Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
%
Judgment reserved on: 08.01.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 13.01.2026
Judgment uploaded on: 13.01.2026
+
W.P.(C) 171/2026 & CM APPL. 847/2026, CM APPL.
848/2026, CM APPL. 849/2026, CM APPL. 850/2026, CM
APPL. 851/2026
ABHIMANYU SINGH AND ANR
.....Petitioners
Through: Mr. Shrey Kapoor, Mr. Nishit
Agrawal, Ms. Kanishka Mittal,
Ms. Deepti Rathi, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Ms. Monika Arora, CGSC with
Mr. Debasish Mishra, GP.
+
W.P.(C) NO. 174/2026, CM APPL. 853/2026,CM APPL.
854/2026, CM APPL. 855/2026 & CM APPL. 856/2026
UPAMA JAIN
.....Petitioner
Through: Mr. Shrey Kapoor, Mr. Nishit
Agrawal, Ms. Kanishka Mittal,
Ms. Deepti Rathi, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Mr. Shashank Dixit, CGSC
with Mr. Kunal Raj, Advocate
for UOI.
+
W.P.(C) NO. 236/2026, CM APPL. 1105/2026, CM APPL.
1106/2026, CM APPL. 1107/2026 & CM APPL. 1108/2026
LAVANYA S P
.....Petitioner
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
Through:
Mr. Shrey Kapoor, Mr. Nishit
Agrawal, Ms. Kanishka Mittal,
Ms. Deepti Rathi, Advocates.
versus
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.
.....Respondents
Through: Dr. Monika Arora (CGSC), Mr.
Subhrodeep Saha, Mr. Prabhat
Kumar, Ms. Anamika Thaku,
Mr. Abhinav Verma, Advocates
and Mr. Debasish Mishra (G.P)
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANIL KSHETARPAL
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT MAHAJAN
JUDGMENT
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
1.
The present Writ Petitions, preferred by the Petitioners, assail
the correctness of common judgment and final order dated 12.12.2025
[hereinafter referred to as 8Impugned Order9] passed by the learned
Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi
[hereinafter referred to as the 8Tribunal9], whereby Original
Applications bearing O.A. No. 664/2024, O.A. No. 1754/2024, and
other connected matters were dismissed.
2.
Since the present Writ Petitions arise out of a similar set of
facts, involve identical questions of law, and assail the aforesaid
common Impugned Order, they are being heard together and are
disposed of by this common judgment.The Petitioners are
probationers of the Indian Forest Service [8IFS9], having been selected
through the Indian Forest Service Examination, 2022, and having
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
joined probationary training at the Indira Gandhi National Forest
Academy [8IGNFA9] on 15.11.2023.
3.
The issue which arises for consideration in these Writ Petitions
essentially relates to the applicability of the Indian Forest Service
(Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023, notified on 23.11.2023, insofar
as the said amendment re-introduced a prohibition on probationers
from appearing in the Civil Services Examination or any other open
competitive examination during the period of training.
FACTUAL MATRIX
4.
In order to appreciate the controversy involved, the relevant
facts in brief are required to be noticed.
5.
The Indian Forest Service (Probation) Rules, 1968 were framed
in exercise of powers under Section 3(1) of the All India Services Act,
1951. Rule 8 thereof, as originally enacted and as amended in 1994,
contained a proviso prohibiting IFS probationers from appearing in
the Civil Services Examination or any other open competitive
examination during the period of training at IGNFA.By virtue of the
Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2017, the said
prohibitory proviso to Rule 8(1) was omitted. While the 2017
Amendment remained in force, the statutory prohibition on IFS
probationers appearing in the Civil Services Examination or other
open competitive examinations during training stood omitted.
6.
The Petitioners appeared in the IFS Examination, 2022, were
successful, and were appointed as probationers in the IFS. They joined
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
training at IGNFA on 15.11.2023.
7.
On 23.11.2023, the Department of Personnel and Training
[8DoPT9] notified the Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment
Rules, 2023, whereby the proviso to Rule 8(1), prohibiting
probationers from appearing in the Civil Services Examination or any
other open competitive examination during training, was reintroduced.
8.
Upon issuance of the said notification, the Petitioners made
representations seeking permission to appear in the Civil Services
Examination during their probation, or alternatively, seeking nonapplication of the 2023 Amendment to them, or grant of Extraordinary
Leave. These requests were declined by the competent authority.
9.
