Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-,-
lJ,
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Speciat Originat Jurisdiction)
[ 348s ]
THURSDAY, THE TWELFTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE P.SAM KOSHY
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO
WRIT PETITION NOS: 28703 AND 28716 0F 2025
W.P.NO: 28703 OF 2025
Between:
Lateef Rahman Sharfan, S/o_ M A Salam Sharfan, Aged about 45 years, OccBusiness, R/o. H.No.17-3-38'l/6. lmlibun, yakutpura,-Hyderabad - 500 023.
...PETITIONER
AND
Unron of lndia, IMinistry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Through
Enforcement .Drrectorate, 6th Floor, Lok Nayak Bhavan, New Delhil 110 003
Pirectorate of Enforcement, tVlinistry of Finance Government of India,
Hyderabad Zonal Office, 3rd Floor,-shakar Bhawan, Basheerbagh,
Hydelabad - 500004 Represented by its Deputy Director
TheAdjudicating Aulhor{y under the Preventioh of Money Laundering Act.
2002 Jeevandeep _Building, 4th Floor, Sandad Marg, New Delhi.
Represented by its Chairperson.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, one more particularly in
the nature of Writ of [\Iandamus to call for the records relating to
EClRlHYZol20l2023 dated 31 .03.2023 registered under the prevention of
Money Laundering Act,2002,pending before the Respondent No.2 including the
Order under Section 21 (1) of the PII/LA and proceedings vide PMLA/OA/
153lDELl2025 pending before the Respondent No.3 as being illegat, arbitrary,
and without jurisdiction and consequently set aside all the proceedings in relation
to ECIR/HYZOl2ol2023 dated 31.03.2023 against the petitioner including ail the
consequential impugned proceedings arising therefrom.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
I
I
Petition under Section .1 51 CPC praying that in tht: circumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High C(,r rt may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings in respect of EC lR/HYZO l20l','. 23 dated 31.03.2023
pending before Respondent No.2 Enforcement Directorat: including not to take
any coercive steps or proceedings against the Petitioner, l), nding disposal of the
above writ petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under section 1 51 cPC praying that in th€ rircumstances stated
in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High ccL.t may be pleased to
stay all further proceedings in connection with pMLA/oA I
3lDELtZo2s pending
before the Respondent No.3 against the petitioner, pe I iing disposal of the
above writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRt G.ASHOK REDDY FOR SRt JAKKULA VAMSHI
KRISHNA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 3: SRI B.MUKHERJEI FOR
SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Solicitc r Generat of lndia
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Ms. pRANATHI KARUTL RI FOR
SRI D.NARENDAR NAIK, si( ; FoR ED
W.P.NO: 28716 OF 2o25
Between:
1. Abdul Rahman Sharfan, S/o. M A Salam Sharfan, Agerl about 50 years, Occ.
-Business, R/o. H. No.'17-3-381/6, lmlibun, yakutpura,"H,r lerabad _ SOO
OZS.
2. lvlohammed Abdul Shukoor, S/o. Late M A W;heed tged aboui 6S-Vears,
Occ. Business, R/o. H.No.'17-'l -375t261Mt1, plot No. 4 ;r id 5, We Virat f.fagai,
Laxmi Enclave, Hyderabad, Telangana.
...PETIT|ONERS
AND
t !11on of lndi4 Ministry of Finance, Department of Rever -re, Through
tnforcement Directorate, 6th Floor, Lok Nayak Bhavan, lew Delhil 110 003
2, Directorate of Enforcement, Ministry of Finance Govern r ent of india,
Hyderabad Zonal Office, 3rd Floor,-shakar Bhawan, Ba s reerbagh,
H.yderqpad - 500004 Represented by its Deputy Director
^ TheAdjudicating
Authority un.der the preventioh of Mon: I Laundering Act,
2002, Jeevandeep Building, 4th Floor, Sandad Marg, Nr: v Oelfri, Rep"resenteO
by its Chairperson.
...RESPONDENTS
{
-
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue an appropriate Writ, Order or direction, one more particularly in
the nature of Writ of Mandamus to call for the records relating to
EClRlHYZ0l20l2023 daled 31.03-2023 registered under the Prevention of Money
Laundering Act, 2002,pending before the Respondent No 2 including the Order
under Section 21 (1) ot the PII/LA and proceedings vide PMLA/OAl 153tDELt2025
pending before the Respondent No.3 as being illegal, arbitrary, and without
jurisdiction and consequently set aside all the proceedings in relation to
EClRlHYZOl20l2023 dated 31.03.2023 against the Petitioners including all the
consequential impugned proceedings arising therefrom.
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings in respect of ECIR/HYZO12012023 dated 31.03.2023
pending before Respondent No.2 Enforcement Directorate including not to take
any coercive steps or proceedings against the Petitioner, pending disposal of the
above writ petition.
lA NO: 2 OF 2025
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to stay
all further proceedings in connection with PMLA/OA/ 153lDELl2025 pending
before the Respondent No.3 against the Petitioners, pending disposal of the above
writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI G.ASHOK REDDY FOR SRI JAKKULA VAMSHI
KRISHNA
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 3: SRI B.MUKHERJEE FOR
SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Solicitor General of lndia
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Ms. PRANATHI KARUTURI FOR
SRI D.NARENDAR NAIK, SC FOR ED
The Court made the following: COMMON ORDER
I'agc -i o[ 33
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TE] ANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI T USTICE P .SAM KOS ,]IY
AND
THE HO N'BLE SRI TUSTICE S U DDAI-ACHALA-.) \THI RAo
W.P.N o.28703 AND 28716 of2025
DATE:12.02.2026
Bctwecn :
[,atccI Rahrnan SI'rarfan irncl othct s
Petr tioncr
,\ND
Union o[ India,
N{inistry of Financc, I)cpartment of llcvenuc,
'f hrough Enforcemcut I)itcctot-ate,
6rr, liloor, [,ok Navak Bhavan,
Ncw Dclhi - 110 003 ancl 2 othcts.
Rcspondents
COMMON ORDER: (lo ttt Ltot l)h .\ .lanl. P.\ot Ko:/t;)
I leard N{r. (}.-\shol< ltcddt', lcarnccl couuscl ztPPcz I ng on bchalf
of NIr. Takkula Yarnslri Krishna, lcatncd counscl ti )r' I ru pcritiorrer;
NIr. l].N[ukhcr1ec, Icarnccl cottnscl tcprcscntiLrQ -\Ir' N l huianga ltao'
leatned Deputy' St>licitor (lencral oI India fcrr tcspond'l r: Nos l & 3,
and N'ts. Ptanathi l(aruturi, Iearned counse I
tcprcsenting
I)aqc I cif 33
l\lr. l).Narcrrdar Naik, lcarned Stancling (loLrnscl [rrr I']nlcrrccment
Dircctotatc ti.rr rcsllonclcrl t No-2
2.
