Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
FORM NO. J (2)
In the High Court at Calcutta
Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction
Appellate Side
Present:
THE HON’BLE JUSTICE REETOBROTO KUMAR MITRA
WPA/25540/2026
DR. ABIR KUMAR PAL
Vs.
THE WEST BENGAL POWER DEVELOPMENT
CORPORATION LIMITED & ORS.
For the Petitioner
:
Mr. Samim Ahammed, Advocate
Mr. Md. Nasirul Haque, Advocate
Ms. Zoya Eram, Advocate
For the State
:
Ms. Piush Chaturvedi, Sr. Advocate
Mr. Anujit Mookerjee, Advocate
For Respondent 1-5
:
Mr. R. De, Advocate
Mr. B. Banerjee, Advocate
Mr. A.A. Bose, Advocate
Heard on
:
September 23, 2026.
Judgment on
:
September 25, 2026.
THE COURT:
1.
The grievance of the writ petitioner is that the exercise of his
option seeking revocation of his resignation has not been
accepted.
nandy
Page 1
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
2.
The facts of this case are fairly simple and admitted. A brief
enumeration thereof will render the deliberation more
meaningful.
3.
The petitioner was employed in the service of Respondent
No. 1 as a Senior Medical Officer at the Medical Unit,
Sagardighi Thermal Power Project (hereinafter referred to as
the Corporation).
4.
Owing to a marital discord with his now estranged wife,
which arose sometime in 2022, the petitioner tendered his
resignation on October 25, 2025, effective from February 4,
2026. In terms of prevalent rules, the resignation was made
effective from February 4, 2026, upon completion of the
required three months' notice, in compliance with Clause
5(b) of his letter of appointment dated November 10, 2016.
5.
The respondent Corporation accepted the resignation
tendered by the petitioner “provisionally” on December 31,
2025.
6.
In the interregnum between the provisional acceptance of the
resignation and February 4, 2026, being the effective date of
resignation, the petitioner received salaries for the months of
October to December 2025, as well as for January and part of
February 2026. On February 9, 2026, February 12, 2026
March 10, 2026 all after the resignation had been finally
effected
and
completed,
the
petitioner
had
made
representations inter alia seeking to recall and/or revoke his
resignation.
The
said
request
was
ignored
by
the
Page 2
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
Corporation. On March 11, 2026, the release order as well as
the retirement benefits of the petitioner was released.
7.
On July 16, 2026, the petitioner finally obtained his divorce
from his wife.
8.
After the representations of February 9, 2026, February 12,
2026, and March 10, 2026, were rejected by the authorities
by their order of March 23, 2026, fresh representations on the
exact lines as the earlier ones were made successively in the
months of May, June, and July. These representations were
also rejected by a reasoned order of August 14, 2026.
9.
The petitioner is aggrieved that his prayer for revocation of
his resignation was rejected by the respondent Corporation
on multiple occasion. Hence, the present writ petition.
10.
Mr. Shamim Ahammed, learned advocate appearing for the
petitioner, has made the following submissions:i.
The resignation was given on October 25, 2025. In spite
thereof, he received payment for the month of October to
December 2025.
ii.
The resignation was accepted only provisionally on December
31, 2025, and there was no final acceptance of such
resignation.
iii.
This is evident from the fact that the release order of the
petitioner was issued by the Corporation only on March 11,
2026, which necessarily implies that the petitioner was still in
service on the date of the first representation on February 9,
2026.
Page 3
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
iv.
Thus, his representation of February 9, 2026, February 12,
2026, March 10, 2026 ought to have been allowed, as the
resignation was effected on March 11, 2026. Therefore, the
petitioner's prayer for revocation of his resignation was
justified and should have been considered in a more positive
manner.
v.
In fact, in rejecting the representations, the authority has
placed reliance on Rule 34A of the West Bengal Service Rules
Part I which stipulates that a person continues in service if he,
withdraws the letter before the date from which the
resignation is to take effect. The resignation becomes
inoperative. According to Mr. Ahmad, this effective date is
March 11, 2026, and not any date prior thereto.
vi.
Therefore, the representations of the petitioner seeking
revocation of his resignation has been wrongfully and wrongly
rejected and should be set aside, thereby permitting the
petitioner to continue in service.
vii. The petitioner submits that certain other persons, Mohadev
Ganguly, Papia Mohinder, and Debolina Nath, were all
permitted to withdraw their resignation and resume service.
