Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:18250
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(S) No. 6421 of 2022
….…..
Abhai Kumar, aged about 60 years, son of Late Jagdeo
Bhuiya @ Jagdeo Prasad, Resident of Near Dhori
Dispensary, P.O. - Dhori, P.S. Bermo, District - Bokaro,
PIN-825102.
..… Petitioner (s)
Versus
1. Central Coalfields Limited, Darbhanga House, PO GPO, PS Kotwali, Dist. Ranchi through its Chairman
cum Managing Director.
2. Director (Personnel), Central Coalfields Limited,
Darbhanga House, PO-GPO, PS - Kotwali, Dist. Ranchi.
3. General Manager (Personnel/IR), Central Coalfields
Limited, Darbhanga House, PO - GPO, PS-Kotwali,
Dist. - Ranchi.
4. General Manager, Dhori Area of CCL, PO - Dhori, PS
Bermo, Dist. - Bokaro.
5. Project Officer, Tarmi OCP/ SDOCM under Dhori
Area of CCL, PO-Bhandaridah, PS - Bermo, Dist Bokaro.
..... Respondent(s)
….…..
CORAM:
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEEPAK ROSHAN
….…
For the Petitioner(s)
For the Respondent
C.A.V. ON: 04/05/2026
: Mr. Rahul Kumar, Advocate
Mr. Ajay Kr. Singh, Adv
: Mr. Anoop Kr. Mehta, Adv
Mr. Shubham Malviya, Adv
PRONOUNCED ON: 22/06/2026
1.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
2.
In the instant writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for
the following reliefs:(i)
For Quashing Order of Dismissal dated 16/17.12.2021
passed by Respondent No. 5 although no oral or
documentary evidence was produced to prove the charges in
the Departmental Proceeding;
(ii)
For Quashing the Order in Appeal dated 03.06.2022
passed by the Respondent No. 2 whereby the Appellate
Authority has affirmed the Order of Dismissal;
(iii)
Upon setting aside the order of dismissal since
affirmed in appeal the Respondents be directed to make
2026:JHHC:18250
payment of unpaid salary for the month of December 2021
and also to make payment of all retiral benefits including
Gratuity, Provident Fund and Pension under CMPS 1998,
Leave Encashment, etc. on his attaining age of
superannuation on 31.12.2021.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that that the mother of
petitioner Smt. Jirwa Kamin was appointed as a Piece Rated
Worker at Dhori Colliery on 17.08.1972 and in her place and
upon her application under voluntary retirement scheme,
which had been approved, the petitioner had been appointed on
19.06.1980 and for 39 long years, the petitioner worked
uninterruptedly.
4.
On receiving a Complaint from one Ajay Ghasi on
09.02.2019, the petitioner was served Chargesheet by the
Respondent No. 5 alleging that the petitioner has secured
employment in the year 1980 by falsely representing himself to
be son of Jagdeo Bhuiya.
5.
After receipt of the Chargesheet dated 09.02.2019, the
petitioner submitted his reply dated 12.03.2019 denying the
charges. Thereafter, Respondent No. 5 by his Enquiry Memo
No. 1789 dated 30.03.2019, held that the reply to the Charge
Sheet
submitted
by
the
petitioner
on
12.03.2019
is
unsatisfactory and accordingly appointed Inquiry Officer and a
total of 18 sittings were held by the Inquiry Officer; however,
not a single witness was examined.
Thereafter, the Disciplinary Authority, enclosing a
2026:JHHC:18250
copy of the Enquiry Report, called upon the petitioner to submit
his response to the 2nd Show Cause Notice and petitioner in
response to the 2nd Show Cause Notice submitted his
representation/reply wherein he had pointed out that in the
Enquiry Proceedings not a single witness has been examined by
the Management; nor any document has been proved and
marked as Exhibit. Even thereafter, the punishment of
‘dismissal from service’ has been imposed upon the Petitioner
whereafter he had submitted his Appeal before the Director
(Personnel), the Appellate Authority on 31.01.2022. Even in the
Appeal the Petitioner has highlighted that in the Enquiry
Proceedings not a single witness has been examined by the
Management, nor any document has been proved; however, the
Appellate Authority by his order dated 03.06.2022 has
dismissed the appeal without considering the points raised in
the Appeal.
6.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the
Petitioner had brought on record 8 number of documents
including his service sheet, CCL ID, Bank Account, Aadhar
Card, PAN Card, Death Certificate of his mother Jirwa Kamin,
death certificate of Jagdeo Bhuiyan and Employee Benefit Relief
Fund (EBRF) Form of Jirwa Kamin, and the Management has
also relied upon 5 number of documents, which are, the service
register of Jagdeo Bhuiyan, his LTC Form, Gratuity Form and
2026:JHHC:18250
the service register of Jirwa Kamin.