It is not in dispute that, contemporaneously, an option was
made available to probationers, including the Petitioners, to seek
deferment or exemption from training if they desired to appear in the
Civil Services Examination. The Petitioners, however, did not opt for
deferment of training and continued with the probationary course at
IGNFA.
10.
Aggrieved thereby, the Petitioners approached the Tribunal,
which, by the Impugned Order dated 12.12.2025, dismissed the
Original Applications. The Tribunal held that the 2023 Amendment
did not take away any vested right and upheld the restriction imposed
during training.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
CONTENTIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PARTIES
11.
CONTENTIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONERS
11.1 Learned counsel for the Petitioners contended that the Indian
Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023, notified on
23.11.2023, could not be applied to the Petitioners, who had joined
training at IGNFA on 15.11.2023, prior to the said amendment. It was
submitted that the 2023 Amendment re-introduced a prohibition on
appearing in the Civil Services Examination or any other open
competitive examination during the period of probation, but did not
expressly provide for retrospective operation.
11.2 It was further submitted that the Petitioners, having been
selected through the Indian Forest Service Examination, 2022, and
having joined probationary training at IGNFA, had a legitimate
expectation, based on the rules in force at the time of joining and the
joining instructions provided, to appear in the UPSC Civil Services
Examination while undergoing probation. Learned counsel contended
that any attempt to apply the 2023 Amendment retrospectively would
be arbitrary, unreasonable, and violative of Article 14 of the
Constitution of India.
11.3 The Petitioners also emphasized their merit, noting that they
had successfully qualified the IFS Examination and, in addition, had
cleared preliminary and main stages of the UPSC Civil Services
Examination. It was submitted that their selection was the result of
long-term dedicated preparation and sustained academic effort, and
that denying them the opportunity to appear in subsequent
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
examinations during probation would unfairly curtail their legitimate
career prospects.
11.4 Learned counsel further submitted that there was no allegation
of insincerity, misconduct, or negligence against the Petitioners. On
the contrary, the Petitioners had undergone uninterrupted training at
IGNFA, completed all prescribed requirements, and earned awards
and commendations, thereby demonstrating exceptional conduct.
Learned counsel argued that the restriction imposed by the 2023
Amendment amounted to a punitive measure without fault, contrary to
principles of fairness and proportionality.
11.5 Reliance was placed on the decisions of the Supreme Court in
N.T. Devin Katti v. Karnataka Public Service Commission1 and M.
Surender Reddy v. State of A.P.2, wherein it was held that in the
absence of express provision or necessary implication to the contrary,
statutory rules operate prospectively and not retrospectively. It was
submitted that, accordingly, the 2023 Amendment could not affect the
Petitioners9 rights under the Rules in force at the time of their
appointment.
12.
CONTENTIONS ON BEHALF OF THE RESPONDENTS
12.1 Per contra, learned counsel for the Respondents, who appeared
on advance notice, contended that the Indian Forest Service
(Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023, were enacted to ensure proper
discipline, uninterrupted training, and efficient utilization of
(1990) 3 SCC 157
(2015) 8 SCC 410
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
government resources at IGNFA. It was submitted that the 2023
Amendment did not prohibit probationers from appearing in the UPSC
Civil Services Examination entirely, but only restricted participation
during the period of probationary training.
12.2 It was submitted that the Ministry had, at the time of issuing the
offer of appointment, provided an option to probationers, including
the Petitioners, to seek deferment or exemption from training if they
wished to appear in the UPSC examination. Several candidates had
availed themselves of this option.
12.3 Learned counsel further contended that the Petitioners
voluntarily chose to join training without opting for the extension or
exemption, thereby electing to continue training while seeking to
appear in the UPSC examination, contrary to the Rules in force. It was
emphasized that the 2023 Amendment was applied prospectively and
in accordance with law and therefore, the Petitioners9 claims were
without merit, as the amendment merely sought to ensure proper
conduct of probation, maintain discipline, and safeguard the training
process
12.4 Reliance was placed on the decision of the Constitution Bench
of the Supreme Court in Syed Yakoob v. K.S. Radhakrishnan and
Others3 to contend that where a statutory authority or Tribunal records
a finding of fact based on material before it, such finding cannot be
interfered with by a writ court merely because it may appear that some
material evidence was overlooked, unless it is shown that the finding
(1963) SCC OnLine SC 24
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
is based on no evidence at all. It was submitted that the said decision
establishes that the High Courts9 jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution is supervisory in nature and cannot convert the writ court
into an appellate authority to re-examine factual determinations of
competent authorities. Learned counsel contended that, on the same
principle, the 2023 Amendment, as applied to the Petitioners, is within
the competence of the Ministry and does not impinge upon any vested
right; the Petitioners9 challenge to the prospective application of the
Rules is therefore without merit.
ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION
13.
The principal issues that arise for consideration are:
i.
Whether IFS probationers can claim a right to be governed, for
all purposes, by the rules prevailing on the date of their appointment,
notwithstanding subsequent amendments made during the period of
service or probation;
ii.
Whether the Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment
Rules, 2023, notified on 23.11.2023, are inapplicable to the Petitioners
on the ground that they joined training prior to the said notification;
and
iii.
Whether the denial of permission to appear in the Civil Services
Examination or any other open competitive examination during the
probationary period suffers from arbitrariness or illegality warranting
interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
ANALYSIS & FINDINGS
14.
This Court has carefully considered the submissions advanced
on behalf of the parties and perused the material on record. At the
outset, it becomes necessary to examine the scope and applicability of
the Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023, in
relation to the Petitioners, who joined the probationary training at
IGNFA on 15.11.2023.
15.
The foundational premise on which the Petitioners9 challenge
rests is that the conditions governing their probation and training
must, for all purposes, remain frozen as they stood on the date of their
appointment. Such a proposition, however, cannot be accepted as an
absolute rule. Service jurisprudence recognises that conditions of
service, including those regulating probation and training, are
governed by the statutory rules as they stand from time to time,
subject to constitutional limitations. A probationer does not acquire an
immutable or vested right to insist that the regulatory framework
prevailing on the date of entry into service must continue unchanged
throughout the period of probation or thereafter.
16.
The legal position regarding the applicability of amended
service rules also stands clarified by the decision of the Supreme
Court in State of Himachal Pradesh v. Raj Kumar4, wherein the
earlier understanding flowing from Y.V. Rangaiah v. J. Sreenivasa
Rao5 that vacancies arising prior to amendment of the rules must
necessarily be governed by the unamended rules, was revisited and
(2022) SCC OnLine SC 680
(1983) 3 SCC 284
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
explained. After an exhaustive review of the precedents, the Supreme
Court authoritatively held that there is no rule of universal application
that vacancies must invariably be filled in accordance with the rules
existing on the date of their occurrence, and that a government servant
does not acquire a vested or immutable right except a right to be
considered in accordance with the rules in force when the process of
consideration is undertaken. It was further reiterated that service
conditions are liable to change in public interest, subject to the
requirements of fairness under Article 14 of the Constitution, and that
unless a vested or accrued right has crystallised, the rule-making
authority is competent to amend the applicable rules, which would
govern the field from the date of their enforcement. The decision thus
reinforces the settled principle that service conditions, including those
relating to probation and training, do not stand frozen on the date of
appointment and may validly be regulated by statutory rules as
amended from time to time.
17.
In the present case, the statutory framework governing
probation in the Indian Forest Service itself demonstrates that the
prohibition on appearing in open competitive examinations during
training is not alien or newly introduced. Rule 8 of the Indian Forest
Service (Probation) Rules, 1968, as originally enacted and as it stood
for decades thereafter, expressly contained a proviso barring
probationers from appearing in the Civil Services Examination or any
other open competitive examination during the period of training at
the IGNFA. The omission of the said proviso by the 2017 Amendment
therefore, did not create a permanent or vested entitlement in favour of
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
probationers to participate in such examinations during training, but
remained subject to alteration by a subsequent amendment in exercise
of statutory rule-making power.
18.
The Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023,
notified on 23.11.2023, re-introduced the very prohibition which
formed part of the statutory regime governing IFS probation for a
substantial period of time. The Amendment neither alters the structure
of Rule 8 nor introduces a new condition previously unknown to the
service. It restores the original position that probationary training at
IGNFA is required to be pursued without simultaneous engagement in
open competitive examinations. Viewed thus, the 2023 Amendment
operates on the probationary conditions as they exist during training
and does not, in law, amount to a retrospective deprivation of any
accrued or vested right.This conclusion follows not merely from the
historical existence of such a prohibition, but from the settled
principle that conditions governing probation and training are liable to
change during service, subject to statutory authority.
19.