,l,hc
insrant \,rit pctitions har.c bcen tilcd by thc pctitioncrs
undcr ,\ruclc 226 ol thc (.onstitrrtion of India praf ing thc
(-ourt [t'r
the ftrllorving rclic f/ s, viz.,
".........lo ii.ttt, t.t Ltf)PrlfiLttl' ll it. Orrh'r rtr lir-(i/tott' 0 ( nar ptrlita/ar11'
trt llte nttttrrt tl ll:'itl rtl ,\l,rtt,l.uttr.s trt ;d// /br lLr rttard'r ruhring to
i
I
I
F-CIR/ t|YZO/20/202) dttL,! ,t.0i.202i rtgi'tttnl undtr th Prttttttion
ol' ,\lont-y' I ttrrruL'nrrq . 1.1, )00)' \lrliq hr.litrr' lhe llespo ctt No 2
itthuling lhe Onler anltr -\'tttutn 2 | (l ) ttl tfu Pl'lL'| und t'ronulitg'r idt
P.\'il)/O.'1/ I ; ) /DI:l -/ 202; 2tttditry bt|on lrc lltipondtnt Xo ) as being
'ttq ?nt/1' ttt u lt d/ tlte
i/legt1, arbifra4', tttrr! wilhrttt Vtri'litli0tt tt'd
agairttt
prottr:tlit4qs irt rtlutirtn to I:LIRIIt\'1-O/:0I202) rlartd )I0)'202)
tlt ItL'tiiorter rntlutlir4q ,r/l lltt crttt.;ttlrtut/itt/ intft4qrul f'roudirtXi 'n'iirt.1
llrtrt-f iottt and p,rt .tuch .ltrrlfur or o/lttr (lrtltr! d'i t/'i'; l lrtt'ltl"
lit rrnl Itropr itt lbe -litti ul
( omt ntJ detnt
cir,rnt-;ltttrtt; aJ /ht t'rt"' in lhe inrrrttls of'
FACTS TN \(.P.No ) 8703 of 2025
3.
The bricf hcts of tlre casc :lrc that thc petiuorrcr hcrcin lras
bccn irnplicated ir-r an I'.ttfotccnrcut (.ase In[<rrrnauorr Rcport (F](-fR)
bearingFI(.IR/FIYZO/20/2023.datcd31032023,initiatcdbvthe
i
I
Pagc 5 of 33
Irnlirrccmcnt L)irt ctoletc i.c. rt'spondcnt No.2 unclc'r I r. I)rcvcntron
oi Nloncy Latrnclt ring \ct, 2002 (tbr short rhc 'Ptrll
\ct) rvit hout
all\ tenlible cviclencc. marcrial particulars, or ncxlrs linlir,4 hrm to anv
allcgcci procccds r.,l-crimc or prcdicatc offencc.'lhe pt,tL, r.,rcr subrnits
that hc is thc lari ttl ou,trer of land bcaling Sun c
\o t9-l/.5/ 1,
situatt rl in I rrravclli Villegc, \hclrararn ,\landal, Itanga i - rlth Disr rict,
rvlrtch is l'rclcl urrrlcr valitl parra and is enrirelr tlis ir-'r liorn the
disputccl Ilhoodan lancls alleuc<llv involvcd in thr irrr r:stisation
Dcsl.>itc having no intclcst, ()vncrship, c()1rtr()1,
(tl:
irrvolr.cn'rcnt
whafs()cvcr in tlrt saicl clisptrtcd lands, thc petilr( l ( r has bccn
subjcctcd t() search and scizurc ()pcrations rncreh' or .r r,--( )unt ()f his
inciclcntal prcscncc at thc rcsidcntial prcrniscs oI hrs l r, rrlx'r \lrtlul
Ilahtnan at Imlibtrrr, \hktrtpura, Ilvdcrabad, during rlrt 'otrr.se of rhe
scarch conrluctecl bl thc lto ti rrccrncnt l)ircctorat(.. os,evcr, the
I)ctiti()r)cr hacl no rlircct or indirCct orvflcrshil'r, coltti ( I or. bcncflcial
intercst in an1, of thc entitics, acc()unts, [ransactions, (,r ] r1)l)(.rucs that
arc thc sub,cct mattcr of thc prcscnt enc1uir1., and that I , r-cccir-cd onl),
Paee 6 of 33
prolessional lecs lor his services
compliancc rvith all applicablc
FAC TS IN w. P.N o.
-['hc
rvhich rvcre dulv accounted
[or in
m_\ad()n ard rcglrlarorl, nortns_
716 of 20 25
pctirioncrs hcrcin arr. thc 621e12kcrs
of propcrucs bclonging
to L,{ohd. Xlunarvar Khan_ l,he linlorcement
respondenr No.2 has initiated
I)ircctorate i.c
procccclings agarost them
under the
PNIL;\ r\ct in conncction rvirh
li(l[t/t NZO/20/2023. dated
31.03.2023, despitc the fact
that the pcritioncrs are nor accused
alleged predicatc offence, which
has becn closcd bl the Invcstr,garing
Agencv as being civil in nature.
ailegcdlv unaurh()rized oFficer,
photocopics oF rcgistered dccds
During a search concluctcd bv
-50
an
certain clocurncnts inclucling
rvere scizcd, none of rvhich
procecds.rt crimc- 1'he petiri..ers
givc statemcnts under St:ction
in thc
constitute
\!crc sr'unroucd ancr c.tn,crlccr
to
,,i rhc lr.\ll_ \ \ct unclcr cocrcivc
tactlcs
C
N
TION SOF THE ETITION ER IN W. P.N
703 of
Learncd co..scl fbr tire petitio,er
co.tended that
i
lre has .eithcr
bccn named as an accusccl in
the I,.lR tcgisterecl rn reladcr,n-to thc
l
I
Page 7 ol 3i)
ptcclicatc oflcncc ltor has hc bccn chargc-shceted bv anr
r\.cs tlga t1f1g
xgcnc\'. '1'hc final rcPort filed bl thc lnvcstrgating - \ I :ncr in thc
l)rcclicate oifencc clcarlr, tccords
that the dispute is ol'I civtl naturc
ancl no ctirninalitr is made out. Thercforc, the vcty lir Lnclatiot'r lirr
iniriating procccditrgs undcr the PNILA :\ct is abs.: rr, and thc
c()n tilrrltti( )
n of such proceedings is rvholh' illcgal nd r,u,itl.rout
jurisrtictkrn.'['hc prcdicatc oftcnce forms tlrc vert' ftrutlt rtiorr oi thc
l).\ [ .
\ procuedings, and in its absencc, thc machint t ,' undcr the
Plll..\ \ct crnu()[ bL] sct ifl motion.'Ib substantiate this : -gulrcfl t, tllc
lcarnccl counscl iirr the pctitioner relicd on thc iutli; rcnt oi
thc:
Hou'[>lc Su;rretnc Court in Vilay Madanlal Choudhat ,, vs. Union
of Incliar s hich holcls that in the abseucc o[ a prcdica t offencc, thc
jurrsdictiot of thc lln [orcetncflt Directorater under thc [. \ IL \ cannot
bc inr-okcd.'l'hus, pctitioncr has no contlcction trrhatstr . cr rvith rhc
tr?ulsrcti()ns or c\clcutlon clf cl<lcutnents bctrveen thc pat ics, tror docs
lrc have arl\ c()ttccrlt or itltetcst in thc subiect pttrl' -'rtl'. and trtr
pr,ccccls of ctit'ttc are allcged to bc in possesslon o[ thc r:tilroncr.
I
' izot e1 t't scc't
Y
l'age tl o| 33
6.
,\ccording to thc leamed counscl lor thc pctitioncr, these
allcgatrons are mcreiv retterations of cornplaints alrcaclv adludicatcd bv
(lourts and ftruncl rvithorrt merit, bcrng repretiux' antl civil in natLrre,
r)ot warrantinll ir-rvesugatron under thc PNtl , \'l' \ct. .\ccording to th(.
