The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
05. 12.2017, the review application being RA 1/18, was also considered and came to be dismissed only on 30.08.2021. Without further discussing in detail the orders passed by the learned Tribunal, it can be seen that there exists no element of deprivation of adequate opportunity to the petitioners or any blatant violation of the principles of natural justice as alleged, and as such no case had been made out to warrant any interference, or for any exercise of powers under Article 227 of the Constitution, by this Court.
9. The presence of alternate remedy as held in the case of Punjab National Bank vs. O.C. Krishnan (supra) cited by the counsel of the respondent Bank, in the absence of any contingency or situation to warrant interference under Article 227, the instant case is squarely covered by this judgment, wherein at Para-6, which is relevant, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows:“6. The Act has been enacted with a view to provide a special procedure for recovery of debts due to the banks and the financial institutions. There is a hierarchy of appeal provided in the Act, namely, filing of an appeal under Section 20 and this fast-track procedure cannot be allowed to be derailed either by taking recourse to proceedings under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution or by filing a civil suit, which is expressly barred. Even though a provision under an Act cannot expressly oust the jurisdiction of the court under Articles 227 and 227 of the Constitution, nevertheless, when there is an alternative remedy available, judicial prudence demands that the Court refrains from exercising its jurisdiction under the said Constitutional provisions. This was a case where the High Court should not have entertained the petition under Article 227 of the Constitution and should have directed the respondent to take recourse to the appeal mechanism provided by the Act.
10. The petitioner therefore having recourse to alternative efficacious remedy under the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, in the facts and circumstances of the case, this matter in the considered view of this Court, does not deserve any further consideration and accordingly stands dismissed.
11. However, there shall be no order as to costs. Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
CRP No. 16 of 2021
Date of Decision: 12.09.2023
Abhi Coke Private Limited & Ors.
Vs. Industrial Development
Bank of India Ltd.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S. Thapa, Adv.
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Mr. B.K. Das, Adv.
Mr. H. Yadav, Adv.
Mr. S.D. Upadhaya, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
This revision petition under Article 227 of the
Constitution of India, has been filed assailing the impugned orders
dated 05.12.2017 allowing O.A. No. 25 of 2017 and order dated
30.08.2021, rejecting a review application being RA. No. 1/2018 in
O.A. No. 25 of 2017, by the learned Debts Recovery Tribunal,
Guwahati.
2.
The petitioners have alleged that in the proceedings
before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, there has been a flagrant abuse
of the principles of natural justice and that there is error of law patent
on the face of the record, which has resulted in the miscarriage of
justice. The allegation of the petitioners, is founded on the fact that
the proceedings and judgment rendered was done ex parte and the
petitioners, were unjustly deprived of an opportunity to participate
in the proceedings.
3.
The background facts in brief, are that on the default
by the Petitioner Company on the re-payment of loan along with
interest, the respondent Bank had filed an application before the
Debts Recovery Tribunal at Guwahati for recovery of Rs.
30,79,24,469/- (Rupees Thirty Crores Seventy-Nine Lakhs TwentyFour Thousand Four Hundred Sixty-Nine only), and the said
application was registered as O.A. No. 25/2017. On receipt of notice,
the petitioners appeared on 10.03.2017 and the next date was fixed
on 11.04.2017 for filing of vakalatnama on behalf of the other
petitioners, and for written statement, which however while filing
the vakalat, the petitioners, prayed for further time to file written
statement. The matter was then fixed on 12.05.2017, and on that date
the matter was then adjourned to 29.05.2017. On 29.05.2017, further
time was again prayed by the petitioners for filing written statement,
which was allowed by the Tribunal and the next date was fixed on
29.06.2017. On 29.06.2017 because of summer vacations, the case
was again fixed on 31.07.2017. On this date on the failure of the
petitioners to file the written statement which was duly recorded by
the learned Tribunal, the right of the petitioners to file their written
statement-cum-evidence on affidavit stood closed, and the matter
was then fixed for final hearing on 04.09.2017. The petitioners then
by way of I.A. 375/2017, filed for vacating the order dated
31.07.2017, along with a prayer for accepting their written statement
and evidence on affidavit. On this application, the learned Tribunal
allowed the respondent Bank to file its objections and the matter was
then fixed for 26.10.2017. On 26.10.2017, the learned Tribunal
finding that no cogent reasons had been given as to why the written
statement could not be filed from 10.03.2017 to 31.10.2017, then
rejected the I.A. 375/2017 and fixed the matter for final hearing on
23.11.2017. The matter was then subsequently heard, and the
judgment was pronounced and recovery certificate issued on
05.12.2017.
4.
The petitioners thereafter preferred a review
application being RA 1 of 2018 under Section 22(2)(e) and Section
19(25) of the Recovery of Debts due to Banks and Financial Act,
1993 for review of the judgment dated 05.12.2017 passed by the
learned Tribunal, to which the respondent Bank filed objections
thereto. The learned Tribunal after hearing the parties then by the
second impugned order dated 30.08.2021, dismissed the said review
application.
5.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.
Thapa, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the learned
Tribunal itself, had accorded time to the petitioners to file its written
statement-cum-evidence on affidavit beyond 10.03.2017, on being
satisfied with the causes assigned, and as such had erred in rejecting
the application for vacating the order dated 31.07.2017. It is
submitted that the rejection by the learned Tribunal, of the
application for recall of the order dated 31.07.2017, was only on the
reason given in the order that the written statement was to be filed
on 10.03.2017, which was not done, and the matter was adjourned
on several dates that is 11.04.2017, 12.05.2017, 29.05.2017,
29.06.2017 and 31.07.2017 but petitioners still did not file the same.
