Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF GUJARAT AT AHMEDABAD
R/SPECIAL CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 13530 of 2026
==========================================================
ABHIRAJSINH KANAKSINH GOHIL
Versus
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR.
==========================================================
Appearance:
MR. VIREN A. PATEL(18484) for the Petitioner(s) No. 1
MR. ANGESH A. PANCHAL, AGP for the Respondent(s) No. 1,2
==========================================================
CORAM:HONOURABLE MS. JUSTICE NISHA M. THAKORE
Date : 01/10/2026
ORAL ORDER
Rule. Learned Assistant Government Pleader waives service of
notice of Rule for the respondents.
2.
By way of present petition under Article 226 of the Constitution
of India, the petitioner herein prays for the following reliefs:
“A) YOUR LORDSHIPS may be pleased to admit and allow this petition; in
the interest of justice;
(B) YOUR LORDSHIPS may be pleased to issue appropriate writ, order or
direction for quashing and setting aside the notice (at ANNEXURE-B) and
action of seizing the vehicle being Eicher Company 06 Tyre truck bearing
registration no. GJ05AZ9940 by the respondent authorities and release the
vehicle being Eicher Company 06 Tyre truck bearing registration no.
GJ05AZ9940, of the ownership of the petitioner which is seized by the
respondents and at present the case is pending with the respondent, on such
terms and conditions as this Hon'ble Court may deem think fit.
(C) YOUR LORDSHIPS may be pleased to issue appropriate writ, order or
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
direction for releasing the vehicle being Eicher Company 06 Tyre truck
bearing registration no. GJ05AZ9940 of the ownership of the petitioner
which is seized by the respondents and at present the case is pending with
the respondent, on such terms and conditions as this Hon'ble Court may
deem fit pleased to direct the respondent authorities to forthwith release
the Eicher Company 06 Tyre truck bearing registration no. GJ05AZ9940 in
the interest of justice;
(D) YOUR LORDSHIPS may be pleased to Pending admission and final
disposal of this petition, your lordships may be pleased to release the vehicle
being Eicher Company 06 Tyre truck bearing registration no. GJ05AZ9940,
appropriate terms and conditions that may be deemed fit and proper to this
Hon'ble Court in the interest of Justice.”
3.
Heard learned advocate for the petitioner and Learned
Assistant Government Pleader for the respondents.
4.
It is the case of the petitioner that the petitioner is the owner of
the seized vehicle and the vehicle in question was seized by
respondent No.2 on 07.07.2026. Notice pertaining to the same was
issued which duly produced at Annexure B.
5.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submitted that as is clear
from the seizure memo, the same was issued on 07.07.2026; however,
no steps worth the name have been initiated by the respondent, much
less filing the F.I.R. as provided under sub-clause (ii) of sub-clause (b)
of sub-Rule (2) of Rule 12 of the Gujarat Mineral (Prevention of Illegal
Mining, Transportation and Storage) Rules, 2017 (hereinafter referred
to as the “Rules of 2017”). It is submitted that in absence of any F.I.R.
registered beyond the specified period, the action of the respondent
authority seizing the vehicle, is illegal and against the principles laid
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
down by this Court in the case of Nathubhai Jinabhai Gamara v. State
of Gujarat, rendered in Special Civil Application No.9203 of 2020. It is
submitted that, this Court has categorically held and observed that if
the complaint is not registered as envisaged under sub- clause (ii) of
sub-clause (b) of sub-Rule (2) of Rule 12 of the Rules of 2017, in
absence of the complaint, the competent authority will have no option
but to release the seized vehicle without insisting for any bank
guarantee. Therefore, the principles laid down by this Court in the
case of Nathubhai Jinabhai Gamara v. State of Gujarat (supra) applies
to the facts of the present case. It is therefore urged that the petition
deserves to be allowed directing the respondent authorities to
release the vehicle. It is urged that the petition be entertained only
for the limited purpose of release of the vehicle.
6.
Per contra, learned AGP for the respondent authority submitted
that the respondent authority has filed complaint in the Court of
learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nasvadi on 19.08.2026 being
Criminal Inquiry No.10 of 2026.
7.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submitted that the said
complaint dated 19.08.2026 filed by the respondent authority is
lodged in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nasvadi,
which is against the provision of Rule 12(2) of the Gujarat Minerals
(Prevention of Illegal Mining Transportation and Storage) Rules 2017.
(Amended Rules, 2019).
8.
Placing reliance on Rule 12(2) of the Rules 2017, it was
submitted that the complaint would be maintainable before the Court
of Sessions. It was submitted that the aforesaid complaint filed by the
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
respondent authority in the Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate,
Nasvadi is non-est in eye of law.
9.
Heard learned advocates appearing for the respective parties.
10.
Rule 12 of the Rules, 2017 read thus:
“12. Seizure of property liable to confiscation.(1) Whenever any person raises, transports or causes to be raised
or transported, without any lawful authority, any mineral from
any land, and for that purpose, uses any tool, equipment, vehicle
or any other thing, such mineral, tool, equipment, vehicle or other
thing (hereinafter referred to as "property") shall be liable to be
seized by the Government in the manner specified in sub-rule (2)
of this rule.