.
learned counscl [<x thc pctiu<>ner, thc rcgisu:ation ol tjClR bv
respondent No.2 was illcgal and Lrntcnable and rcgisterccl solelr
bccause trIR No.83 oF 2023 contains a schcciulc offcnce- Flowcvcr. the
Investigating ,\ger-ro, in thc predrcate o[ttncc alrcadv Frlccl its Irinal
Repott clearly recording that the dispurc is civil in nature, ver
respondcnt No.2 conunued rvith thc inr.esugation u'r an illegal and
high handed manner.
I.
Lcarned counscl tirr the pedtioncr also dcnicd the lalsc
allegation tcgarding succcssion and parution. l [r. \arvab llohd. Ha ji
I{han was the absolute orvncl oF land in Sr,.No. I [il and 1U2, and
nominally giftcd land admcasuring Ac.4l 3l grs. in surr.cv numbers
181/4,181 /6, and 182 to \krhd. Farcxrq -\[i hhan firr agricultural land
ccrling purposcs under thc ;\gricultural Land Cciling.\ct, 1973. Afrer
li
rc\-cnlrc rccords sltorvcd that cettain lands rvere catcgc rizcd as Patta
lanrls $'tthottt chirls br rhc llhoodan Yapyra Boarcl, \lr r'au ab \fohcl'
t{aii t{tian validlv giitccl land admeasuring Ac 5l ? I gts' to his
daughtcr Srnt. I{hadcr Unnlsa on 15.04.2004. Subsccptr tlv, a paruuon
rlcccl rvas c\ccutcd <tn 04.02.2014 arrd r:atifiecl by NIr' Ir r ooq
"\[i
Khan
<rt 2l .(tI.20Il, a[1cr rvhich Pattedar passbooks rver'' obtaincd aflcl
lln.ls scrt r,,ltl lr lrt r tlrt ir tttct'ssirir.s.
8.
Lcartrcd cc.,ltnsel lc.,r the pctitioncr contendcd th: t tlrc
-lelangana
Bhoodar Yagna llorrd passed an order dated 28 0: l'125 clirccung
rcstt>ratitttt of Iencls as 1]hoodan lands, which rvas lrallcngccl rzZ
\{iP.\o.7rl0 oi 1025, rvhctein lcarned Singlc Juclgc- !,8 ordcr darcd
13.01.202-a <lircctccl Rcr cnuc ,\uthoritics to maintair.t t'ttrrs qno in' ;il
rcsp(cts trll clisposal of thc said \{iP 'I'hcrefcrrc, tlr' Investigating
\gcncr' catrtrot assttlrlc ltLrisclicuon to conduct a pare I ') inlt'stigation
to clc:cidc civrl ritlc of thc propcrq' during pendcucr ' '
\\ rit petiti.ns
bcfirrc thc Hot'l;lc Fligh Court. Thus, this careless :1 proach o[ the
rcspondctrts slrows that tlrc invcstigation is sham.
EF
\
l)agc 10 o[ 33
9.
Learned colrnscl for the peririofler further contefldcd that there
exists nc.r pima facie marerial evidcnce co,nccti.g the petiti,r'rer witrr
anr''procccds of crime'as deEnccl unclcr Sccriorr 2(i)(u) oi rhc plll_:\
lct. -fhc vcry fourrdation for assurning jur.isdiction under rhc p\II,..\
-,\ct [es in the cxistencc o[ proceeds oF crirnc, rvhich is naLrow.lt.
circurnscribcd to properq,- derivcd or obtaincd, cli_t-ccrlv or indirerctly,, as
a rcsult oi criminal activirv relaung to a schedulccl offencc. in thc
prcscl1t case , thc only articic se izecl l.rom t he pctinone r tvas his
personal mobile phone, nameh, Samsung Cialaxv \5.1, ]Ioclcl Name:
SXI .\54611 DS, along u,irh an active SI\,I carcl, t,hich uas in his
possession and used for routinc pcrsonal communication.'l'hcrc is no
rnaterial rvhatsocl,er to shorv that this mobilc phonc constitutcs
ptocceds o[ crimc or has anv connection rvith anr allcgccl crirninal
activitv. 'l'he peutioner has no manncL of conncction, cither dircct or
indirect, rvith the cntiues, bank accounts, uansactions, or inrrnovable
propetucs that are norv being ffe,rtcd as thc subjcct rratter oi cnquirr.
unclcr thc PNILA ,\ct. 'fhc proccedirrgs proceed on vaguc and
s\\rccping asscrtions without anI cogcnt material p,uticulars
l
Pagc 11 of 33
c()nnccdng the pctittoncr l'ith the alleged
acts constitll' lg thc offelnce
of nrotrct latrtl rlc ritltr.
10. i,carned cttunscl lirr thc Peritioner fur ther col t
F'.nforccmcnt Dircctoratc has failccl to disclose
tl-rat torm the basis lirr rhc iniuadon o[
'ndccl that the
the 'rc r ons to believc'
thc ECIR antL :hc subscqucn t
scrrch ancl scizttrc rlllcratiorrs, thcrcbv dcpriving
thc : :ritioner oI his
funclamt:nta] right to bc hcercl and to challcnge
actron betirrc thc appropriatc lrrrum' The
th'' legalitv ol the
impull t tl action is in
Lsticc and thc
blatant viohtiotr of thc principies of natural i
constittrtional grlarlntccs crrshrincd under
Articies 1' ancl 21 ol the
(.onstitutroLr oi lrrclia \ccorcling to the lcarntrtl
pctiti()ncr, it is rr scttlcrl principlc of law that
scizcr undcr Scctit'tr 17
the po'r :r to search ancl
oi thc P\lt'A Act can onlv I t excrciscd b,v an
ar.rth()rizcd t t it'icct rr'ho hls 'f cason to
posscrssiott of atu- ptocecds oi
T'-n forccmct'tt
ounscl ftrr thc
believc' that ,nt pcrson is in
crime' In thc ) r:sctrt ctse, the
l)ircctoratt has neithcr discloscd tht: r .rs( )ns to belicvcl
llot- dcmonstmtc(l anv tnlrtctiai basis for forming
'f
suct bciict-. he mcrc
td]tt
Pagc 12 of 3.)
fact that Section 420 of IPC aPPears in thc schccltrlc to thc i)\[I.,\,\ct
ri.cs n<rt ip.rrt facto clothc the Enforccrncnt [)ircct6ratc rvith tlrc porvcr
to registcr an E(ll lt. The esscntial condiuon is thrt thetc must be
proceeds of crime and that such tainled P!:opcrn'is being Prolectcd as
untainted xs pcr the rcqukemcnts and ingrcdients of St:ction 3 of thc
P\t] . \ 1ct.
1l
'l'hr-rs, thc leatned counserl lot thc
Pctitioncr ptavccl that ther
cndrc pr()cccclings are arbiuat;,', unconstitutl()nal, anc.l liablc to bc
cluashccl and sct aside in thc intercsts of justicc.
e NTENTI
FT
ETITIO
R
IN W.