The mere fact that the Petitioners joined probationary training
on 15.11.2023, i.e., a few days prior to the notification of the 2023
Amendment, does not confer upon them a legal right to insist that the
regulatory conditions governing training must remain static for the
entire duration of probation. Probation, by its very nature, is a
transitional phase of service, regulated continuously by the rules in
force. So long as the amended rules operate prospectively and regulate
conduct during an ongoing period of training, their application cannot
be characterised as retrospective merely because the probationer
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
entered service earlier.
20.
The doctrine of legitimate expectation, as invoked on behalf of
the Petitioners, is equally inapplicable in the present case. A legitimate
expectation can arise only when it is founded upon a consistent past
practice or an express representation, and even then, it cannot operate
to defeat a statutory rule validly framed in exercise of legislative
power. During the currency of the 2017 Amendment, probationers
may have been permitted to appear in competitive examinations;
however, such permissibility was always subject to the governing
statutory framework as it stood from time to time. Once the competent
authority, in exercise of its rule-making power, restored the earlier
prohibition by notifying the 2023 Amendment, no enforceable
expectation could survive contrary to the amended rule. Legitimate
expectation, in any event, cannot crystallise into a vested right to insist
upon the continued application of a repealed or amended statutory
provision.
21.
It is also well-settled that a probationer does not possess an
indefeasible right to insist upon the continuance of service conditions
as they existed on the date of appointment, particularly insofar as such
conditions relate to training, discipline, and regulatory control during
probation. Probation, by its very nature, is a period of assessment,
conditioning, and institutional training, during which the employer
retains a wide latitude to prescribe, modify, or regulate the terms
governing conduct and engagement, so long as such regulation is
traceable to statutory authority and is not arbitrary or discriminatory.
The conditions governing probationary training at IGNFA are
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
intended not merely to regulate service, but to ensure focused,
uninterrupted training and optimal utilisation of public resources, and
must therefore be viewed as dynamic rather than immutable.
22.
Tested on the aforesaid principles, this Court is unable to accept
the contention that the Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment
Rules, 2023 operate retrospectively merely because they came into
force after the Petitioners had joined probationary training. A statutory
rule operates retrospectively only when it is expressly so provided, or
when it seeks to alter or take away vested or accrued rights. The 2023
Amendment does neither. It does not undo any completed event,
disturb any concluded selection, or impair the Petitioners9
appointment to the Indian Forest Service. The Amendment merely
regulates the manner in which probationary training is to be
undergone from the date of its enforcement onwards. Its application to
probationers who were already undergoing training on the date of its
notification, therefore, constitutes prospective operation upon a
continuing
and
ongoing
relationship,
and
not
retrospective
interference with vested rights.
23.
It is also material to note that the Petitioners were not placed in
a situation of compulsion or impossibility upon the notification of the
2023 Amendment. The record clearly reflects, and indeed it is not in
dispute, that an option was made available to all probationers,
including the Petitioners, to seek deferment or exemption from
training in the event they intended to appear in the Civil Services
Examination. Several probationers availed of this option. The
Petitioners, however, consciously elected to continue with the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
probationary training at IGNFA without seeking deferment,
notwithstanding full knowledge of the amended Rule position.
24.
It also merits notice that the Petitioners sought to apply for
participation in the Civil Services Examination, 2024 only after the
Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023 had
already come into force. As recorded in the proceedings before the
Tribunal, the last date for submission of applications for the Civil
Services (Preliminary) Examination, 2024 was 05.03.2024, and the
interim order dated 01.03.2024 was passed precisely on the
Petitioners9 apprehension that submission of the application form
during the subsistence of the amended Rule may attract adverse
consequences. Thus, on the date when the Petitioners sought to apply
and participate in the Civil Services Examination, the amended
proviso to Rule 8(1) was fully operative and governed the field. The
Petitioners, therefore, cannot assert that their application for the Civil
Services Examination stood insulated from the operation of the 2023
Amendment or was referable to a legal regime which had ceased to
exist.
25.
Such an election carries legal consequences. Having chosen to
remain within the framework of probationary training governed by the
amended Rules, the Petitioners cannot thereafter be permitted to
contend that the very Rules under which they continued to undergo
training ought not to bind them. The principle that one cannot
approbate and reprobate applies with full force. A probationer who
voluntarily subjects himself or herself to the discipline of training
under the prevailing statutory regime cannot selectively disown those
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
provisions which are perceived to operate to his or her disadvantage.