Hence, there is no reason as to why the petitioner should not
be accordingly allowed to withdraw his resignation and
resume service. Discriminatory treatment should not be
permitted as against the petitioner.
11.
Mr. De, learned Senior Advocate appearing for the
respondent
Corporation,
has
made
the
following
submissions:-
Page 4
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
i.
The Corporation is a State under Article 12 and is bound by its
own rules and regulations and the West Bengal Service Rules to
the extent that they have been adopted and incorporated into
the service rules and regulations of the Corporation.
ii.
Regulation 4 of the (WBSEDCL) Employees' Service Regulations
is clear and unequivocal and reflects adoption and reliance on
Rule 34A of the West Bengal Service Rules.
iii.
The effective date of resignation has been specified ; once one
juxtaposes these service rules, the regulations along with the
specifics in the letter of appointment of the petitioner.
iv.
The three months' notice has been specifically incorporated in
Clause 5B of the letter of appointment of the petitioner issued by
the Corporation.
v.
An employee is permitted to resign upon giving such three
months' notice.
vi.
This notice period has been specified by the petitioner himself in
the letter of resignation dated October 25, 2025, thereby fixing
the date of resignation to be February 4, 2026, which must
necessarily be construed as the effective date of resignation of
the petitioner.
vii. The
acceptance
of
the
petitioner's
resignation
by
the
Corporation on December 31, 2025 has to be a provisional
acceptance
as
a
final
acceptance
would
have
twofold
consequences:a) First, the authorities would be curtailing the notice period of
three months if the same was accepted finally on December
31, 2025.
b) Second, any final acceptance on December 31, 2025, would
entail consequential financial benefits to the petitioner,
Page 5
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
including pension, leave salary, gratuity, provident fund, etc.
This could not be done prior to February 4, 2026, being the
effective date of resignation.
viii. It is for this purpose that the resignation was accepted
provisionally, prior to its effective date.
ix. The actions of March 11, 2026 are merely the consequence of
resignation, resulting in ministerial acts of issuance of the
releasing order and the financial benefits thereof.
x. The effective date of resignation being February 4, 2026, the
same takes effect without any further act of commission or
omission on behalf of any of the parties. Had the representations
been made at any time prior to February 4, 2026, the petitioner
could have still argued that he had a right to withdraw as that
would have been prior to the date from which the resignation is
to take effect, which is February 4, 2026.
xi. Having taken effect on February 4, 2026, the resignation of the
petitioner because irrevocable and operative. Thus, there is no
question of revocation of the same.
xii. He has placed reliance on a decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India reported in (2024) 13 SCC 598, (Dr. Suman v.
Marwadi Sammelan through its Secretary & Ors), in aid of his
argument that a resignation can be withdrawn at any time before
it becomes effective. However, upon the arrival of the effective
date, such resignation becomes complete and operative and
there is no right bestowed on the incumbent officer to rescind,
revoke or withdraw such resignation.
xiii.Thus, the authorities in no uncertain terms and with sufficient
clarity rejected the representations of the petitioner seeking
revocation of his resignation dated February 9, 2026.
Page 6
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
12.
I have heard the learned advocates for the parties and
considered the documents and decisions relied upon by
them.
13.
It is of no import as to why the petitioner tendered the
resignation. The submission on behalf of the petitioner that
the same was done on account of the marital discord of the
petitioner, which stood resolved subsequently, is of no value
to the instant case.
14.
The letter of resignation of October 25, 2025 issued by the
petitioner is a prospective resignation, which is to take place
on a future date which has been defined as the “effective
date”. It is this effective date which is of great relevance.
Unless the resignation letter is rejected , it becomes final,
complete and becomes operative on the effective date itself.
15.
In this case, it is indisputable that Clause 5B in the letter of
appointment stipulates a three months' notice period for any
incumbent officer who wishes to tender his resignation.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner issued a letter of resignation
thereby stipulating a timeline of three months corresponding
to the three months' notice which is to be given. Thus, the
petitioner himself stipulated February 4, 2026 as the effective
date when his resignation would become operative and
complete.
16.