2 '|tG of
12. Lcarnecl coulsel for the pctitioncrs in this case submittet] that
thc petitioncrs beirrg merc caretakers oi thc propertics bcloncing trr
Niohd- trlutrarvar I(han, havc uo mlnner t,f corrttection, cither direct
()r i:rdircct, rvith thc enLittes, bank accouflts, ttrtrsactiotrs, r'r
irnrtror.alrlc properties that atc now being treatccl as the sublcct uattcr
of cn<1uirv unclct thc PNILA T\ct. The pctitioners havc never hcld, nor
clo thc1, prcscnthl hold anv owncrship, cotltrol, title, possession, or
l'age 13 of li3
bencficial intercst ttr ant' ctf thc said ProPertics or assct , rvl'rcthcr in
their individual tralnt's rlr itr assoctariorr wlth ln\r othell l crson. \t ntr
stagc havc [hc pcltitioncrs cntcrcd lnto anv arranl]emclr , financial or
other$''1sc, that t'oLrlcl cotrlcr upotl thcm any ec'r r,rmic s take,
adr.antagc, or sharc in thc clealings allcged by tl '
fespoudcflt
authorities. '['hcrc is als<t nrt llro fit sh:rrint mech2nis' r- undisclosccl
financial arr2tlgcmclrt, ltitlclctl ccotrotllic iuLcrest, ot '' cn a rcmote
Frnancial inr.oh.'emcnt c,i ant liirrd linking thc petitioncr I r,r thc allcged
actir.itics or thc l)cl's()lls:rccuscd oi such activiries'
13. Learned cottnscl tirr thr: petitiotrcrs furthct sul>rr ir,tccl that thc
matcrials sctzud cl,-rritrg thc scarclr contlrcted at the P 1 rnises do not
establish atrt'clcntt:trt of tnoltc\' laurlclcring or unlawhr]
part of thc pctitioncrs.
t:trvitr. on thc
'l hc tlocutncnts scizcd arc mcf ,photocopics
of tegistctcd ctccds ancl ()thcr PaPers related to tbe rropcrties oi
llohc[. Nlunarvar l''hatt, t Ilich thc PClitionets rvcre mritt aining ir-r their
capacitl as caretahcrs.
'l'he tncre posscssion of such
J I Pers does
not
bv anv sttctch of imagitration conslitute posscssion, ( ( rrcealuent, or
.,1
usc ()f pr()ceccls r.rf ctitnc
\ccorcling to the leatnccl couuscl for thc
peutioners, the Pctitioncrs ncither receivcd nor harrdlcd
procceds oi crin-rc, uor have thcv proiectcd or
PIoPcrN as r.rntainted.
anv allegcd
claitncd anY taiutcd
'l'hc cntrre allcgation that the peutroners arc
and nala .fide
mi.l,-llclncn (,r fa cililx tors lSa bald, unstrbs tantiated,
evidctldarv
assettl()tl rvithout anr, matcflal particulars or
support and
n() specl fic ncxus or indiviclualized rcasorrs havc bcen
rccordcd ()f
dcm()flstratecl to cstablish anv hnk bcnvccn thc
matcrials seized during
thc scrrch ancl the alk:ged proccecls o[ crirne'
o
IO
o T
E
No
PO DE TS
f
14. Learnctl counsel lcrr the rcspondcnts contcndcd that thcr
8(3) of thc
atrachmcnr and rcrcntion of propeth' under Sccriotr
l).\tl. \ -\ct is lcgalh valid and in accordance rvith
provisions. ( )ncc thc .\diudicating t\uthoritrr confitms
thc statutor\'
the attachment
of propcrrr trntlcr Scction B(3), such attachmeut contiuues during
inr.estigauon tbt a pcriod uot excecdinpl 365 da1's
thc
or uutll thc disposal
of thc prosccLruon comPlaint filcd beFore thc PNfl--\ Court'
as thc
-/
tl ,.'
[)anc 15 of .]3
casc lrla\r bc. Lcar.cr-l cotrnscl fttr rhc respondcnts rclir
( o. thc rccent
judgment of thc Ikrn'blc Suprcn-rc (-ourt in Union rri India vs.
J.p.
Singh2 which clarificci that rvhcrr an order undcr li ction 8(3) ot
PNILr\ ,{ct is passecl, thc orcler conlinucs till thc I sposal o[ the
r
complaint. In thc prr:scnr c:rsc, silrcc n( r prosecudon :omplaint has
been filcd yet, Lhc attachrnent orclcr rcmains in lorcc ()r a statutor\i
period of 365 dar s. It s'ls also strbmrrred that I r: petiuoner's
challengc to thc continuatiorr of atrachmcnt is mi:r c,nccived and
contrar\. to thc sctflccl lcgal PositroD.
15. I-carnccl co,:nscl firr thc rcsponden[s categol.tc I Ii, denicd the
pctitio,cr's cor-ltc,ti()ns tlrar thc sciztrrc.f r,.bi[c ph.rL, rvas unlarvful
or arbiuarv. 'l'[rc sublccr rnobilc plrone was sei; r cl strictl,,. in
accordance rvith thc pror isions oI the P\tl,A \,: ancl ptoper
proccd,rres rvenr lirlkr*ccl.'['ht: rctcl]ri()n of thc seizcc .obile ph..e
\Vas
sought rhrough ()ricinal \pplicarion N(,l. 153/20,1 trlcd betirrc
the ,\djudicating \utlprih', ancl the salne w?s dulv corr irmed by thc
Adiudicating Atrthorirv throusl] pronour)ccment of an r ral judgment.
CriminalAppeal No1102 of 2025, dated 05.03.2025
l'agc 1(r ol j3
'I'hus, thc scizurc tas n()t arbitrarv brrt rvas bascd on lniltcrial cr-idenct:
tnd was ncccssar\' [irr thc purposc of- ttn'cstigation. 'l ltc .\tlitrdicaung
'\uthoritr',
bcin.g the a1>propriatc totr:ttrt tttrdcr the Ptr[I-.\ scltclnc, has
alrcadl adjuclicatcd Lrpon this issu<', and the PctiLiunet cxnrlL,t
circunl'cnt this br approaching the I Iigh Court dirccth'.
16. l,carnccl corrnsel tirt tlte rcspotttlcnts firrther c()rltcndcd that tht
'feasorrs to bt lit vt:' ri't'rt' tirtrtttlecl r,rr crediblc, c()gclrt, and tangilllc
matcrial havirrg a dii't ct ncrtts r'.'it h thc proceeds oI critnc.
'.f
hc
rnatcrial criclcncc collcr:tccl dtrrirrg thc Irl\'estigation has a livc link rvith
thc 'rcasons to bclicvt' tirrtnctl bv tltc authorizcd ofFrccr, and all
actions rvcrc takcn in rccofclance rvith larv'. It was fut thcr c()tltclldclcl
that a dclicatc balatrct trust l)c ntaintirinc<l l>ctrvcctr thc rights oi
citizcns and tlrt trghts oi trrr cstiQating agcllcie s as tlre dlrtr
() t
thc
Iinf<;rcclncnt l)ircctorarc is to trttcarth ancl discovcr thc nl()cltls
operantli 1cs()rtcd to lrr t[re bcncficiaries o[ proceeds of crirre, ancl
rhis excrcisc crnu()t l)c utrcltrlv restrictcd. 'i'herelore, thc leamcd
counscl tirr thc rcsponclcnts subtnits that this I lt-rn'blc Court cann()t
l)age 17 of -33
4I
t
a{
g. into the clucsti.n of rvlicther rhc rnatcrial cr itl -, r,:c has a li'e [i'k
vhcn thc narrer has alrcaclv bcen decidccl br thc .\rljuclicating
,\uthoriry ar-rd thc periri()ncr has thc rcmcdr.
rpproaching thc
,r
Appcllate liibunal
.,
.:
tl
tx
17. Learncd counscl for the respondents submrrre I that thc pMLA
I
.'\ct cstablishes its rxvn corn p rch crrsir.e enfirrccrnt
t:
t
r r rnachirrcrt, and
other authoritics s.rth acljuclicaton. pos,crs atrtl LLrisclictron. -l,he
,
x
cnForcement machincrt, is conlctrccl rvith
t
&
i
E
T
rnresugauolr, rr.ith lrrrilt in sali.gu;rrrls to
irorvcrs e r I jurisdrction for
cnqr.,. lhir r ..,s. lrrnspxrcnc).,
and accountabilitv et all stagcs. .l''c plIL-\ \ct
.
