Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
CGHC010493102025
Digitally signed
by ALOK
2026:CGHC:27669-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
SHARMA
ALOK
Date:
SHARMA 2026.07.10
10:42:32
+0530
CRA No. 2462 of 2025
Abhishek Chouhan S/o Nurpo Chouhan Aged About 22 Years R/o Village
Kolaibahal P.S. Chakradhar Nagar Raigarh District And Tehsil Raigarh,
Chhattisgarh
... Appellant(s)
versus
State of Chhattisgarh Through SHO Chakradhar Nagar Raigarh, District :
Raigarh, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Case title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Ankit Singh, Advocate.
For State
:
Mr. Priyank Rathi, Govt. Advocate.
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Shri Ravindra Kumar Agrawal, Judge
Judgment on Board
06/07/2026
Per, Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice.
Though the matter was listed for consideration on application for
suspension of sentence and grant of bail, however, with the consent of
the parties the appeal is being finally heard as the appellant is in jail
since 29.10.2025.
The present appeal under Section 415(2) of the Bharatiya Nagarik
Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 has been filed by the appellant against the
impugned judgment of conviction and order of sentence dated
29.10.2025 passed by the learned Second Additional Sessions Judge,
Raigarh, District Raigarh (C.G.), in Sessions Trial No.72/2022, whereby
the appellant has been convicted and sentenced in the following
manner:Conviction
Sentence
Under Section 302 of the Life imprisonment and fine amount of
Indian Penal Code.
Rs.1,000/-, in default of payment of
fine, additional R.I. for 06 months (the
fine amount has already been paid).
The brief facts of the case are that, on 12.08.2022, complainant
Shankar Chauhan (PW-1) lodged merg intimation before Police Station
Chakradhar Nagar stating that on 11.08.2022 at about 06:30 PM, on
hearing hue and cry in the village, he came to know that Abhishek
Chauhan had murdered his second wife Soni Sidar in his house
situated at Indira Awas Mohalla, village Kolaibahal, by pressing her
neck, and when he reached the house, he found Soni Sidar lying dead
in the room with blood oozing from the back side of her head and the
appellant shouting that he had strangulated her as she was insisting
that she would not live with him and was trying to leave the house. On
the basis of the said information, merg intimation Ex.P/1 was recorded
and thereafter FIR Ex.P/2 was registered against the appellant for the
offence under Section 302 IPC. During merg inquiry, notice under
Section 175 CrPC Ex.P/3 was issued to the witnesses and inquest
over the dead body of the deceased was prepared vide Ex.P/4,
wherein opinion was given for sending the dead body for postmortem.
Spot map Ex.P/5 was prepared by the police and thereafter Patwari
map Ex.P/6 and Panchanama Ex.P/7 were also prepared. The dead
body was sent for postmortem examination to Government Hospital,
Raigarh, where PW-11 Dr. Prakash Chetwani conducted autopsy and
gave his report Ex.P/15. During postmortem, he found lacerated injury
over the upper lip, abrasion/bruising on the lower lip, congestion and
contusions beneath the scalp, contusions over the face and chest, and
opined that the cause of death was asphyxia due to pressure over the
mouth, nose and chest, and that the death was homicidal in nature.
During investigation, bloodstained cement concrete, plain cement
concrete, bloodstained towel and pieces of broken bangles were
seized from the spot vide seizure memo Ex.P/9. The appellant was
arrested and his memorandum statement was recorded vide Ex.P/13,
pursuant to which investigation proceeded further. One dark blue
nighty preserved during postmortem was also seized vide Ex.P/16. The
seized articles were sent for chemical examination/FSL and the report
thereof was received as Ex.P/24.
The statement under Section 161 CrPC of the witnesses were
recorded. After completion of usual investigation, charge sheet was
filed against the appellant for the offence under Section 302 IPC before
the Court of learned Judicial Magistrate First Class, Raigarh. Since the
offence was exclusively triable by the Court of Session, the case was
committed to the Court of Sessions, Raigarh, where it was registered
as Sessions Trial No.72/2022 and was thereafter made over to the
Court of Fifth Additional Sessions Judge, Raigarh for trial.
