Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P. (PIL) No. 4534 of 2021
Achyut Swaroop Mishra, aged about 33 years, son of Late Birendra
Kumar Mishra, Permanent Resident of Gandhinagar East, P.O. & P.S. :
Sadar, District – Hazaribagh, currently residing at Dwarikapuri Road No.
11, Lower Chutia, P.O. & P.S. Chutia. Dist:- Ranchi, Jharkhand.
...
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. The State of Jharkhand.
2. The Deputy Commissioner, Hazaribagh, Post office & Police Station
: Sadar, District – Hazaribagh.
3. The Superintendent of Police, Hazaribagh, Post office & Police
Station : Sadar, District – Hazaribagh.
4. The Municipal Commissioner, Hazaribagh Municipal Corporation,
Post office & Police Station : Sadar, District – Hazaribagh.
…
…
…
...
Respondents
--------CORAM:
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH SHANKAR
--------For the Petitioner:
Party-in-Person
For the State:
Mr Vibhor Mayank, A.C. to A.G.
For Resp. No. 4:
Mr Ranjit Kumar, Advocate
--------Reserved on: 10.09.2026
Pronounced on: 29/09/2026
Per M. S. Sonak, C.J.
1.
Heard the petitioner, who appears in person, and learned counsel for
the respondents.
2.
The present writ petition, instituted in public interest, highlights the
chaotic traffic situation at Hazaribagh and seeks writs, orders and
directions requiring the respondent authorities to formulate and
implement effective measures for traffic regulations and civic
management within a time-bound schedule.
3.
The petitioner has referred to the absence of any traffic-light
monitoring system, CCTV, and other surveillance measures; the lack
of reasonable parking facilities; encroachments on public footpaths;
and several other issues leading to a chaotic traffic situation. The
petitioner has pointed out that the respondents are taking no steps to
redress the situation, and that such sustained inaction on their part
directly infringes upon the fundamental rights guaranteed under the
Constitution.
4.
The petitioner has also cited instances of fatal collisions at the
Barkagaon More and Kargil Chowk, which are crowded traffic
intersections in Hazaribagh. The petitioner has also cited instances
of injuries to pedestrians or those involved in vehicular accidents, on
account of unmanaged traffic. Against this background, the
petitioner has sought several directions, which, according to the
petitioner, need to be issued if the traffic situation in Hazaribagh is
to improve.
5.
This petition was instituted in 2021, and since then a series of orders
have been made by Coordinate Benches and even by this Bench,
mainly to direct the respondents to adopt reasonable steps to
improve the situation.
6.
At the outset, the respondents were in denial mode and chose to
contest the factual assertions made by the petitioner. By order dated
11.07.2024, the Coordinate Bench of this Court appointed Mr
Prashant Pallav, who was then an Advocate practising before this
Court (and was later appointed as learned A.S.G.I.), as an Advocate
Commissioner to inspect the City and submit a comprehensive
report. Mr Pallav submitted his comprehensive report, which was
duly taken on record.
7.
Mr Pallav’s report, by and large, confirms the chaotic traffic
situation at Hazaribagh. The report also noted the conspicuous
absence of traffic personnel at several key intersections and
junctions, and the lack of automatic traffic signals. The report also
noted that although CCTVs were installed in some places, they were
largely non-functional. The report also referred to widespread
haphazard parking and a lackadaisical attitude towards enforcing
traffic rules, such as wearing helmets and seatbelts. The report also
referred to a severe deficit of police and traffic personnel for
maintaining orderly traffic at Hazaribagh.
8.
The Coordinate Benches of this Court directed the respondents to
respond to Mr Pallav’s report. The respondents accordingly filed
affidavits assuring the Court that remedial measures would be taken.
However, the remedial measures taken have addressed only some of
the aspects highlighted in this petition.
9.
The Police authorities and the Municipal authorities, who are
impleaded as respondents in this petition, tried, through their
affidavits, to pass the blame for this chaotic traffic situation to each
other. For example, State Administration officials, such as the
Deputy Commissioner and the Superintendent of Police, asserted
that parking issues are to be handled by the Hazaribagh Municipal
Corporation officials. The Corporation officials complained about a
lack of effective assistance from the police. Thus, whilst the chaotic
traffic situation at Hazaribagh could not be denied, there was a
blame game between various officials and agencies, rendering the
remedies a casualty.
10. The Coordinate Benches of this Court were constrained to issue
further orders inter alia for coordination between the State
Administration and the Municipal authorities at Hazaribagh. Under
Court orders, meetings were directed to be held involving all
stakeholders so that some reasonable solutions could be found to the
chaotic traffic situation, which had become not only unbearable but
was resulting in hazards to commuters and pedestrians alike.
