SCC 633
wherein purport of Section 10(1) of Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 was
considered in detail and held that even any apprehended dispute can be
referred and only after exchange of pleadings, the issue whether
engagement was purely contractual or otherwise can be decided by
Labour Court. Court finds that it can be a preliminary issue also. For
reference, some paragraphs of M/s Premium Transmission (supra) is
quoted below:“55. Plainly interpreted, an industrial dispute means any “dispute or
difference”
between
employers
and
workmen
connected
with
employment, non-employment, the terms of employment, or conditions of
labour.
56. From Management's perspective, the members of the third respondent
Union are not its workers. The very denial of the status could also be
considered as a dispute in the established facts and circumstances of a
case.
57. The relevant portion of Section 10(1) of the ID Act reads as follows:
“10. Reference of disputes to Boards, Courts or Tribunals.—(1) Where
the appropriate Government is of opinion that any industrial dispute exists
or is apprehended, it may at any time….”
58. Section 10 enables the appropriate Government to refer an industrial
WRIC No. 40418 of 2026
dispute to a Board, to a Labour Court or to a Tribunal, depending upon
the nature of the dispute. The step taken under Section 10 sets in motion a
process for adjudication of a dispute between the parties. The steps
envisaged under Section 12 are known as a conciliatory measure without
actually inviting adjudication between the management and the Union.
Section 12, in terms, does not stipulate that a condition precedent to
invoking its jurisdiction is to first approach the management and receive a
reply, and then knock on the doors of the Conciliation Officer. The
process of reference is administrative in nature and is not tested on the
touchstone of a judicial or quasi-judicial order by a statutory authority or
a court.
xxx
60. A dispute in fact or a dispute in law cannot be exhaustively dealt with
either by examples or through a definition. The dispute is presented in a
variety of dynamic circumstances where one party asserts a right, and
another party denies the right. Similarly, a party affirms the existence of a
fact, and another party disputes its existence. These situations would
attract the simple meaning of a dispute. Similarly, industrial disputes can
have different combinations; namely, between workers and management,
Union and management, and, as in the present case, contract labour and
the Management. In a situation where an unresolved dispute subsists, the
same is resolved through the process of conciliation.
61. The management, in the instant case, objects to the status of workers
and, at the same time, cannot be heard to argue that the status asserted by
them is not adjudicated by the Industrial Court. The inconsistency is that
the preliminary objection is raised to reject the ongoing proceedings in
Reference (IT) No. 1 of 2021, as there is no demand made to the
management beforehand. The Union and the workers complain of unfair
labour practice against the Management, and the remedy for redressal of
both unfair practice and declaration that the contract is a sham is before
the Industrial Court. Therefore, for the Rule of Law to prevail, the
grievances are not wished away without adjudication. Ubi jus ibi
remedium, i.e. where there is a right, there is a remedy in law, is a
WRIC No. 40418 of 2026
principle to be kept in perspective. Through the reference, a forum for
redressal alone is provided to the contract labour. The argument of the
management derives a forum to the Union/workers and hence not
accepted.
62. Further, as per the ratio of SAIL [SAIL v. National Union Waterfront
Workers, (2001) 7 SCC 1] , the contract labour is given the option to
question the contract as a sham and nominal, and pray for appropriate
reliefs. The objection to continuing the industrial dispute under Section 10
is substantial and has been rightly rejected by the High Court.
xxx
64. The power to refer an “apprehended” dispute is the statutory
application of the old adage “a stitch in time saves nine”. It enables the
State to intervene before the industrial peace is shattered. Consequently,
permitting preliminary objections to stall this urgent process negates the
preventive intent of the statute, converting a mechanism of immediate
relief into an engine of delay. The appropriate Government, in its
armchair, while referring an industrial dispute for resolution, keeps in its
perspective industrial peace and prosperity, to enable workers to work out
their just and economic demands and avoid strikes and lockouts. The
administrative decision merely looks at an industrial dispute or an
apprehended industrial dispute. The merit or otherwise of the dispute is
for the adjudicatory body to decide.
xxx
67. In the circumstances of this case, the Management's preliminary
objection is that the industrial dispute referred to is illegal and without
merit. For the reasons stated above, we are in agreement with the
impugned judgment [Premium Transmission (P) Ltd. v. State of
Maharashtra, 2023 SCC OnLine Bom 3340] . To keep the ongoing
adjudication in line with the principles laid down by this Court, the
Labour Court is directed to frame two issues, namely: (i) whether the
contracts through which the employment is provided to the contract
labour are sham and nominal, and (ii) whether, considering the nature of
WRIC No. 40418 of 2026
work discharged by the workmen of the subject Union, the Management
is the principal employer of the members of the respondent Union.”
(b) The case set up by petitioner was of disengagement from service or
termination from service and not a case of retrenchment, therefore, a
finding that since petitioner has not worked for 240 days in a calendar
year and worked for only 45 days, therefore, no industrial dispute could
be referred, is unsustainable. Even if such dispute exist, it would be
decided by Labour Court after an industrial dispute is referred.
8. In view of above discussion, impugned order dated 24.08.2026 is set
aside and matter is remitted to Conciliation Officer, Jhansi to decide
afresh after giving an opportunity to Employer also and for that a fresh
notice be issued. Subsequently, preferably within a period of six months
fresh order be passed.
9. The writ petition is accordingly disposed of.
(Saurabh Shyam Shamshery,J.)
October 6, 2026
AK
High Court of Judicature at Allahabad
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review