However, he further submitted that, the Inquiry
Officer submitted his report dated 30.11.2021 holding that the
petitioner has been appointed in place of his mother, although
the charge had been for the father. The Inquiry Officer also held
that despite of several notices, the Complainant had not
appeared and that in the proceeding one officer from Personnel
Department ought to have been engaged in view of the nature of
the allegation and documents submitted by the Petitioner.
7.
Per contra, learned counsel for the respondents argued
that the Court under Article 226 and 227 of the Constitution of
India cannot re-appreciate the evidences and in a Departmental
Proceeding, the finding is based upon preponderance of
probabilities. He further highlighted the fact that the petitioner
has approached this Court vide W.P.(S) No. 2520 of 2019
challenging the Memo of Charges which has been dismissed
and the order passed has been upheld.
8.
Learned counsel for the respondents also submitted that
in the Departmental Enquiry, reasonable opportunity of hearing
by issuing Show Cause has been given to the petitioner.
9.
In the aforesaid background, the issue for consideration
before this Court is that in absence of examination of oral
witness, whether the documents can be relied upon to prove
the charges levelled against the Petitioner. Furthermore, can
2026:JHHC:18250
the Disciplinary Authority look into the charges not originally
framed and can rely upon documents not proved to hold the
Petitioner guilty and can dismiss him on the basis of charges
not proved.
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner amongst other grounds
contended that no oral witness has been examined in this case.
He further draws attention of the Court towards the chargesheet and the enquiry report and submitted that oral witness
has not been examined in order to prove the charges against
the delinquent and now it is a settled law that any document is
to be proved by the oral evidence. He further relied on several
judgments of the Hon’ble Apex Court including one recent
judgment in Jai Prakash Saini v. Managing Director, U. P.
Cooperative Federation Ltd. and Others reported in 2026
SCC Online SC 505.
11. Learned counsel for the respondents though supports the
impugned order but could not point out that any oral witness
had been examined in order to prove the charge / documentary
evidence.
12. At this stage it is pertinent to mention here that the law in
this regard is well settled that any document has to be proved
by oral evidence. As a matter of fact, an Inquiry officer has to
act as an umpire and not as a representative of the
respondents.
2026:JHHC:18250
13. Having heard learned counsel for the parties and after
going through the documents available on record; admittedly,
in this case no oral witness has been examined in order to
prove the document/charges levelled against the petitioner. The
issue of examination of oral witness has been dealt repeatedly
by the Hon’ble Apex Court right from the case of Roop Singh
Negi v. Punjab National Bank (2009) 2 SCC 570 and further
reiterated in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh v. Saroj
Kumar Sinha (2010) 2 SCC 772. However, it has been seen in
many cases that the authorities have not yet understood the
importance of evidence of oral evidence.
14. Thereafter, again in the case of Satyendra Singh Vs.
State of Uttar Pradesh and Another reported in 2024 SCC
OnLine SC 3325, the Hon’ble Apex Court has held as under:
“14…..
14.Indisputably, a departmental proceeding is
a quasi-judicial proceeding. The enquiry officer
performs a quasi-judicial function. The charges
levelled against the delinquent officer must be
found to have been proved. The enquiry officer
has a duty to arrive at a finding upon taking
into consideration the materials brought on
record by the parties. The purported evidence
collected
during
investigation
by
the
investigating officer against all the accused by
itself could not be treated to be evidence in the
disciplinary proceeding. No witness was
examined to prove the said documents. The
management witnesses merely tendered the
documents and did not prove the contents thereof.
Reliance, inter alia, was placed by the enquiry
officer on the FIR which could not have been treated
as evidence.
15. We have noticed hereinbefore that the only basic
evidence whereupon reliance has been placed by the
2026:JHHC:18250
enquiry officer was the purported confession made
by the appellant before the police. According to the
appellant, he was forced to sign on the said
confession, as he was tortured in the police station.
The appellant being an employee of the Bank, the
said confession should have been proved. Some
evidence should have been brought on record to
show that he had indulged in stealing the bank
draft book. Admittedly, there was no direct
evidence. Even there was no indirect evidence.
The tenor of the report demonstrates that the
enquiry officer had made up his mind to find him
guilty as otherwise he would not have proceeded on
the basis that the offence was committed in such a
manner that no evidence was left.