I
,
t
statlrtorv r-ncchanisrn for apPcals :rgaiDsr the orde ,
r r,i \dludicatrng
.\uth<>rirv through the .\ppcllatc .l,ribuual.
t
I
i
pr, r rcics a complctc
.\ccorclrrr 1 ro thc learned
counscl for thc tcspr>nclc^ts, it is scrtlcd larv rlut
u,(l,r r schcrnc of an
Act rvhcre thcre rs a lricrarcl.n. of authorities b,- irrc
pctltiofler carl gct adcqLr:rte r.cc_lrcss, he shoulcl
lp r oach thc samc
authc)rtt)- rathcr than inr.oking rhe s,ri r jurisdictiorr
Court. In the prcscnt casc, the peddoncr has
\
rvhich the
, this I lon,ble
cornplc_, lr blpasse<J thc
l)agc 18 of 33
statutoi:v appcllate mechanism pro.'icled undet PN'fLA '\ct and has
dirccrh, approachccl this Courr thror-rgtr thc p[cscrrt rvrit pctition.
'I'he
lcarnccl coullscl tbt the rcsporltlents subrnits that since the '\ppellate
Tribunal has bccomc {ulh' fuflcu()oal, t}rc petitioncr should approach
thc r\diudicating '\uthotitv ()r thc \Ppellatc fribunal as providcd
undcr thc statutc. 'fhc Sullrcmc (,ourt's iLrdg-ncnt as citcd bv thc
pctitioner in Vilay Mandanlat Choudhary (supra) is not aPPlicable to
thc Facts of thc ptctscr1t casc becausc thosc cascs did not involvc
situauons rvhcrc a cornPlete statut()fv appcl1atc remcdl,
q,as ar.ailable
and had 6."n f 1'passccl.
1g. Learnecl counscl lor thc rcspoflclcrrt clcnied the petitioner's claim
that he [,as mefch, dragcccl into thc ltroccetlings due to prorimity oi
his tand of his prcsencc ar his brorhcr's rcsidcnce during thc search. It
was subn-ritted that the pctititlncr is delibcratclv misrepresenting facts
to mislcacl this coutt. l)uring rlrc coursc r-,f invesrigatron undcr the
PN{l,A Act, an order datccl 27.()1J.1997 passed b)' the Nlandal Revcnue
OfFrccr, Nlahe shrvaram Nlandal *''as disct.rvctctl, which clearlt'
mentions
Page 19 of 3.3
that (1) I{ohd. LatecF, (2) Nlohd , \bclul
.lavcccl, and (3) \ r.shi_r a Srrlrana
\\,erc [hc grandsons / claughrcr of ,\lohcl.
Zabardasth K I :ru. rhc tarht:r
o[ \-awab I Iaji l..]ran, rvh. had gii,en hibanama r.
Surr.ev No.194 admcasuring 26 acrcs
cstablish that thc pctiuoncr was part
rh.. rr lrrr lancl at
30 guntas. Ilir.; tlocr-nncnt
of the consprrac, oI acquiring
land through illcgaI rncans anci [orgerr.,
t:vco rhorrgl) ,)(. \\,as n()t
dircctlv c()nrlectc.l to NIohd. .l.a.barclasth
l{han *.h. ir tia,r ,rvnccl
land at Surr.cy Nos. 18 1 arrd 1g2. Ijurthennorc,
rclauve oi ,\bdut llahma, and NI.,\.
,\ khtar, rvho assr: r .:l \ Iuna*.ar
Khan and l(l-radcrunissa ir-r rhe illegal salc
collcctir.ch' rcccir.ccl procceds of crimc
also reas',ablc suspicio, that the
of s()vcrrrr r r rr lancl ancl
r.r,orth Rs.2.-l() cr r.r.s. .1.[rcrc is
pcdtroncr pla'ed a slg1, r(rart rorc i,
thc fabricati.' of lancr dr.rcuments relating
'l'herclirrc, the pcuti.ner's
t. S,rr.c' N.s . rr1 arcr i g2.
inr.,lvcmert in thc al,,i.cl 1n().c,\
launclcring activitrcs is not incidcntal
but substantivr: :rncl r r Lrcr.ial.
19. Lcarned coturscl for thc respondcr_rts lastly
petitioner's c,rtenriorr that actron
\
the 1,r 1i111yl1q1 1q .
subrni rr-i rhat thc
under pNILr\ r\ct car.r r bc rakc,
Page 2[) o[ 33
against him without being nanred as an accused in the FIR or being
charge-shcctcd is legaltv untctrable and retlccts a comPlctc
misundctstanding of thc P\11..\ -\ct framcs'ork. It is not flecessar)i
that a persofl against whorr act.ion utldcl Scction i7 of I)NILA Act is
taken or who is sutnmoned under Scctiotr 50 o I PtrIl,A \ct needs tcr
be named as an accused in the trll{ or sh,-,r-rlcl bc chargc sheeted in thc
predrcatc o[[ence. ln thc prescnt casc, acti()n lras lrccn takcn against
thc petitionet onl-y under Scctic.rns 17 and 50 of l)IlT..'\ '\ct' for which
he necd not nccessarily bc alt accusecl or c[ratgc- lreetcd in thc
s
predicate ofFcnce.
'l'hc investigation unclct [)IIL \ \cr is indepcndent
and distinct from thc invcstigauon in thc Preclicatc offcr-rcc. Reearding
the existcnce oI the prcdicltc <.,fFcncc, tllt: resprrtldcnts rciteratc that
I]IR No.B3/2023, datcd 1-i.03.2023, is sdll in cxistcncc as thc closure
fcport has flot beett acceptccl br tht' conrllt-'tcut lrrtlroritv. N{orcovct,
cven one schedulecl ofte ncc is suft-icicnt to initiarc a l)\ l[.A case' and
once thc PNll,A case ls registcred, thc invcstigation utrdcr PNILA '\ct
bccomcs distinct ancl difttrcnt front that of rhc predicate agencl" In
Pagc 21 of 33
the insmnt casc. sincc Section 420 of IPC was in\rokc I and the samc
bcins a schcdulcd offence, the present E(lIR rvas r.alitll rccorclcd
CONTENTIONS OF THE RESPONDENTS IN !i P.No.28716 of
20. -\ccording t() thc lcarncd counsel tbr the lr s rondcnts, the
contentions raisecl rrr \\{ I1 No. 28103 of 2025 arc also a1 irltcable to thc
prcscnt casc- Hon,cr.cr, the lollorving additional sulr r',issi,rns t'crc
maclc spccificallr- t.ith rcspcct to WP No. 28116 <tf 2l), -
.
21. ]-earned cotLtrsel for the respondent contenderl trat thc scetch
ancl scizutc opcral,iolls conductcd undcr Sccuon 17 ot rrc P\11,.\ .\ct
terrc carried out in sttict acc()rdance wrth the la,,r'. lrc aLrthorizcd
oit-iccr, rvas dull emporvcred by thc Joint Dircctor oi
rc I Ir de rabad
Zr>nal ()Ffrcc to crinduct the search and seized all tht: l rctu'ncnts and
Propcrtics, inclLLditrg rnobilc phoncs, were reler.ant t( ) L r irrr ustig:rtion
and had a dircct rrexus rvith the proceeds of crtnr:' Iirrrtlrer, tlrc
'rcasons to bc[cr-c' standatd tcquired under Scction ll !as nrct at tl]c
authorizatlon stagc, and ()nce authorized, the investrga'rg oif-icer rvas
not rcquirecl t<l ltrrtn'r scpalate rcasons fbr each scizur,r. litrrttrcrn'rolc,
.".**
Pagc 22 ot- 33
tLrc panchanama rvas propcrlv excclltecl rvith indcpcnclent rvitncsses, and
all procedural safeguards r,,.ere folkrrvccl dtrring rlrc sclrch and seizlttc
oPCrations.