11. Pursuant to the meetings of the stakeholders and orders made by this
Court from time to time, the Municipal Corporation placed on record
an action plan dated 25.08.2025 along with a proposal for a traffic
monitoring system for which the Corporation proposed to expend an
amount of Rs. 38.64 Crores (approximately). The Corporation
submitted that it had submitted the proposal to the Urban
Development and Housing Department of the Government of
Jharkhand for financial sanction.
12. Again, there was no clarity about sanctions, and because the
Coordinate Bench of this Court felt that the amount of Rs. 38.64
Crores was disproportionately high, no steps were taken to remedy
the situation at Hazaribagh. Finally, this Court issued several
directions to the respondents, inter alia, concerning the clearance of
encroachments upon footpaths and parking spaces, the establishment
of traffic kiosks, and the conduct of traffic awareness programmes.
Directions were also issued to ensure the functioning of CCTV and
other surveillance cameras, and to enforce motor-vehicle mandates
concerning helmets, seat-belts, tilted glass, illegal horns, etc. This
Court, vide order dated 07.10.2025, noted that there was no serious
compliance with most of the directions issued by the Court. Similar
notings were made in orders dated 09.01.2026 and 16.02.2026,
given that the respondents were filing piecemeal affidavits.
13. Upon this Court taking cognisance of non-compliances and directing
the respondents to file further affidavits showing the status of
compliance, the situation marginally improved. The affidavits
submitted by the Police Administration demonstrate a considerable
increase in the deployment of police/traffic control personnel and in
statutory enforcement. Earlier, the strength of police/traffic
personnel was only 35, and it was now increased to 212, as declared
in the supplementary counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the Police
Administration on 24.06.2025.
14. A supplementary affidavit dated 26.02.2026, filed by the Police
authorities, disclosed the deployment of 20 additional personnel
across Kallu Chowk, Pagoda Chowk, Indrapuri Chowk, and Jhanda
Chowk, together with the operationalisation of a dedicated Traffic
Police Station at District Chowk and a post at Panch Mandir Chowk.
The affidavit also disclosed that fines amounting to Rs. 42,26,200/were collected for unauthorised parking of vehicles. The final
affidavit of 26.02.206 referred to a cumulative realisation of Rs.
10,87,22,661/- for violations relating to non-wearing of helmets,
seat-belts, or driving vehicles with tinted glasses or in a rash and
negligent manner.
15. The above figures, with records of Inter Departmental Coordination
Committees held on 14.03.2024, 04.04.2024, 27.06.2024 and
19.01.2026, demonstrate that the Police and Police Stations’
responses evolved from mere paper denial to active enforcement
under judicial oversight.
16. Insofar as the Municipal Corporation is concerned, the initial
financial proposal for Rs. 38.64 Crores was abandoned. Following a
fresh tender process, an agreement was entered into on 19.08.2026
with M/s. Keyhole Design Private Limited for the supply,
installation, testing, and trial run of the Automated Traffic Light
Management System. The contract was valued at Rs. 2.68 Crores or
thereabouts. The Court was informed that the work is in progress.
Although no specific date has been indicated for its completion, we
direct its completion within a maximum of six months from today.
In fact, it is expected that a trial run will be carried out within four
months from today.
17. The Corporation reported that an Anti-Encroachment Task Force
was constituted vide Memo No. 53 dated 17.01.2026 and this Task
Force cleared the Trimurti Chowk, relocated vendors from Kalibari
Chowk and initiated a survey near Sadar Hospital for designating
vending zones under the provisions of the Street Vendors (Protection
of Livelihood and Regulation of Street Vending) Act, 2014.
18. Further, Memos bearing Nos. 2997 and 2998, dated 10.09.2025,
were also issued by the Municipal Corporation to clear the 14
designated parking sites and 03 parking sites, in coordination with
the District Police and the Regional Transport officials. The affidavit
dated 08.09.2026, sworn by the Deputy Commissioner, records a
high-level meeting convened on 25.08.2026 regarding the execution
of the traffic light contract and the relocation of the Old Bus Stand.
The Circle Officer has been directed to identify suitable land along
the Bye Pass Road for the construction of a Bus Terminal outside
the City limits.
19. While not disputing the issuance of the above orders, the petitioner
submitted that there is laxity in implementation and that the position
on site has not changed substantially. From the affidavits and other
material filed before us, we cannot say that the respondents have
failed to take any remedial steps. However, we agree with the
petitioner that much more needs to be done to secure
implementation and monitoring.