The respondent Corporation by its letter of December 31,
2025 accepted the resignation provisionally. Thus, even if the
petitioner wished to revoke his resignation, it could have
Page 7
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
been done anytime within three months, prior to the effective
date of the resignation. Mere provisional acceptance would
not curtail the three months' notice period. Likewise, mere
provisional acceptance does not also curtail the right of the
petitioner to seek revocation of his resignation before the
effective date of resignation on February 4, 2026.
17.
However, once the timeline crosses the effective date, the
said resignation does not remain prospective and indeed
assumes finality and irrevocability and cannot be rescinded
or revoked.
18.
The decision of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Dr.
Mrs. Suman (supra) is absolutely clear and lays down this
very proposition by which this Court is bound.
19.
The argument of the petitioner that the provisional
acceptance of the resignation on December 31, 2025 left
room for him to seek revocation thereof is not in dispute, as
he could indeed withdraw the resignation even after the
provisional acceptance, but only until the effective date, i.e.,
February 4, 2026. The mere issuance of the release order on
March 11, 2026 and payment of the petitioner's retirement
benefits on the very same date, which were accepted by the
petitioner without any prejudice or demur, does not mean or
imply, nor can it be construed in any manner to imply, that
the acceptance of the resignation of the petitioner was finally
effected on March 11, 2026.
20.
Somewhere in the milieu of these facts, the petitioner was
also aware that the resignation tendered by him had become
Page 8
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
effective. It is upon such realization, the petitioner prayed for
revocation of the resignation.
21.
The subsequent representations after the divorce of the
petitioner on July 16, 2026, are on similar lines, that the
petitioner ought to have been permitted to resume service
upon revocation of his resignation, made by successive
representations, all of which are, however, after the effective
date of resignation on February 4, 2026.
22.
The petitioner's submission that other officers/employees of
the Corporation were permitted to withdraw their resignation
and resume service is bald and without material particulars,
since the effective date of resignation of these persons has
not been disclosed in the petition nor argued. No assertion
with any particular, has been made that these persons had
withdrawn or were permitted to withdraw their resignation
after the effective date of their resignation. Therefore, there
is no allegation or even an insinuation that these persons,
referred to by the petitioner in paragraph 35 of the petition,
were permitted to resume service after revocation of their
resignation post the effective date of resignation. Such a
fleeting
submission,
unsupported
by
documents
and
pleadings, is best ignored.
23.
The acceptance of the resignation was on February 4, 2026
and the consequential benefits of such resignation including
the financial benefits were meted out on March 11, 2026
along with the release order. The release order coming at a
later date than the effective date of resignation cannot clothe
Page 9
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
the petitioner with an additional right to challenge such
resignation as if the said resignation had not taken effect on
February 4, 2026 but on March 11, 2026.
24.
In the orders impugned, dated March 23, 2026 and August
14, 2026, the respondent Corporation took into consideration
all facts and the prevalent rules and regulations and held that
since the petitioner did not withdraw the letter of resignation
prior to February 4, 2026, and since all service benefits of the
petitioner had been released by the Corporation, the
petitioner had no vested right to seek revocation of his
resignation.
25.
In view of the afore-stated discussions and findings, the
following findings are unavoidable:
i.
The petitioner tendered his resignation letter on October 25,
2025 upon due compliance with all regulations and the three
months' notice period to be effective from February 4, 2026.
ii.
This was accepted provisionally on December 31, 2025.
iii.
The resignation took effect on February 4, 2026 assuming a
complete, operative and irrevocable character.
iv.
The release order and the benefits pursuant to the resignation
were issued on March 11, 2026 based on the resignation of
February 4, 2026.
v.
Once the resignation became final, operative and complete
and thereby irrevocable, the representations subsequent
thereto were no value.
vi.
There is no vested right to exercise an option and seek
withdrawal, once the resignation has taken effect and has
become operational and irrevocable on the effective date.
Page 10
[WPA/25540/2026 – DISMISSED]
vii. Thus, the request for revocation of the resignation letter made
by the petitioner has been rightly rejected.
26.
In view of the afore-stated facts and circumstances, I do not
find any reason to interfere with the orders of the respondent
Corporation dated March 23, 2026 and August 14, 2026
rejecting the revocation of the resignation.
27.
Accordingly, the writ petition fails and is hereby dismissed.
(Reetobroto Kumar Mitra, J.)
Page 11
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review