(2) [Every Authorised Officer seizing any property under these
rules shall photograph the property and place on such property a
mark in such manner as may be determined, indicating that the
same has been so seized and shall:
(a) issue a notice in Form J informing the person from whom the
property is seized of the property so seized, and release the
property so seized upon receipt of a bank guarantee for an
amount equal to (i) the penalty payable under rule 21, in case of transportation of,
or causing to transport, mineral without lawful authority; or
(ii) the written down value of the property, in case of illegal
mining or illegal storage of mineral:
Provided that, release under clause (a) of sub- rule (2) shall be
without prejudice to and shall not in any manner affect the
conduct of investigations and other actions contemplated under
clause (b) of sub-rule (2).
Explanation: Under these rules property is seized as a security
against the amount of penalty due to the Government and to
ensure the presence of the alleged offender before the
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
Government if the case is at notice stage.]
(b)[conduct,
(i) an investigation and if he is satisfied that a compoundable
offence has been committed in respect of the property, he may,
subject to receipt of a compounding application, order payment
of such amount for compounding the offence as may be deemed
appropriate, which amount, if not paid within thirty days, may be
recovered by invocation of the bank guarantee furnished under
clause (a) of sub-rule (2); or
(ii) a preliminary investigation, and if compounding is not
permissible under rule 22 or if he is satisfied that the offence
committed in respect of the property is not compoundable, upon
the expiry of forty-five days from the date of seizure or upon
completion of the investigation, whichever is earlier, shall
approach by way of making a written complaint, before the Court
of Sessions.
Explanation:
Any offence under these rules shall be tried by
the Court of Sessions in accordance with the Procedure laid down
under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973;]
(3) [Where the court is satisfied that an offence has been
committed and is punishable under these rules, the court may
order for,(a) penalty in accordance with rule 21,
(b) confiscation of the property under sub-section (4A) of section
21 of the Act, where the property seized under sub-rule (1) above
is produced before a court under sub-clause (ii) of clause (b) of
sub-rule (2).]
(4) No order for confiscating any property shall be made under
sub-rule (3) unless the person from whom the property seized is
given:
(a) an opportunity of making a representation in writing within
such reasonable time as may be specified in the notice against the
grounds for confiscation; and; (b) a reasonable opportunity of
being heard in the matter.
(5) [***]
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
(6) [The bank guarantee issued under clause (a) of sub- rule (2)
shall be valid for an initial period of one year and shall be
renewed from time to time until payment for compounding the
offence under sub-clause (i) of clause (b) of sub- rule (2) or until
payment of the penalty determined under sub-rule (3), as
applicable, is made:
Provided that, if upon a determination under sub-rule (3), a
penalty for an amount exceeding the amount of the bank
guarantee is levied and the penalty amount is not paid, then the
excess penalty amount may be recovered in the same manner as
if it were an arrear of land revenue.]
(7) [The property seized under this rule shall be kept in the
custody of the Authorised Officer, any other third party, nearest
police station or Government premises until:
(a) a bank guarantee is provided pursuant to clause (a) of sub-rule
(2)
(b) payment of the amount as determined under sub- clause (i) of
clause (b) of sub-rule (2) for compounding the offence is made or,
(c) payment of penalty as determined under sub-rule (3) is made:
or
(d) an order of the Court directing its disposal is received by the
Authorized Officer.”
11. Considered the aforesaid submissions advanced by the learned
advocates for the respective parties. The aforesaid issue was
considered in Special Civil Application No.9213 of 2020, wherein, by
order dated 06th November, 2020, while considering identical facts, it
was held that the complaint is to be filed before the Court of Sessions
under Rule 12(2) of the Rules, which provide that for an offence under
the said Rules, the same be tried by Court of Sessions in accordance
with the procedure laid down under the Criminal Procedure Code,
Considering Rule-12 of the Rules, 2017 and the Notification dated
29th July, 2023 duly produced by the petitioner, the competent forum
is Sessions Court, wherein, the complaint is to be filed. Learned
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
Assistant Government Pleader appearing for the respondent – State
was not in a position to controvert the aforesaid position of law and
the Notification, as referred above.
12.