20. Ultimately, the respondents must remain aware that the right to a
clean, dignified and reasonably safe urban life is an integral facet of
the right to life guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Further, Article 19(1)(d) and other rights enshrined in Article 19
protect the freedom of movement of every citizen, whether
navigating the city as a pedestrian, motorist or commuter. Besides,
the respondents also cannot afford to ignore the statutory framework
of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and the provisions of the
Municipal Corporation Act, which govern the functioning of the
Corporations. This constitutional and statutory framework obliges
the respondents to take effective steps to redress such issues of
chaotic traffic management, which result in the loss of valuable lives
among people from the area.
21. The respondents also cannot ignore the provisions of the Noise
Pollution (Regulation and Control) Rules, 2000, and the Street
Vendors (Protection of Livelihood and Regulation of Street
Vending) Act, 2014. While the former Rules address the menace of
noise pollution, the latter addresses a very significant and sensitive
aspect of the rights of street vendors. The respondents have to be
alive to such legislation and the duties that such legislation has cast
upon them to ensure that the chaotic traffic management situation
improves.
22. By citing financial stringency, administrative inconvenience and
lack of coordination among several governmental authorities, the
above-referred duties cannot be avoided or abdicated. In Municipal
Council, Ratlam v. Vardhichand, AIR 1980 SC 1622, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court has rejected the plea of lack of finances in the matter
of discharge of public duties related to civil safety and sanitation.
23. In Ahmedabad Municipal Corporation v. Nawab Khan Gulab
Khan, (1997) 11 SCC 121, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that
pavements constitute essential infrastructure enabling ordinary
citizens to navigate public spaces with reasonable safety, and this
facility cannot be negated by private occupation.
24. In Sudhir Madan v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi, (2009) 17
SCC 597, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that public streets and
footpaths are intended for the general public and cannot be
monopolised by unauthorised squatters.
25. In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India, (2019) 10 SCC 614, the Hon’ble
Supreme Court held that parking on footpaths is strictly prohibited.
Recently, in Maniyar Iliyaz @ Shaik Riyaz v. P. Ayyappan, 2026
INSC 647, the Hon’ble Supreme Court reaffirmed that the right to
walk on unencroached, demarcated footpaths is integral to the
fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 19(1)(d) and 21 of the
Constitution, creating a corresponding constitutional duty upon
municipal bodies to construct, protect, and maintain pedestrian
infrastructure.
26. The statutory regime, as well as the decisions on the subject, no
longer favours the complete ouster of street vendors. The objective
should be to allow street vending to harmoniously coexist with
motorable carriageways and walkable footpaths. The respondents
must accordingly formulate policies and take steps in this regard.
27. The petitioner has highlighted specific situations. Counter-affidavits
have been filed addressing the petitioner’s concerns regarding those
situations. The petitioner’s complaint is now about a lack of
implementation. The respondents must remember that merely giving
paper assurances is not sufficient. Such assurances have to translate
into action, and that action must be sustained.
28. Therefore, after perusing the entire material placed before us, we
propose to issue certain directions to the respondents. Such
directions are in addition to, and not in derogation of, the statutory
duties that the respondents-authorities are tasked with under the law.
The Deputy Commissioner, the Superintendent of Police and the
Municipal Commissioner must work in tandem and shall be held
personally responsible for due compliance.
29. Accordingly, based upon the material on record, which includes the
affidavits filed on behalf of the respondents and the orders made by
this Court from time to time, we dispose of this writ petition by
issuing the following directions: (i)
The
Municipal
Commissioner,
Hazaribagh
Municipal
Corporation, shall ensure that all works under the agreement
dated 19.08.2026 with M/s. Keyhole Design Private Limited
for the supply, installation, testing, and trial run of the
Automated Traffic Light Management System are completed,
and the system is put to operational trial, within four months
from today.
(ii)
The trial shall cover at least the twenty major intersections
identified on record: Hazaribagh District Court Chowk (near
Jain Petrol Pump), Korrah Chowk, Babugaon Chowk,
Matwari Chowk, St. Columba’s College More, Barkagaon
More (near Kargil Petrol Pump), Bharat Mata Chowk, PTC
Chowk, DVC Chowk (near Upkar Hotel), District More
Chowk (near Arogyam Hospital), Circuit House Chowk,
Indrapuri Chowk, Jhanda Chowk, Old Bus Stand Chowk,
New Bus Stand Chowk, Bansilal Chowk, Sardar Chowk,
Carmel School Chowk, Kallu Chowk and Panch Mandir
Chowk.