He submits that the learned Tribunal failed to appreciate the matter
or the causes of the failure in filing the written statement by the
petitioners, in its proper perspective, and such the impugned orders
are liable to be interfered with. It has been further contended that
even assuming the order dated 31.07.2017 is correct, the petitioners’
right to participate could not have been denied and he submits that a
perusal of orders dated 23.11.2017 and 05.12.2017, would clearly
testify that the petitioners’ right to participate in the hearing had been
declined by the learned Tribunal and the matter proceeded ex parte.
He therefore asserts that the learned Tribunal in not permitting the
petitioners to participate in the hearing, tantamount to the violation
of the principles of natural justice, and even though this has been
categorically pleaded in the Review Application, the same was not
given any consideration which is an error apparent on the face of the
record.
6.
The learned Senior counsel to justify the invocation
of Article 227 of the Constitution, despite the availability of alternate
remedy under The Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993,
has submitted that the same is warranted to correct errors of
jurisdiction which has been committed by the learned Tribunal in the
instant case. He submits that the powers of superintendence of the
High Court is to be exercised in the instant case, as there has been an
abuse of the elementary of principles of justice which has resulted in
the miscarriage of justice, and the orders of the learned Tribunal
therefore are surely amenable to judicial review under Article 227.
In support of his arguments with regard to the invocation of Article
227, and also the power of judicial review, the learned counsel has
placed reliance on the following judgments: -
7.
i)
Whirlpool Corporation vs. Registrar of Trade Marks,
Mumbai & Ors. (1998) 8 SCC 1
ii)
L. Chandra Kumar vs. Union of India & Ors. (1997) 3
SCC 261
Mr. B.K. Das, learned counsel for the respondent
Bank in his submissions has referred to Rule 12 of The Debts
Recovery Tribunal (Procedure) Rule, 1993 and submits that the
time limit and period for which written statement and other
documents to be filed before the Tribunal is clearly prescribed
therein, and that the learned Tribunal had even extended the time for
filing written statement, which the petitioners had repeatedly failed
to do so. Ample opportunity he contends, has been accorded to the
petitioners and it is not a case wherein the petitioners have been
denied any such opportunity to file their written statement, as sought
to be made out. He further submits that the availability of alternate
remedy for appeal, against any order of the learned Tribunal under
the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy Act, 1993, which is a special
statute would surely prevent this Court from exercising its powers
under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. He submits that in the
impugned orders there is no presence of any manifest error as
alleged, or that the learned Tribunal had acted in excess of its
jurisdiction vested in by law. The learned counsel has then cited a
decision rendered by the Supreme Court, in the case of Punjab
National Bank vs. O.C. Krishnan & Ors. reported in (2001) 6 SCC
569 in support of his submissions on the availability of alternate
remedy and the non-maintainability of the instant revision
application under Article 227 of the Constitution.
7.
Heard the learned counsels for the parties and
examined the materials on record. As noted in the judgment of
Whirlpool Corporation (supra), if an effective an efficacious
remedy is available, the High Court would not normally exercise its
jurisdiction, though presence of alternate remedy as has been held
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, will not operate as a bar in certain
contingencies, one of which is the violation of the principles of
natural justice. In the instant case, the only issue to be looked into,
is whether there was any violation of the principles of natural justice
as contended by the petitioners. To answer this question, this Court
has examined the orders passed by the learned Tribunal and the
sequence of events. As noted initially by this Court, in the brief
narration of facts, and on a further perusal of the orders, it is clearly
seen that this is not a case where there has been any denial of
opportunity to the petitioners for filing of their written statements
and other documents. In fact, an unduly long period spanning from
10.03.2017 to 31.07.2017 which is over 4(four) months, was allowed
by the learned Tribunal for filing of written statements which,
however the petitioners failed to comply with. Even I.A. No.
375/2017 for recall of the order dated 31.07.2017 closing the
opportunity for filing of written statement was given due
consideration and was rejected by a reasoned order.
8.
Further, on the pronouncement of the judgment on
05.12.2017, the review application being RA 1/18, was also
considered and came to be dismissed only on 30.08.2021. Without
further discussing in detail the orders passed by the learned Tribunal,
it can be seen that there exists no element of deprivation of adequate
opportunity to the petitioners or any blatant violation of the
principles of natural justice as alleged, and as such no case had been
made out to warrant any interference, or for any exercise of powers
under Article 227 of the Constitution, by this Court.
9.
The presence of alternate remedy as held in the case
of Punjab National Bank vs. O.C. Krishnan (supra) cited by the
counsel of the respondent Bank, in the absence of any contingency
or situation to warrant interference under Article 227, the instant
case is squarely covered by this judgment, wherein at Para-6, which
is relevant, the Hon’ble Supreme Court held as follows:“6. The Act has been enacted with a view to provide a
special procedure for recovery of debts due to the
banks and the financial institutions. There is a
hierarchy of appeal provided in the Act, namely, filing
of an appeal under Section 20 and this fast-track
procedure cannot be allowed to be derailed either by
taking recourse to proceedings under Articles 226 and
227 of the Constitution or by filing a civil suit, which
is expressly barred. Even though a provision under an
Act cannot expressly oust the jurisdiction of the court
under Articles 227 and 227 of the Constitution,
nevertheless, when there is an alternative remedy
available, judicial prudence demands that the Court
refrains from exercising its jurisdiction under the said
Constitutional provisions. This was a case where the
High Court should not have entertained the petition
under Article 227 of the Constitution and should have
directed the respondent to take recourse to the appeal
mechanism provided by the Act.
10.
The petitioner therefore having recourse to alternative
efficacious remedy under the Recovery of Debts and Bankruptcy
Act, 1993, in the facts and circumstances of the case, this matter in
the considered view of this Court, does not deserve any further
consideration and accordingly stands dismissed.
11.
However, there shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
12.09.2023
“V. Lyndem PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review