22. Lcarned counsel fot resporrdents submtttccl that thc pctiuoncrs
and their family members wcre actir-c bencficiaries of procecds of
crimc amounting to Rs.2,30,00,000/ rvhtch t'as dirccrlv traccxble to
thc illegal sale oF government Bho()dan lancl.
'I l'rc monct' trail cleatlv
csrabLish that Rs.1,15,00,000/ cach s':rs t'cccivccl br' Ilohammed
Abdul Rahman and N{ohar-nmed \bclul .\khtar Fronr }Iunarvar I{han
and the buyets Q'.1. Santosh Kumar attcl Robbali Visrvanatha Reddl)
rnaking them maior beneltciaties in the criminal conspiracr'. It rvas
further submittcd that the statctrents rccordccl undcr Scction 50 of
PNTLA Act also wcrc voluntarv ancl rvithor-rt coerciott, as cvidenccd b1'
declata[iorrs made b,v the pctitioncrs tltcnlst'h cs.
ISSUES
23.
Flaving heard the contcflti()ns ptrt ltrrth on cithcr side and on
pcfusal o[ rccords, thc qucstiofr rhat:rrisc tirr consideration irr this writ
petlfions afc:-
Page 23 o[ 33
a) \\rhctlrcr thc rvrir pcdrion is maintainable irL [au' u'hcn a
corr-rplcrc statut()rl appellatc mechanism under rl r l)\[1..\ \ct is
availablc ancl functional, and thc pctrtioner has bl passed thc
salnc/
b) \X,hether ttre rcgistrarion of ECIR/HYZO/t','.1 /2023, da,red
i1.0-1.2021, and subscquent actions under Sectio r 17 aad 50 of
t[-rc PNI[.
\ \u arc arbitrarl,, illegal, or violatrr c rf \rticles 1'1
and 21 of thc Constituuon of India?
CONSIDERATION OF THE ISST]ES
21. \X,c arc o[ thc considcrcd opinlon that thc 1,, titroners havc
attcrnptctl
TO
circtrmr.cnt thc complete statutot\- ap1-r ilatc hrcrarcll'
enshrinccl unclcr Scctions 26 and 42 of the I']NIL-\ t:t bt clirectlr,
invoking the cr t r:rotclinarr- rvtit jurisdiction oI this .ourr without
cxhatrsting thc c it-rcacious alternativc remedtes availr rle r-rnclet tlrc
s ta
tutc
['hc [ [on'ble SLrprcme Cor.rtt has repeatcdh, t L rphasizcd that
rvrrt iurisdicuon under .\rticle 226 should not be exer:r i t:cl to strt'lc ()r
irnpede investigation oI cconomic offcnccs, pa]:t:( Lllarlr moncl
laundcririg rvl'rich has scrious national and intetnatior: ratnitlcatrotrs
Pagc 24 of 33
afld threatens the verv economic sccuriw and financial integrin' of the
natlon.
Furthct, thc pcdtroner [ras failed to dctnonstratc an\
compclling cffcumstances, jurisdictional crror or consritutional
violation that rvould warraflt bvpassing the statutotv appellate
mechanism and invoking thc discrctionarr rvrit juriscliction at tl-ris
nascent stagc of invcstigation. The matcrial on rccotcl irre futabh
cstabhshcs that the Ijnforcement Cornplaint Infcrttlarion Ilcpott
(.LCIIt) rvas validly registered on the basis oi a schcdr.rlc:d prcdicatc
offence registcrcd in Crimc No.B5 of 2021 urrclcr Section:120 of ll)C-,
rvhich relates to largcscalc illcgal alicnation of sovemmcnt lands
through lraudulent means involving multiplc accuscd persons
including the pcLttioner's familv n'rcn'rbcrs and busincss xss()cixtes. l'hc
investigatior-r has tevealed l urcll orclrcstratccl crirninal conspiracv
rvherein goverflmcnt lands mcant ltor rcdistribrrtion to lancllcss poot
under the Rhoodan Yagna movemellt \\rcrc s\ stcmaticallv and illcgalh
alicnatcd through fabtication of documcnts, rnanipulation oi rcr.cnuc
rccords, impersonation, and crcauon of ftauclulent titlc chains, thetebr'
gcncraflng e l1()fmous proceeds of crimc rr,lrich r.r'ere subsequcntlv
Page 25 ot 33
laverecl ancl ifltegr:atctl thlough comPlex ProPcrty transac lorls to glvc
rhcm tl-rc xl)pcaratrcc oF lcsitimacl', the vcrv csst'rl' r "i mouc\
launclcring as is dcfrncd unclcr Section 3 of the PNII'A '\:
25. -['he three uclqc L]cnch o[ thc Flon'ble Suprcme ( - >urt l{on'blc
-f
Suprcn-re (-ourt in Viiay Madanlal Choudhary (supra) 1r s upheld thc
constitutional valiclrtr of thc PNIL.\ ,\ct and held thrLr (' [)r{ )\risi{ 't1:
of thc l)I{t,,\ \cL tlo not violatc an}' [undamcntal tiglr s guarantecd
unclcr Part Il[ oi rhc (]onstitution. fror rcadr. rcferenc: rhe finclings
gir.en bv thc llrn'blc Supremc Court in the aforcsaici t rsc of Vijay
Madantal Choudharv (supta) in paragraph Nos l I I &
.169,
rcprocluccd lrcreu n clc r, r'i2.,
"13rt. tiorl /1t". ,t,rri' iutt,Erttgc af .\'ection ) of the 2002 At, it r; tnp/1't/cur
tlol l/,t oJfLrra' /)l /natk)' /undutng i.t un indefendenl (Jent ' l,rrlirX thr:
frttt'st' or r/it.tt'. ;t thtt ltl aitl) lte Traued.;
o.f oine which ltad b t
obl n'tl u-, ,1 1'1.'tril of ttirttinul ndii\ rtt/ahng to or in relalitn t' t stfukrfud
ollin*.-['lr frt,t.;i nr,rrliri/1 can be it ttty fitrrn
fo.tiLi.tiotr, ltitlt 'i/tt)/1, rr-t,' o.f proteul.; ttf
-
be it one t)f
oirue a-s mtuh at 7t't, ,tlir,g it l.t
a k.ti t l t)r0fu /) or tlairuir4g it la br -ro. 1'has, inuoluement in at' )tt( of stLh
ntr-rli,t a ttllinn o.f
f)rlft.i! 0r dttlt:ia ;rtlnt,led with thc frorud.s o-f rinte wou/d
monq' hnndcirr1. l'lti.t o-1firuz othcnvi.;a hn nothirry to do wit'l'
lr,tinina/
are
uctirity relatitr,q to u :th,:dtled olJinie NftPl llte lroteclt o.f ttmt funn'd or
ohtdttad u rt ru ltf' l/tdl ,:rt///c.