(iii)
For any intersection outside the contracted scope, the
Municipal Commissioner shall state in the compliance
affidavit whether signalisation is proposed, with cost and
timeline, or the engineering reason why it is not required.
(iv)
A joint completion-and-trial certificate, signed by the
Municipal Commissioner, the Superintendent of Police and
the Executive Engineer of the Corporation, shall be appended
to the compliance affidavit under clause (XVI).
(v)
Zebra markings and statutory signage at the signalised
junctions shall form part of the certificate.
(vi)
A Three-Member Monitoring and Maintenance Team; an
Officer of the Corporation not below Assistant Engineer, a
Traffic Police Officer not below the rank of Inspector, and a
representative of the contractor, shall be constituted within
three weeks. It shall maintain a daily downtime log. Any
signal dark or stuck beyond forty-eight hours shall be restored
within the next forty-eight hours, failing which the reasons
shall be reported in the compliance affidavit.
(vii) Within two months, the Deputy Commissioner and the
Superintendent of Police shall file a joint inventory of all
CCTV cameras installed since 2017, unit-wise, stating
functionality, storage location, and AMC status. Nonfunctional cameras shall be repaired or replaced within four
months. Junction and ANPR cameras under the 2026 contract
shall be integrated with the Police Control Room.
(viii) The Superintendent of Police shall file a peak-hour
deployment chart (08:00–11:00 and 16:00–20:00 hours on
working days) for each of the twenty intersections, naming the
officer accountable for each junction.
(ix)
Traffic personnel shall complete a training programme of not
less than three days within three months, in coordination with
the District Legal Services Authority, Hazaribagh.
(x)
The prohibition on entry of heavy and commercial goods
vehicles into the notified municipal limits between 08:00 a.m.
and 08:00 p.m., save for essential services, shall be enforced
as a single rule. The Corporation shall not levy any entry fee
not sanctioned by law. The Superintendent of Police and the
Municipal Commissioner shall, within four weeks, file a joint
one-page order setting out the rule with a sketch of the
notified cordon. Any collection official permitting a breach
should be made to face departmental action.
(xi)
The Municipal Commissioner shall, within three months: (a)
file an authenticated map of designated and free parking
spaces with date-stamped photographs; (b) keep those spaces
free of vending and unauthorised stands; and (c) issue notices
under the Jharkhand Municipal Act, 2012 and development
control norms to establishments on the PTC Chowk–Korrah
Chowk stretch lacking off-street parking, and report the action
taken.
(xii) The Deputy Commissioner and the Municipal Commissioner
shall, within four months, complete the survey and
notification of vending and non-vending zones under the
Street Vendors Act, 2014, including a zone near Sadar
Hospital, if feasible.
(xiii) Encroachments on footpaths, junctions, zebra crossings and
carriageways shall be removed in accordance with the law.
Re-occupation after clearance shall be proceeded against
under Section 606 of the Jharkhand Municipal Act, 2012.
(xiv) Silence zones of not less than one hundred metres shall,
within two months, be notified under the Noise Pollution
Rules, 2000 around the Civil Court complex, major hospitals
including Sadar and Arogyam, and educational institutions
including St. Columba’s College and Carmel School. The
Superintendent of Police shall enforce and report monthly on
pressure horns and unauthorised amplification.
(xv) The Deputy Commissioner shall, within four months, place on
record the status of land for a bus terminal on the bypass and
of the old bus stand’s relocation, together with a routing plan
for autos and e-rickshaws.
(xvi) The Deputy Commissioner, the Superintendent of Police and
the Municipal Commissioner shall each file a personal
compliance affidavit within four months, covering clauses (i)
to (xv). The affidavits shall not be sworn by subordinate
officers.
(xvii) Copies of the personal affidavits shall be served on the
petitioner within one week of filing.
30. Once again, we clarify that the above directions are in addition to the
statutory compliances, which the respondents cannot avoid. In fact,
the respondents must comply with all the statutory directives and
take to task those found breaching the law and the rules relating to
traffic safety and management.
31. The petition is disposed of in the above terms, without any order for
costs.
32. Pending IAs, if any, will not survive and are disposed of.
33. We appreciate the efforts of the petitioner and the learned counsel
for the respondents. None of the parties treated this matter as
adversarial. We only hope that compliance continues and the
situation is not allowed to deteriorate.
34. Let a copy of this judgment be transmitted to the parties concerned,
including the Chairperson, DLSA, Hazaribagh, for necessary
compliances.
(M. S. Sonak, C.J.)
(Rajesh Shankar, J.)
September 29, 2026
A.F.R.
Manoj/Cp.2/Uploaded on 29.09.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review