The trial Court has framed charge against the appellant for the offence
under Section 302 of IPC. The appellant abjured his guilt and claimed
trial.
In order to establish charge against the appellant, the prosecution has
examined as many as 17 witnesses. The statement of the
appellant/accused under Section 313 CrPC was also recorded, in
which he denied all the incriminating circumstances appearing against
him in the prosecution evidence, pleaded innocence and stated that he
has been falsely implicated in the case. In defence, however, he did
not examine any witness.
After appreciation of oral as well as documentary evidence led by the
prosecution, the learned trial Court convicted the appellant and
sentenced him as mentioned in opening para of this judgment. Hence
this appeal.
Learned counsel for the appellant would submit that the prosecution
has failed to prove its case beyond reasonable doubt. It is argued that
there is no eyewitness to the incident and the entire case rests on
circumstantial evidence, but the chain of circumstances is not complete
so as to unerringly point towards the guilt of the appellant. It is further
submitted that the prosecution witnesses, particularly the independent
witnesses, have not supported the case of the prosecution in material
particulars and there are material contradictions and omissions in their
evidence. The alleged extra-judicial confession attributed to the
appellant is not reliable and cannot be made the sole basis for
conviction, especially when the witnesses in whose presence such
confession is alleged to have been made have not consistently
supported the prosecution version. It is also contended that though the
deceased was found dead in the house of the appellant, mere recovery
of the dead body from the house is not sufficient to draw an adverse
presumption under Section 106 of the Evidence Act unless the
prosecution first establishes, by cogent and reliable evidence, that at
the relevant time the appellant and the deceased were together in the
house and that no one else had access to the place of occurrence.
According to learned counsel, the memorandum and seizure witnesses
have also not supported the prosecution case and, therefore, the
memorandum and seizure lose much of their evidentiary value. It is
thus submitted that in absence of any complete and reliable chain of
incriminating circumstances, the conviction of the appellant is
unsustainable in law and he is entitled to be acquitted of the charge
under Section 302 IPC.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the State opposes the
submissions advanced on behalf of the appellant and submits that the
prosecution has adduced sufficient evidence to establish the guilt of the
appellant for the offence in question. It is submitted that the deceased
was found dead inside the house of the appellant and the medical
evidence clearly establishes that her death was homicidal in nature,
caused by asphyxia due to pressure over the mouth, nose and chest. It
is further submitted that the evidence of prosecution witnesses,
particularly Shankar Chauhan (PW-1), Raju Sidar (PW-8) and the
investigating officers, shows that immediately after the incident the
appellant was present at the spot and was stating that he had killed the
deceased as she was insisting on leaving him and not residing with
him. The dead body of the deceased having been found in the house
where the appellant and the deceased were residing together, the
burden was upon the appellant, in terms of Section 106 of the
Evidence Act, to explain as to how the deceased suffered homicidal
death inside his house, but no plausible explanation has been offered
by him in his statement under Section 313 CrPC. It is also submitted
that though some witnesses have not fully supported the prosecution
case, their evidence does not demolish the core of the prosecution
story, and the testimony of the investigating officers and medical
witness, coupled with the circumstances proved on record, complete
the chain of circumstances pointing unerringly towards the guilt of the
appellant. It is, therefore, argued that the trial Court has rightly
appreciated the oral and documentary evidence available on record,
recorded a proper finding of conviction and there being no perversity or
illegality in the impugned judgment, the appeal deserves to be
dismissed.
10 We have heard the counsel for the parties and perused the records of
the case.