.…
19. The judgment and decree passed against the
respondent in Narinder Mohan Arya case [(2006) 4
SCC 713 : 2006 SCC (L&S) 840] had attained
finality. In the said suit, the enquiry report in the
disciplinary proceeding was considered, the same
was held to have been based on no evidence. The
appellant therein in the aforementioned situation
filed a writ petition questioning the validity of the
disciplinary proceeding, the same was dismissed.
This Court held that when a crucial finding like
forgery was arrived at on evidence which is non est
in the eye of the law, the civil court would have
jurisdiction to interfere in the matter. This Court
emphasised that a finding can be arrived at by the
enquiry officer if there is some evidence on record.
…”
(emphasis supplied)
15. Same view was reiterated in State of Uttar Pradesh v.
Saroj Kumar Sinha, wherein, this Court held that even in
an ex-parte inquiry, it is the duty of the Inquiry Officer to
examine the evidence presented by the Department to
find out whether the unrebutted evidence is sufficient to
hold that the charges are proved. The relevant
observations made in Saroj Kumar Sinha are as
follows:—
“28. An inquiry officer acting in a quasi-judicial
authority is in the position of an independent
adjudicator. He is not supposed to be a
representative
the
department/disciplinary
authority/Government. His function of is to
examine the evidence presented by the
Department, even in the absence of the
delinquent official to see as to whether the
unrebutted evidence is sufficient to hold that
the charges are proved. In the present case the
2026:JHHC:18250
aforesaid procedure has not been observed.
Since no oral evidence has been examined the
documents have not been proved, and could not
have been taken into consideration to conclude
that the charges have been proved against the
respondents.
….
33. As noticed earlier in the present case not only
the re spondent has been denied access to
documents sought to be relied upon against him, but
he has been condemned unheard as the inquiry
officer failed to fix any date for conduct of the
enquiry. In other words, not a single witness
has been examined in support of the charges
levelled against the respondent. The High
Court, therefore, has rightly observed that the
entire proceedings are vitiated having been
conducted in complete violation of the
principles of natural justice and total
disregard of fair play. The respondent never had
any opportunity at any stage of the proceedings to
offer an explanation against the allegations made in
the charge-sheet.”
(emphasis supplied)
15. Recently, the same issue was raised before the Hon’ble
Apex Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh through
Principal Secretary, Department of Pachayati Raj, Lucknow
Vs. Ram Prakash Singh 2025 SCC OnLine SC 891 and the
Hon’ble Apex Court after going through several previous
judgments has reiterated the law as under:
“13. In Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank, it was
held that an officer conducting an enquiry has a duty to
arrive at findings in respect of the charges upon taking into
consideration the materials brought on record by the
parties. It has also been held therein that any evidence
collected during investigation by an investigating officer
against the accused by itself could not be treated to be
evidence in the disciplinary proceedings.
14. What follows from a conjoint reading of the above two
decisions is and what applies here is that, ‘materials
brought on record by the parties' (to which consideration in
the enquiry ought to be confined) mean only such materials
2026:JHHC:18250
can be considered which are brought on record in a manner
known to law. Such materials can then be considered legal
evidence, which can be acted upon. Though the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872 is not strictly applicable to departmental
enquiries, which are not judicial proceedings, nevertheless,
the principles flowing therefrom can be applied in specific
cases. Evidence tendered by witnesses must be recorded in
the presence of the delinquent employee, he should be given
opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and no
document should be relied on by the prosecution without
giving copy thereof to the delinquent - all these basic
principles of fair play have their root in such Act. In such
light, the documents referred to in the list of documents
forming part of the annexures to the chargesheet, on which
the department seeks to rely in the enquiry, cannot be
treated as legal evidence worthy of forming the basis for a
finding of guilt if the contents of such documents are not
spoken to by persons competent to speak about them. A
document does not prove itself. In the enquiry, therefore, the
contents of the relied-on documents have to be proved by
examining a witness having knowledge of the contents of
such document and who can depose as regards its
authenticity. In the present case, no such exercise was
undertaken by producing any witness.
15. We may further refer to the decision of this Court in
State of Uttar Pradesh v. Saroj Kumar Sinha17 where
disciplinary proceedings were drawn up against the
respondent, Saroj Kumar Sinha, under the 1999 Rules itself
with which we are concerned. Paragraphs 26 to 30 and 33
of the said decision being relevant are quoted below:
“26. The first inquiry report is vitiated also on the
ground that the inquiry officers failed to fix any date
for the appearance of the respondent to answer the
charges. Rule 7(x) clearly provides as under:
‘7. (x) Where the charged government servant does not
appear on the date fixed in the inquiry or at any stage
of the proceeding in spite of the service of the notice on
him or having knowledge of the date, the inquiry officer
shall proceed with the inquiry ex parte. In such a case
the inquiry officer shall record the statement of
witnesses mentioned in the charge-sheet in absence of
the charged government servant.’
