Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:1422
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 234 of 2026
-----Abhishek Munda, aged about 23 years, son of Late Sukul Munda,
resident of Gram Chama, P.O. Bukru, P.S Kanke, District Ranchi,
Jharkhand.
… … Petitioner(s)
Versus
1.
The State of Jharkhand, through Secretary, Department of
Health, Medical Education & Family Welfare, having its office
at Project Building, Dhurwa, P.O. & P.S. Dhurwa, District
Ranchi.
2.
Deputy Commissioner, Ranchi, having its office at Kutchery
Road, P.O. G.P.O., P.S. Kotwali, District Ranchi.
3.
Civil Surgeon cum Chief Medical Officer, Ranchi, having its
office at Sadar Hospital Campus, Puruliya Road, P.O. G.P.O.,
P.S. Kotwali, District Ranchi.
4.
Medical Officer (In-Charge), Community Health Center,
Kanke, having its office at Kanke, P.O. & P.S. Kanke, District
Ranchi.
… … Respondent(s)
-----CORAM : SRI ANANDA SEN, J.
-----For the Petitioner(s)
:
Ms. Geeta Kumary, Advocate
Mr. Vipul Poddar, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Ayush Deb, AC to GP-VI
-----02/ 20
th
January, 2026
1.
Heard the parties.
2.
The claim for compassionate appointment of the
petitioner was rejected on the ground that the application was filed
beyond five years.
3.
The compassionate appointment is not a right. Further,
the scheme of compassionate appointment has to be strictly
followed. The grant of compassionate appointment cannot be
deferred for a long period of time. There cannot be reservation of
vacancy till such time when the applicant became major.
4.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of “Canara
Bank Vs. AjithKumar G.K.”, reported in 2025 SCC Online SC
290 at paragraph No.11 of its judgment carved out the settled
principles for grant of compassionate appointment which is here
under:1
2026:JHHC:1422
“11. Decisions of this Court on the contours of appointment
on compassionate ground are legion and it would be apt for
us to consider certain well-settled principles, which have
crystallized through precedents into a rule of law. They are
(not in sequential but contextual order):
a) Appointment on compassionate ground, which is offered
on humanitarian grounds, is an exception to the rule of
equality in the matter of public employment [see General
Manager, State Bank of India v. Anju Jain14]. (2008) 8 SCC
b) Compassionate appointment cannot be made in the
absence of rules or instructions [see Haryana State
Electricity Board v. Krishna Devi15]. (2002) 10 SCC 246
c) Compassionate appointment is ordinarily offered in two
contingencies carved out as exceptions to the general rule,
viz. to meet the sudden crisis occurring in a family either on
account of death or of medical invalidation of the
breadwinner while in service [see V. Sivamurthy v. Union of
India16]. (2008) 13 SCC 730
d) The whole object of granting compassionate employment
by an employer being intended to enable the family
members of a deceased or an incapacitated employee to tide
over the sudden financial crisis, appointments on
compassionate ground should be made immediately to
redeem the family in distress [see Sushma Gosain v. Union of
India17]. (1989) 4 SCC 468
e) Since rules relating to compassionate appointment permit
a side-door entry, the same have to be given strict
interpretation [see Uttaranchal Jal Sansthan v. Laxmi
Devi18]. (2009) 11 SCC 453
f) Compassionate appointment is a concession and not a
right and the criteria laid down in the Rules must be satisfied
by all aspirants [see SAIL v. Madhusudan Das19]. (2008) 15
SCC 560
g) None can claim compassionate appointment by way of
inheritance [see State of Chattisgarh v. Dhirjo Kumar
Sengar20]. (2009) 13 SCC 600
h) Appointment based solely on descent is inimical to our
constitutional scheme, and being an exception, the scheme
has to be strictly construed and confined only to the purpose
it seeks to achieve [see Bhawani Prasad Sonkar v. Union of
India21]. (2011) 4 SCC 209
i) None can claim compassionate appointment, on the
occurrence of death/medical incapacitation of the
concerned employee (the sole bread earner of the family), as
if it were a vested right, and any appointment without
considering the financial condition of the family of the
deceased is legally impermissible [see Union of
India v. Amrita Sinha22]. (2021) 20 SCC 695
2026:JHHC:1422
j) An application for compassionate appointment has to be
made immediately upon death/incapacitation and in any
case within a reasonable period thereof or else a
presumption could be drawn that the family of the
deceased/incapacitated employee is not in immediate need
of financial assistance. Such appointment not being a vested
right, the right to apply cannot be exercised at any time in
future and it cannot be offered whatever the lapse of time
and after the crisis is over [see Eastern Coalfields Ltd. v. Anil
Badyakar23]. (2009) 13 SCC 112
k) The object of compassionate employment is not to give a
member of a family of the deceased employee a post much
less a post for post held by the deceased. Offering
compassionate employment as a matter of course
irrespective of the financial condition of the family of the
deceased and making compassionate appointments in posts
above Class III and IV is legally impermissible [see Umesh
Kumar Nagpal v. State of Haryana24]. (1994) 4 SCC 138
l) Indigence of the dependents of the deceased employee is
the first precondition to bring the case under the scheme of
compassionate appointment. If the element of indigence
and the need to provide immediate assistance for relief from