11 The homicidal death of the deceased Soni Sidar has been duly proved
by the prosecution from the evidence available on record. Shankar
Chauhan (PW-1), who lodged the merg intimation, has deposed that on
receiving information regarding the incident, he went to the house of
the appellant and found the deceased lying dead inside the room, with
blood oozing from the back side of her head. The inquest over the
dead body was prepared vide Ex.P/4 in presence of witnesses,
including Mohd. Akhtar (PW-2), Ratan Kaner (PW-3), Damini Sidar
(PW-7) and Raju Sidar (PW-8), who have also supported the factum of
recovery of the dead body of the deceased from the house of the
appellant. Further, Dr. Prakash Chetwani (PW-11), who conducted the
postmortem over the dead body of the deceased and proved the
postmortem report Ex.P/15, has clearly established that the death was
homicidal in nature. He deposed that on examination of the dead body,
he found, inter alia, a lacerated wound over the upper lip,
abrasion/bruising on the lower lip, congestion and contusions beneath
the scalp, contusions over the face and chest, swelling of lips and
breasts, and signs of pressure over the face and neck. On internal
examination, he found contusions beneath the scalp, contusions over
the facial skin and chest, congested lungs and other internal organs,
and opined that the cause of death was asphyxia on account of
pressure over the mouth, nose and chest, and that the nature of death
was homicidal. Nothing substantial has been elicited in his crossexamination to discredit his medical opinion. Thus, the prosecution has
successfully established that the deceased died a homicidal death.
12 So far as the involvement of the appellant in the offence in question is
concerned, the case of the prosecution is based on circumstantial
evidence. The deceased Soni Sidar was residing with the appellant
Abhishek Chauhan and, according to the prosecution, she was his
second wife. Shankar Chauhan (PW-1), who lodged merg intimation
Ex.P/1, has stated that on hearing hue and cry in the village on
11.08.2022 at about 06:30 PM, he went to the house of the appellant
and found the deceased lying dead inside the room, with blood oozing
from the back side of her head and the appellant present there. He has
further stated that the appellant was shouting that he had strangulated
Soni Sidar as she was saying that she would not stay with him and was
trying to leave the house. Damini Sidar (PW-7) and Raju Sidar (PW-8)
have also deposed that on receiving information, they reached the spot
and found the deceased lying dead inside the appellant’s house.
13 From the perusal of spot map Ex.P/5 prepared by the police, Patwari
map Ex.P/6 and Panchanama Ex.P/7, it is clear that the dead body of
the deceased was found lying on the cot inside the first room of the
appellant’s house. The evidence of Investigating Officer Santara
Chauhan (PW-17) also shows that on inspection of the spot,
bloodstained cement concrete, plain cement concrete, bloodstained
towel and pieces of broken bangles were seized from the room vide
seizure memo Ex.P/9. Thus, the evidence on record clearly establishes
that the deceased was found dead in homicidal circumstances inside
the house where she was residing with the appellant.
14 PW-2 Mohd. Akhtar is one of the witnesses to the inquest proceedings
and spot-related documents. However, he turned hostile and has not
supported the prosecution’s case. Though he turned hostile, but he
admitted his signatures on notice Ex.P/3 and inquest/panchayatnama
Ex.P/4.
15 PW-3 Ratan Kaner is a witness to the spot-related proceedings and
seizure memo Ex.P/9 by which bloodstained cement concrete, plain
cement concrete, bloodstained towel and broken pieces of bangles
were seized from the place of occurrence.
16 PW-7 Damini Sidar and PW-8 Raju Sidar are the sister and father of
the deceased respectively. PW-7 has stated that on receiving
information from her maternal uncle, she reached the house of the
appellant and found her sister Soni Sidar lying dead on the cot in a
partially unclothed condition, with blood coming out from her head and
mouth. PW-8 Raju Sidar has also deposed that on getting information,
he went to the spot and found his daughter lying dead on the cot in the
house of the appellant, and on making enquiry, he was told that the
appellant had caused her death. Their evidence shows that the
deceased was found dead inside the house of the appellant soon after
the incident.