169.,'l.r o.fbre.trid, in /Lit ltotktlrap :lmtndment ,1i 2 ttl 201 L'tnr inlu
being. Couideing /? ParPort ()-f tfu anenfud prut:i-tionr tncl lltt rxpuieut of'
inpktnentiry/ etfbncne t (13( Lie.i, futtbtr thntX':'r be m? t^rat.'y la
th'etgthett tltt netbanism rcgt i 3 Pnt'r til
af t0 ?)'latrnderit.q' It i'; not
nlh/ in atlamitg that the attachment qf' Prl\r\' (!,roti:ional) undtr th vrltnd
fraui.so, as arnetded, has
no litrk with lln nlndtltd aLfe Le
l (tr tutl) u.t '\'e'tiot
)(l)tntisl,qts Jhul -rult an attiot nn bt ititiakd on/y at tt bt''i'; of nt Lttirl
irt pose.;sion oJ tfu aatboi.;ed ot'fnr inditaliue of any petnn btin,'l itt ["'''"''''irttt
ol' proceerls oJ' time. Tln prcc'onditirtn.[or fuir3 pro;tedt of ttttttr: it lhtrl llt
Pn)Prr4' hd.r fuu lciul c'r obttited,
direifi ttr iulinctil. b1 tn1 ftr'rttt rtt 'r
revh of triruinn/ aclittif,rclatiw lo a:chedu/e,'l o//inn.l'Le .ruttp af \ttliorr
5(t) it ttot liniled ta the arused rudn"ed in tlr oiniru/ atlitatl' rt/ithrtl kt tt
.;futlu/ed afiirttt. It woald upPh t0 dtry Perco (tot ncte.tsanl1' [17x'1 rtittrt irr
tlr scherluled q1[cw), tf hr it irtt'oh,ed it tttty frots.t or ttdtli7 tornt't*4 uillt
tlt: prorcetls ol tine . Sub a person bas)rle-r .f'ai tg tbt ".ott.;eqrunt rti pnt i;trttttt/
ttlldl)rtt t ordtr, na1 ertd up in bung nuncd ai utttt.rrd in lln ttnt/t/ttrttt ht lt
) tln ]00)
liletl lry lhe afihoivtl offi,rr toncerning o.[[e nu mder .\'ettion oi
-1, t.
"
26. 'l'hc Flon'ble Suprcmc (-outt also in thc case oF Satycndar
Kumar Jain v. Enforcement Directorate3 hcld at paragraPh \o 20
as Lrnder, \riz.,
'(zozqa scc 715
Pagc 27 of 33
''20. 'fhe afltrtL of ntont-t ltttnleritg as tonlenf/ated in -\'eiitrt ) l:'!,, -4 hts
uith 11 tht three'.[ulgt B,'r i itr l'iiLly
.\ladtnl,l(.l,trdl,,tt.'1' |'i1,r1' \l tt tl C.hordltarl'u. Liniott oJ t ,iio. (202 ) )
l2 -\.(.(.. t : (202)) 2l I7-R Ol - I : 2022 .lCC Onljne SC 9. )' , m whi,h
il ha.; lntn olt.,tnt:l lh .\t,litr J hus a widr reach- The oif,r t u d,,tJin:d
bc,:n eltbontkll kdt
LLl1turci ttrt') ['n,ts.r uttl attit'i/)' h lealirg with tlte prorclt tl' , tatc, lu'eclly
of )e .li,td/ n.l 'irttryration
ol' lainted fruPr/) in 1fu lbrntd/ cto tlrT!)r t0 Loflrtit te dt ,'t af ruonel'ar i
irett/1'. ,trtl i.r rut linitul to thc ha/>peniry
,
/tunfuiuq. Of ;rnr.v. tl)( Lt///h0i0' o/ thc Aa nised OlJinr ,'u t 't tbe ./1i h)
!rl!e. tt d )' fi r.trttr .lor tfu rtf/iatr ol nonc),-/uatdeitg ,ge tt ,'t.'a rrrd r,n/y if'
tltcn'Lt.r:i.ils 7nt;rd.t of' trintt wilhut //te rncaning ttf -\'eni) 2(l)1, ) a.l thc ,1r/
arul.furthrr il it itrt'olL ru iry lrlL$J or artiitl. Nol r:uen it :r t 'tJ eiiene
of trnrhnht-trd iruntrt tt
tt rc.spt.tlit't o.f its uo/lmt, tbe def nitir,'t a[ "prateed-s
af rintt" u t .\ei.tion 2(11ftr) wil/ get athaded, rulcst n f;rL! 'r4, ln.r hun
lrin:d or obhriud ,,.t , ,,'.;1r/t ol tnninol artiui4 rchling to a .t,, l.,led alJinn.
'f fu roperh nttr.;/ qtruli1) /ltt l,'linition qf 'pratedt oJ tittt,"
f
rdtr.\'eiiott
2(1 )Qr) o.l llu ..lt:/. ./1.; oh.tLnul. in ttll or uhole o.f the oime Trtt t4, ltnked to
.;tlxdtl,,'l oljtt,i' ru nrtl ht rr,grrded u pronr:d.t oJ tine, l:tr'
r,t/ prr.,pertu-t
Eul1firy tlt dLlinitiott ol ''f'rontd.; o.f rine" ander -f ect,n r ;(t )ftr) wr//
tut.t.iLui/) b, 1lr atn| ftrofttr/iL.t."
. '['hc pctitioner's cotrtcntion that hc has no I ]rlrs with thc
a lle
sc(l
m()nc\
launilcrin.g activitics is demotrstt;L riv talsc and
c()ntradicted br' (locumcntaf\i cvidcnce
includir-r r
his familial
conl'rccti()ns t ith kcv accuscd persons, his involveme - in suspicious
\.
land uansactir)fls in thc samc geogtaphrcal area during thc rele\.ant
pcriod, his business associauons rvith pcrsons dircctlv invoh-cd llt
illcgal alicnatitxr o[ Rhoodan lands, and thc pattcrrl of propcrfi'
acqr-risiuons that pnnta facie suggcsts deplr)1r1gn1 oI proceeds of crimc
Further, thc pcridoncr's argumcnt tliat his land beating Sun el
No.194/5/1 is distrnct flom drsputcd Bhoodan lands is irtclevant at
this stagc, as thc in\.estigation 1s cxamining the cntire nctrvr-rrl< of
illegal land alienation and money laundcring activitics, and tht
petitioner's role therein cannot bc conclusivcly tuled out rvithc.rut
complcting thc invcs tigarior-r
28. 'l'hc scizure o[ the petitioner's mobilc phonc also rvzs
corrdLrcrcd stricth, in accordance s,ith Secuon 17 o[ the PNt]. \ .\ct
rvhich cmporvers authorized ol'l'iccrs to seize not onl)' proccccls of
ctitnc but also anv rccords, clocutnents, .)r Propcrry which mar b':
usc[ul for or rclcvant to any investrgatron undcr the l)NlL-\ \ct. \
mobile phone cor-rtainu'rg digital evidcnce, communicati()n records,
financial transactions, V/hatsApp rrressagcs, cmails, call records,
Pagc 29 of 33
location data, ancl P()tenriallt incriminatir-rg matcri, I lalls squarclv
rvithin thc arnbir of Pr()pcrn' that catr be lawlulll' setzc c under Scction
17 for thc I)utl)()sc of invcstigation. Thc rctcnti()l oI the seizcd
mobilc phonc also has bccn dulv con fitmed b1' tI
'\djudicating
,\uthorin' throtrgh oral iudg,mer.rt in ()riginal Applicati, L No 153/2025
after applicatron of itrdicial tnind to the matcrial plact i bcltrrc rt.