26.
The submission that the denial of permission to appear in the
Civil Services Examination operates harshly or unfairly upon the
Petitioners also does not commend acceptance. The restriction
imposed by the 2023 Amendment is neither permanent nor punitive in
nature. It is confined strictly to the period of probationary training and
is uniformly applicable to all probationers governed by the Rules. The
object sought to be achieved, namely, ensuring uninterrupted training,
institutional discipline, and optimal utilization of public resources,
cannot be said to be extraneous or arbitrary. In matters relating to
service discipline and training, the employer is entitled to prescribe
reasonable conditions, and the Court would be slow to interfere unless
such conditions are shown to be manifestly arbitrary or violative of
constitutional guarantees.
27.
Equally, the Petitioners9 reliance upon their individual merit,
academic achievements, or commendable performance during
training, howsoever laudable, cannot furnish a legal basis to carve out
an exception in their favour. Service jurisprudence recognises that
individual excellence cannot override uniform statutory rules
applicable to a class. To hold otherwise would be to introduce an
element of subjectivity and uncertainty into the administration of
probation, which is antithetical to the very purpose of a structured
training regime.
28.
The scope of interference by this Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution, particularly in matters arising out of service conditions
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
and training regulations, is well settled. The writ jurisdiction is
supervisory and not appellate in nature. Where a competent authority
or a Tribunal has applied the relevant statutory rules and recorded
findings on the basis of material placed before it, the High Court does
not sit in appeal over such findings to re-appreciate evidence or to
substitute its own view merely because another view may be possible.
29.
In Syed Yakoob (supra), the Constitution Bench of the Supreme
Court authoritatively held that a writ of certiorari can be issued only
where there is an error of jurisdiction, an error apparent on the face of
the record, or where a finding is based on no evidence at all. It was
further clarified that mere errors of fact, or the possibility that some
material may not have been accorded due weight, do not furnish a
ground for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution. This
principle squarely governs the present case.
30.
Tested on the aforesaid touchstone, the Impugned Order does
not suffer from any jurisdictional infirmity or manifest illegality. The
Tribunal has taken note of the statutory framework governing IFS
probationers, the re-introduction of the prohibitory proviso by the
2023 Amendment, and the undisputed fact that the Petitioners
continued their training after the Amendment came into force, despite
being afforded the option of deferment or exemption. The conclusion
arrived at by the Tribunal that no vested right of the Petitioners stood
infringed is a plausible and legally sustainable view flowing from the
record.
31.
The
contention
that
the
Amendment
operates
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
retrospectively, merely because the Petitioners had joined training a
few days prior to its notification, has also been rightly repelled. The
Amendment applies to the period of probation and training as it exists
after 23.11.2023. It does not reopen or unsettle any concluded event,
nor does it impose any disqualification with retrospective effect. What
is regulated is the conduct of probationers during training after the
Amendment came into force, which is plainly prospective in
operation.
32.
Once it is held that no vested or accrued right of the Petitioners
stood crystallised to appear in the Civil Services Examination during
probation, the edifice of the challenge under Article 14 of the
Constitution necessarily collapses. The restriction imposed by the
amended Rule applies uniformly to all probationers undergoing
training and is founded on an intelligible differentia having a rational
nexus with the object sought to be achieved. No element of hostile
discrimination or arbitrariness is made out.
33.
Accordingly, the issues framed for determination are answered
as under:
i.
IFS probationers cannot claim a right to be governed, for all
purposes, by the Rules prevailing on the date of their appointment,
irrespective of subsequent amendments validly made during the period
of probation;
ii.
The Indian Forest Service (Probation) Amendment Rules, 2023
are applicable to the Petitioners notwithstanding the fact that they
joined training prior to 23.11.2023, since the Amendment governs the
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
period of training thereafter; and
iii.
The denial of permission to appear in the Civil Services
Examination during probationary training does not suffer from
arbitrariness or illegality so as to warrant interference under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
CONCLUSION
34.
For the aforegoing reasons, this Court finds no infirmity in the
Impugned Order passed by the Tribunal. The Writ Petitions are devoid
of merit and are accordingly dismissed.
35.
All pending applications also stand closed.
ANIL KSHETARPAL, J.
AMIT MAHAJAN, J.
JANUARY 13, 2026
jai/pal
Signed By:JAI
NARAYAN
17:25:08
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review