17 PW-10 Dashrath Lal Khadiya is the Patwari, who prepared the spot
map Ex.P/6 and Panchanama Ex.P/7. Thus, the documentary evidence
prepared at the spot corroborates the prosecution case that the place
of occurrence was the house of the appellant itself, where the
deceased was residing with him.
18 From the evidence of these witnesses and the spot map, it transpires
that the deceased was residing with the appellant in his house and that
her dead body was found inside the said house in homicidal
circumstances. Though the appellant, in his statement under Section
313 CrPC, denied the prosecution allegations and claimed false
implication, he did not furnish any explanation as to how the deceased
suffered homicidal death inside his house, nor did he lead any defence
evidence to probabilise any alternative version.
19 In the case of Nagendra Sah Vs. The State of Bihar (2021) 10 SCC
725 the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para 23 has held as under:
“23. When a case is resting on circumstantial evidence, if
the accused fails to offer a reasonable explanation in
discharge of burden placed on him by virtue of Section 106
of the Evidence Act, such a failure may provide an
additional link to the chain of circumstances.”
In the case of Balvir Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, (2023) Live Law
(SC) 861 the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Para 33 and 34 has held as
under:
“33. Section 106 of the Evidence Act, states as under: "106.
Burden of proving fact especially within knowledge. When
any fact is especially within the knowledge of any person,
the burden of proving that fact is upon him. Illustration (a)
When a person does an act with some intention other than
that which the character and circumstances of the act
suggest, the burden of proving that intention is upon him.(b)
A is charged with travelling on a railway without a ticket,
The burden of proving that he had a ticket is on him.
34. Section 106 of the Evidence Act referred to above
provides that when any fact is especially within the
knowledge of any person, the burden of proving that fact is
upon him. The word "especially" means facts that are preeminently or exceptionally within the knowledge of the
accused. The ordinary rule that applies to the criminal trials
that the onus lies on the prosecution to prove the guilt of
the accused is not in any way modified by the rule of facts
embodied in Section 106 of the Evidence Act. Section 106
of the Evidence Act is an exception to Section 101 of the
Evidence Act. Section 101 with its illustration (a) lays down
the general rule that in a criminal case the burden of proof
is on the prosecution and Section 106 is certainly not
intended to relieve it of that duty. On the contrary, it is
designed to meet certain exceptional cases in which it
would be impossible or at any rate disproportionately
difficult for the prosecution to establish the facts which are,
"especially within the knowledge of the accused and which,
he can prove without difficulty or inconvenience.”
The further circumstance relied upon by the prosecution is the
memorandum statement of the appellant Ex.P/13 and the seizure of
incriminating articles from the spot and during investigation. Though
the witnesses to memorandum and seizure have not fully supported
the prosecution case, the Investigating Officer Santara Chauhan (PW17) has proved that during investigation bloodstained cement concrete,
plain cement concrete, bloodstained towel and pieces of broken
bangles were seized from the place of occurrence vide Ex.P/9, and
one dark blue nighty preserved during postmortem was seized vide
Ex.P/16. The seized articles were sent for chemical examination and
the FSL report Ex.P/24 was obtained, in which presence of blood is
reported on the sent articles except plain soil.
From the overall facts and circumstances of the case, what clearly
emerges is that the deceased was residing with the appellant in his
house and her dead body was found inside the said house in homicidal
circumstances. The medical evidence proves that the death was
caused by asphyxia due to pressure over the mouth, nose and chest.
The spot map Ex.P/5, Patwari map Ex.P/6 and Panchanama Ex.P/7
establish that the place of occurrence was the appellant’s house itself.
In such circumstances, when the deceased suffered homicidal death
inside the house where she was residing with the appellant, the burden
was upon the appellant, in terms of Section 106 of the Evidence Act, to
offer a plausible explanation as to how she died in his house. However,
in his statement under Section 313 CrPC, the appellant merely denied
the incriminating circumstances and pleaded false implication, without
furnishing any explanation regarding the homicidal death of the
deceased inside his house. Thus, the proved circumstances, taken
together, furnish a strong incriminating chain against the appellant and
permit drawing of an adverse inference under Section 106 of the
Evidence Act.