'f he
Aclludicating ,\urhoritv is thc cotnpe tcut statutor\ 2 th()rit\. Lrndcf
r
Section B o[ thc l)\{LA Act to dccitlc upon continuati ,tl o[ seiz':uc f
attachmcflt, ancl oncc suclr authoritv has cxamine(l he mattcr afld
passe<l a reasotrcd order confirlnintr thc retentioLt t his Cnurt rn
exercisc oI s.-rit jtrtisclictton should rrt.rt sr-rbstitute its r,, r', i'iew for that
of thc statutorv authoritf unlcss thc ordcr is sh(x\ 1 rr bc rvl-rollt'
pervcrsc, \\1th()ut jurisdiction, or viriated b1' nala -fidL: lotre oI rvluch
has bcen tlcmonsttatccl ifr thc ptcscnt casc
29. Thc pe utronct's rcmcclt aeaitrst tlrc order of I t .\cliuchcating
r\uthorin lies in statutotv appeal to the r\Ppcllate lribunal undcr
Section 2(r of the PNIL.,\ Act, which provides for exp: lrtious disposal
I'al:(' .10 oi ii
rvithin six (06) monrlrs an,J thercafler l() tlls (,ourt under Section 42
on substantial qur:slions of larr,:'I'hc pctitloncr carrnot be pcrrnitted to
bvpass this complcrte appcllatc liicrarchv and dirccth, approach this
(-ourt in rvrit juristlicdori rncrcl\. becausc rlrc sratutorl, rcmcdics rnav
n()t yicld the desirsl rcsulr. F-urthermorr:, thc peutroncr's allcgations
r>f arbitrariness. violatirn {)f natural justicc, ancl lack of fcasons t()
believc' atc w.holh nriricorceivetl antl rr:flcct a fundamcntal
misr.rnde rstanding oi
thc legal yrrinciples gcrvcrninrl inr.csti.gntion ,,f
cconomic oflcnccs nrrdcr spccial lcgislation. .\t
thc stagc oI
investigation, thc thtr:sho[d is 'rerason to belrer.c' :rnd not 'prooI
beyond rcascrnable clo,ubt' or cvcn '?ixld fdcie case'.
-I'hc
ir-rvesrigating
authorin-is not rcquircd to disclosc cr;rnplete 'rcrsons to bclicvc'at
thc inr.estigtuon stxg(' as snch disclosrrtc rvo'.rlcl dcfleat the lcrr.
purpose o[ tnvcstiganon, alcrt porc,rtial co conspirators, ancl cnable
dcsttuction o I cviderrcc
30. 'I'he petitioncrs' claim of being mcrc careral<ers is lactuallv
unsustainable in light oi rhe irrcfutable monev trail cstabLshing rhat
-'7
Page 3l of 33
rhel rcccir.ed pr()ccrcrds of crimc amountrnll t() Rs.l,1:. )r),000/- c^ch
(toteling l{s.2,30,()0,000/ ) dircctly traccablc t() thc ilcgal sale of
q()vernmcnt llhooclan land.'I'he receipt of Rs.90,00,()( ( 7' cach ftom
Nlunawar Iihan's accoult and an aclditional Rs.25,00,( [)0/- each as
cotnmissron Ftom thc buyers (N. Santosh liumar :Lnd Bobbali
Visu'anatha Rcddr) conclr"rsivelv dcmonstrates that thc 1 r tirioners rvere
trot passivc carctai<crs but active bcncficiarics arcl par i:rpants in thc
lavcring and integtrtion oi procceds of crirne
31. Furthcq rhcr pctitioners allcgations rcgardinu unauthorizcd
scarch opet'ations anci cocrcir.c statcment rccorclir
a tCl
rvholll,
unsubstantratcd alid contraclictcd bv thcir os.n volrrnrar dcclaratrons
maclc cluring thc rccording ()[ statcmcrlts uncler Scctiorr .r0 of I']II],,.\
lct. 'l'hc scarch encl scizutc opcrations u,crc conclrr,' ld strictlv in
accordancc rvith Sccuon 17 of Pi\IL-\ -\ct bl e dulv arrtl .rtizcd officcr
ur-rder ptoper authonzation frorn thc Joint Dirc,' : r, and thc
pancbanana rvas executed with indcpcndent s,itncsscs ir compliancc
rvith all proceclural sa k'guarc'ls
I\.
I):rge 32 ol 33
.):
Lasdr', thc petittoncts argutncnt that thc seizcd documcuts arc
rnere photoco1'rics aucl do n()t c()lrstitrrtc ptocccds of ctimtr rcf-lccts ;r
fundatnental misundcrstanding tlre scope o[ thc PNt],.\ ,\ct, rvhich
extencls rrot only to dircct procccds but also to docutncnts cvidencing
tl-re posscssion, conccalmcnt, trsc. ()t proiection of procccds of crimc
AS
untainted pr()pcrt\. 'fhc clocut.t-tctrts seizcd durirrg thc scarch
cstablish a dircct rrexus rvith thc propt'rtics accluired through proceeds
oi crimc and dcmonstratc thc l)cdii( )ttcrs' rolc irr facrlitadns thc illegal
transacttons.
33. 'l'hc P\ILA .\ct is a spccral lcgislariott cnactccl to combat thc
rrcnacc oI mono' launcle rittg ri'hich facilitates scriolrs crimcs ir-rcluding
tcrrorism financing, drug traftrcking, crlrrupuon, and orgauizcd ctimc
'fhcrcfirtc. (-()urts rnust ercrcise rcstrrlillt ancl a[[orv invcstigating
agenclcs to comp[ctc lnvcstigart()11 rt'ithor'rt prcmaturc itltcricrcncc
unlcss tlrcrc is c[e ar atrd cot.n incing cviclenc c ol xtulu -fides, c()mPIct(
lack oi jurisdiction, or gross violatiorr o[ [unclamctrtal rights, none r.,f
rvhich cxists ir1 thc ptcscnt cas(
Paqc 3i of :i3
CONCLUSION
3-1. lirr rll thc;rfirrcsaicl rcasolrs ancl thc judicial prc.,, ()nrs rctcrrcd
to nbor,'c in tl'rc Precc.tling parauraphs, wc arc of tl , considcred
opinion that thc instant \\-rit pctitions arc dcvoicl of nr . ri, dcscrr.c tcr
bc ancl arc accorclinglv ilisrnissccl
-l:)
\s a scqucl, rnisccllaneous peurions pendinu if rr r. shall stand
closcd. orvcver, thcre sltall bc rto ordcr as to c()sts
SD/-AHMT D ABDULLAH KHAN
SS ISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice P.SAtr
KOSHY
(For His Lordships Kind perusal)
AND
One Fair Copy to the Hon'ble Sri Justice SUDDALA
C - ALAPATHI RAO
(For His Lordships Kind perusal)
To
1. 11 LR Copies.
,
#:,,r.:i,"J*a;:l;lro
Union of tndia Ministry of Law, Jr_s rce and
3. The Secretary. Telanoana Advocates Association Libra r
I
Buildings, Hyierabadl
9n" CC to SRt JAKKULA.VATI_SH| KR|SHNA, Advocar
vv I vr r LU r\
i, Two
El! CD
EE is SHl H.RXH$,tsiAmittztn?8,,"&?t
7.
Copies
PSK,
BS
PmCr
company
High Coud
I OpUCI
i!',!i'#r.aa ropucl
HIGH COURT
DATED:1 210212026
COMMON ORDER
WP.Nos.28703 AND 28716 ot 20
(
oo
t
1H:
13 ''1 );'li
*
eP^r t
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONS
WITHOUT COSTS
c') ?$&
I
\l 31 ,-6
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review