27. A bare perusal of the aforesaid sub-rule shows
that when the respondent had failed to submit the
explanation to the charge-sheet it was incumbent upon
the inquiry officer to fix a date for his appearance in
the inquiry. It is only in a case when the government
servant despite notice of the date fixed failed to appear
that the inquiry officer can proceed with the inquiry ex
parte. Even in such circumstances it is incumbent on
the inquiry officer to record the statement of witnesses
mentioned in the charge-sheet. Since the government
2026:JHHC:18250
servant is absent, he would clearly lose the benefit of
cross-examination of the witnesses. But nonetheless in
order to establish the charges the Department is
required to produce the necessary evidence before the
inquiry officer. This is so as to avoid the charge that
the inquiry officer has acted as a prosecutor as well as
a judge.
28. An inquiry officer acting in a quasi-judicial
authority is in the position of an independent
adjudicator. He is not supposed to be a representative
of the department/disciplinary authority/Government.
His function is to examine the evidence presented by
the Department, even in the absence of the delinquent
official to see as to whether the unrebutted evidence is
sufficient to hold that the charges are proved. In the
present case the aforesaid procedure has not been
observed. Since no oral evidence has been examined
the documents have not been proved, and could not
have been taken into consideration to conclude that the
charges have been proved against the respondents.
29. Apart from the above, by virtue of Article 311(2) of
the Constitution of India the departmental enquiry had
to be conducted in accordance with the rules of natural
justice. It is a basic requirement of the rules of natural
justice that an employee be given a reasonable
opportunity of being heard in any proceedings which
may culminate in punishment being imposed on the
employee.
30. When a departmental enquiry is conducted against
the government servant it cannot be treated as a
casual exercise. The enquiry proceedings also cannot
be conducted with a closed mind. The inquiry officer
has to be wholly unbiased. The rules of natural justice
are required to be observed to ensure not only that
justice is done but is manifestly seen to be done. The
object of rules of natural justice is to ensure that a
government servant is treated fairly in proceedings
which may culminate in imposition of punishment
including dismissal/removal from service.
33. As noticed earlier in the present case not only the
respondent has been denied access to documents
sought to be relied upon against him, but he has been
condemned unheard as the inquiry officer failed to fix
any date for conduct of the enquiry. In other words, not
a single witness has been examined in support of the
charges levelled against the respondent. The High
Court, therefore, has rightly observed that the entire
proceedings are vitiated having been conducted in
complete violation of the principles of natural justice
and total disregard of fair play. The respondent never
had any opportunity at any stage of the proceedings to
offer an explanation against the allegations made in
2026:JHHC:18250
the charge-sheet.”
(emphasis supplied)
16. It appears that the appellant is yet to take lessons
despite the admonition in Saroj Kumar Sinha (supra). The
same kind of omissions and commissions that led to setting
aside of the order of punishment imposed being upheld by
this Court were repeated in the present case.”
16. After going through the materials on record and the
judgments placed by the Learned Counsels, this Court is
having no hesitation in holding that the oral witness is
necessary to prove the documents and the charges levelled
against the delinquent employee, which is absent in the instant
case.
17. Furthermore, it has been admitted in the Enquiry Report
itself that the Complainant had not been examined and
considering the nature of dispute in the enquiry, an employee of
personnel department should have been nominated which
proves that there had been no evidence. The documents as
relied upon has not at all been proved or discussed in the
Enquiry Report, making it inconclusive in nature and hence,
the order of punishment of dismissal dated 16/17.12.2021 and
the order passed by the Appellate Authority dated 03.06.2022
is fit to be interfered and set aside.
18. Accordingly, for the reasons recorded hereinabove, the
impugned Order of Dismissal dated 16/17.12.2021 and Order
in Appeal dated 03.06.2022 are hereby quashed and set aside.
2026:JHHC:18250
19. It has been informed that the Petitioner herein had
attained the age of superannuation on 31.12.2021 itself and in
view of the order of punishment and the order passed by the
Appellate Authority being set aside and quashed, the Petitioner
is entitled for the entire monetary and terminal benefits.
20. Thus, the Respondents are directed to verify the records of
the case and pay the entire monetary benefits within a period of
12 weeks from the date of receipt of copy of this order.
21. Accordingly, the writ application stands allowed in the
aforesaid terms. Pending I.A.(s), if any, also stand closed.
(Deepak Roshan, J.)
Dated:22 /06/2026
Amardeep/
A.F.R
Uploaded on
25.06.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review