A false unsubstantiated defence of alibi is an additional incriminating
factor against the appellant. In Trimukh Maroti Kirkan v. State of
Maharashtra, 2006 (10) SCC 681, it was observed as follows :“22. Where an accused is alleged to have committed the
murder of his wife and the prosecution succeeds in leading evidence to show that shortly before the commission
of crime they were seen together or the offence takes
place in the dwelling home where the husband also normally resided, it has been consistently held that if the accused does not offer any explanation how the wife received injuries or offers an explanation which is found to
be false, it is a strong circumstance which indicates that
he is responsible for commission of the crime. In Nika
Ram v. State of H.P. it was observed that the fact that the
accused alone was with his wife in the house when she
was murdered there with “khukhri” and the fact that the relations of the accused with her were strained would, in
the absence of any cogent explanation by him, point to
his guilt. In Ganeshlal v. State of Maharashtra the appellant was prosecuted for the murder of his wife which took
place inside his house. It was observed that when the
death had occurred in his custody, the appellant is under
an obligation to give a plausible explanation for the cause
of her death in his statement under Section 313 CrPC.
The mere denial of the prosecution case coupled with absence of any explanation was held to be inconsistent with
the innocence of the accused, but consistent with the hypothesis that the appellant is a prime accused in the commission of murder of his wife. In State of U.P. v. Dr.
Ravindra Prakash Mittal the medical evidence disclosed
that the wife died of strangulation during late night hours
or early morning and her body was set on fire after sprinkling kerosene. The defence of the husband was that the
wife had committed suicide by burning herself and that he
was not at home at that time. The letters written by the
wife to her relatives showed that the husband ill-treated
her and their relations were strained and further the evidence showed that both of them were in one room in the
night. It was held that the chain of circumstances was
complete and it was the husband who committed the
murder of his wife by strangulation and accordingly this
Court reversed the
judgment of the High Court acquitting the accused and convicted him under Section 302
IPC. In State of T.N. v. Rajendran the wife was found
dead in a hut which had caught fire. The evidence
showed that the accused and his wife were seen together
in the hut at about 9.00 p.m. and the accused came out in
the morning through the roof when the hut had caught
fire. His explanation was that it was a case of accidental
fire which resulted in the death of his wife and a daughter.
The medical evidence showed that the wife died due to
asphyxia as a result of strangulation and not on account
of burn injuries. It was held that there cannot be any hesitation to come to the conclusion that it was the accused
(husband) who was the perpetrator of the crime.”
Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case, particularly
the proved circumstance that the deceased was found dead in
homicidal circumstances inside the house where she was residing with
the appellant, coupled with the failure of the appellant to furnish any
plausible explanation as to how the deceased suffered such homicidal
death inside his house, and in the light of the law laid down by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court with regard to the applicability of Section 106
of the Evidence Act, the learned trial Court has held the appellant guilty
for commission of the murder of Soni Sidar. On due consideration of
the evidence available on record, we do not find any illegality or
perversity in the said finding recorded by the trial Court.
In the result, the appeal fails and is hereby dismissed. The appellant is
reported to be in jail since 29.10.2025. He shall undergo the entire
sentence as awarded by the trial Court.
Registry is directed to send a copy of this judgment to the concerned
Superintendent of Jail where the appellant is undergoing his jail
sentence to serve the same on the appellant informing him that he is at
liberty to assail the present judgment passed by this court by preferring
an appeal before the Hon’ble Supreme Court with the assistance of
High Court Legal Services Committee or the Supreme Court Legal
Services Committee.
27 The records of the case along with a copy of this judgment be sent
back immediately to the trial court concerned for compliance and
necessary action.
Alok
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Ravindra Kumar Agrawal)
Judge
(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review