financial destitution is taken away from compassionate
appointment, it would turn out to be a reservation in favour
of the dependents of the employee who died while in service
which would directly be in conflict with the ideal of equality
guaranteed
under
Articles 14 and 16 of
the Constitution [see Union of India v. B. Kishore25]. (1994) 4
SCC 138
m) The idea of compassionate appointment is not to provide
for endless compassion [see I.G. (Karmik) v. Prahalad Mani
Tripathi26]. (1994) 4 SCC 138
n) Satisfaction that the family members have been facing
financial distress and that an appointment on
compassionate ground may assist them to tide over such
distress is not enough; the dependent must fulfil the
eligibility criteria for such appointment [see State of
Gujarat v. Arvindkumar T. Tiwari27]. (2012) 9 SCC 545
o) There cannot be reservation of a vacancy till such time as
the applicant becomes a major after a number of years,
unless there are some specific provisions [see Sanjay
Kumar v. State of Bihar28]. (2000) 7 SCC 192
p) Grant of family pension or payment of terminal benefits
cannot be treated as substitute for providing employment
assistance. Also, it is only in rare cases and that too if
provided by the scheme for compassionate appointment and
not otherwise, that a dependent who was a minor on the
date of death/incapacitation, can be considered for
appointment upon attaining majority [see Canara
2026:JHHC:1422
Bank (supra)]. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 290
q) An appointment on compassionate ground made many
years after the death/incapacitation of the employee or
without due consideration of the financial resources
available to the dependent of the deceased/incapacitated
employee would be directly in conflict with
Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution [see National Institute
of Technology v. Niraj Kumar Singh29]. (2007) 2 SCC 481
r) Dependents if gainfully employed cannot be considered
[see Haryana Public Service Commission v. Harinder
Singh30]. (2007) 2 SCC 481
s) The retiral benefits received by the heirs of the deceased
employee are to be taken into consideration to determine if
the family of the deceased is left in penury. The court cannot
dilute the criterion of penury to one of “not very well-to-do”.
[see General Manager (D and PB) v. Kunti Tiwary31]. (2004)
7 SCC 271
t) Financial condition of the family of the deceased
employee, allegedly in distress or penury, has to be
evaluated or else the object of the scheme would stand
defeated inasmuch as in such an eventuality, any and every
dependent of an employee dying-in-harness would claim
employment as if public employment is heritable [see Union
of India v. Shashank Goswami32, (2012) 11 SCC 307 Union
Bank of India v. M. T. Latheesh33, (2006) 7 SCC 350National
Hydroelectric Power Corporation v. Nank Chand34 (2004) 12
SCC 487and Punjab National Bank v. Ashwini Kumar
Taneja35]. (2004) 7 SCC 265
u) The terminal benefits, investments, monthly family
income including the family pension and income of family
from other sources, viz. agricultural land were rightly taken
into consideration by the authority to decide whether the
family is living in penury. [see Somvir Singh (supra)].
v) The benefits received by widow of deceased employee
under Family Benefit Scheme assuring monthly payment
cannot stand in her way for compassionate appointment.
Family Benefit Scheme cannot be equated with benefits of
compassionate appointment. [see Balbir Kaur v. SAIL36]
(2004) 7 SCC 265
w) The fixation of an income slab is, in fact, a measure which
dilutes the element of arbitrariness. While, undoubtedly, the
facts of each individual case have to be borne in mind in
taking a decision, the fixation of an income slab subserves
the purpose of bringing objectivity and uniformity in the
process of decision making. [see State of H.P. v. Shashi
Kumar37]. (2019) 3 SCC 653
x) Courts cannot confer benediction impelled by sympathetic
consideration [see Life Insurance Corporation of
India v. Asha Ramchandra Ambekar38]. (1994) 2 SCC 718
2026:JHHC:1422
y) Courts cannot allow compassionate appointment dehors
the statutory regulations/instructions. Hardship of the
candidate does not entitle him to appointment dehors such
regulations/instructions [see SBI v. Jaspal Kaur39]. (2007) 9
SCC 571
z) An employer cannot be compelled to make an
appointment on compassionate ground contrary to its policy
[see Kendriya
Vidyalaya
Sangathan v. Dharmendra
Sharma ]. (2007) 8 SCC 148
It would be of some relevance to mention here that all the
decisions referred to above are by coordinate benches of two
Judges.
5.
The time-frame fixed by the scheme of the Government
to file the application for grant of compassionate appointment is
five years from the date of death of the employee. Admittedly, in
this case, the employee died on 13.01.2012. At the time of death,
this petitioner was 10 years of age, he could not have been
appointed by any means. Admittedly, he filed an application in the
year 2023 which was rejected. Thus, the application was beyond
the period of five years which is prescribed under the scheme.
Further, since the petitioner was only 10 years at the time of death
of the father of the petitioner, he could not have been appointed
nor he could apply. Thus, I find no illegality in rejecting the claim
of the compassionate appointment.
6.
With the above observation, this writ petition stands
dismissed.
(ANANDA SEN, J.)
20.01.2026
S.K.D., cp2
Uploaded on 24.01.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review