At this stage, it is apposite to refer to the ratio as laid down in
Special Civil Application No.9213 of 2020 dated 06th November, 2020
wherein in an identical facts, the said issue was under consideration,
wherein the paras-9 to 12 of the said order read thus:
“ 9. Now the Court would like to deal with as to when bank
guarantee is required to be furnished. On reading of Rule 12 of
the said Rules as it is, the bank guarantee is required to be
furnished at the time (i) for the release of the seized property (ii)
for recovery of unpaid penalty or (iii) for compounding of offence
and recovery of compounded amount, if it remains unpaid on
expiry of specified period of 30 days. In fact, the offence can be
compounded at two stages being (i) at a notice stage within 45
days of the seizure of the vehicle and (ii) during the prosecution
but before order of confiscation. So State can insist upon
furnishing bank guarantee for compounding the offence during
prosecution, but provided prosecution is lodged and application
for compounding of offence is moved by the petitioner. In the
case on hand, neither there is prosecution nor there is any
application for compounding of offence moved by the petitioner,
therefore, question of bank guarantee does not arise. Looking to
the scheme of Rule 12 of the said Rules, the competent authority
is authorized to seize the property, investigate into the offence
and compound it, whereas, penalty can be imposed and
confiscation of the property can be done only by order of the
Court. So it is clear that imposition of penalty and other
punishment falls in the domain of the Court and not competent
authority. Thus, custody of the property on production with the
Sessions Court for the purpose of confiscation of the property
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
shall be dealt with as indicated in sub-rule 7 of Rule 12 of the said
Rules. So it means where offence is not compounded or not
compoundable, it would be obligatory for the investigator to
approach the Sessions Court with a written complaint and
produce the seized property with the Court on expiry of the
specified period i.e. 45 days. In absence of this exercise, the
purpose of seizure and / or bank guarantee would stand
frustrated. Consequently, the property will have to be released in
favour of the person from whom it was seized without insisting
for the bank guarantee. So, submission made at bar and stand of
the State to contend that furnishing of the bank guarantee is
mandatory upon the seizure of the property is untenable and
unacceptable.
10. In sum and substance, when there is no any compounding
application moved by the petitioner as contemplated in Rule
12(2)(a) of the said Rules, no any investigation is conducted and
finalized by filing complaint before the Sessions Court or produce
the vehicle before the Sessions Court within specified period, the
State authority has no right to have dominance over the seized
property and insist for bank guarantee and thus avoid to follow
procedure as contemplated in Rule 12(2) (b)(i) and (ii) read with
sub-rule 7 of Rule 12 of the said Rules. In nutshell, inaction on the
part of the respondent after effecting seizure on 21.02.2020 till
date, by turning blind eye on Rule 12(2)(b)(i)(ii) and (7) of the said
Rules, is nothing but illegal and unauthorized stand on the part of
the State to continue dominance over the seized property
without recourse of further action contemplated under Rule –
12(2)(b) read with Rule 7 of the said Rules.
11. Lastly, learned AGP would raise contention that order dated
05.09.2020 is appealable before the competent authority under
Rule 18 of the said Rules and therefore, present petition may not
be entertained in view of alternative efficacious remedy available
to the petitioner. In the case of hand, the issue goes to the root of
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
inaction on the part of respondent authority as aforesaid and
therefore, in Court’s opinion, the petitioner is not required to be
relegated to such recourse, more particularity when action of
respondent nos.2 and 3 to continue dominance over seized
vehicle on account of non compliance of Rule 12(2)(b)(ii) of the
said Rules is involved in the present petition and therefore, the
Court is not inclined to accept such contention and direct the
petitioner to relegate to take recourse under Rule 18 of the said
Rules.
12. In view of above position, the petition is required to be
allowed and accordingly action of respondent nos.2 and 3 for
dominance over seized vehicle having become unauthorized and
illegal on account of non compliance of Rule 12(2)(b)(ii) of the
said Rules, relief in terms of para – 7(B) is granted. While parting
with this order, respondent no.1 – State is directed to issue
suitable guidelines to the authorized officer responsible to
implement procedure under Mining Rules of 2017 (as amended in
2019) in terms of this order as to stage and eventuality at which
bank guarantee can be insisted and compliance of Rule 12(2) (b)
in case no application for compounding or release of vehicle /
property is moved by the person concerned. Accordingly, present
petition is allowed. Rule is made absolute to the aforesaid extent.
Direct service is permitted.”
13.
Considering the facts of the present case, and the ratio as laid
down, in Special Civil Application No.9213 of 2020 dated 06th
November, 2020 as referred above, as also Scheme of Rule 12(2)(b)(ii),
as referred above, respondent authority was required to approach the
learned Sessions Court under the provisions of Rule 12(2)(b)(ii) of the
Rules, 2017. In absence of the aforesaid exercise undertaken by the
competent authority, the complaint in question came to be filed in the
Court of learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Nasvadi would be non-est
C/SCA/13530/2026
(GJHC240692142026)
ORDER DATED: 01/10/2026
in the eye of law. At the cost of repetition, the complaint is
maintainable before the Court of Sessions under Rule 12(2)(b)(ii) of
the Rules, 2017 (Amended Rule, 2019).
14.
For the foregoing reasons, the respondent authority is directed
to release the vehicle of the petitioner being Truck of Eicher Company
06 Tyre Truck having Registration No. GJ-05-AZ-9940, the complaint in
question having been filed before the Forum, which has no jurisdiction
to consider the complaint. The present order is passed only to release
the vehicle in question, reserving the liberty in favour of the
respondent authorities to initiate the appropriate steps, in accordance
with law. It is clarified that this Court has not examined the merits of
the issue involved and the observations made are only for the limited
purpose of releasing the vehicle.
15.
In view of the aforementioned discussion, the petition succeeds
and is accordingly allowed in part. Rule is made absolute to the
aforesaid extent. No order as to costs. Direct service is permitted
(NISHA M. THAKORE,J)
SUYASH SRIVASTAVA
Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judge.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review