Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010695102025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3311]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
Tuesday, the thirty first day of March, two thousand and twenty six
Present
The Honourable Ms. Justice B. S. Bhanumathi
Writ Petition No.35881 of 2025
Between:
A. Vijay Kumar
...Petitioner
and
The State of A.P. and others
Counsel for the petitioner:
1. T. N. M. Ranga Rao
Counsel for the respondents:
1. G.P. for Revenue
2. Ms. Baliboyina Sravani, learned A.
A.G.P. for Forest
3. G.P. for Mines & Geology
The Court made the following:
...Respondents
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
ORDER:
This writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India is
filed seeking a writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent
No.8 in issuing notice, dated 27.11.2025, in spite of granting permission
by the concerned authorities and issuing work orders as illegal,
arbitrary, violation of the legal duty and violation of the Articles 14, 16,
19(1)(g) and 21 of the Constitution of India and to set aside the notice,
dated 27.11.2025, issued by the respondent No.8 and consequently
direct the official respondents herein not to interfere with the peaceful
activity of the petitioner as per the leasehold rights.
2.
The case of the petitioner, briefly stated, is as follows:
a.
The petitioner was granted quarry lease for a period of ten (10)
years in the land to an extent of Ac.2.697 hectares in Sy.No.31/P of
Veerlagunapadu village, Ozili mandal, S.P.S.R. Nellore district, vide
lease deed granted by the Deputy Director, Mines & Geology, Guntur,
vide
proceeding
No.3946/Q/AD(N)/2006,
dated
25.11.2006.
The
petitioner made an application on 10.08.2023 to the mining authorities
for renewal of the quarry lease for Road Metal & Gravel for a further
period of 10 years in the same land. The District Mines & Geology
Officer, Nellore, after considering all the relevant papers approved the
proposal vide Lr.No.2256/AMP/DMGO/NLR/2024, dated 12.07.2024.
The Andhra Pradesh Pollution Control Board also issued consent order,
dated 15.05.2025.
The Divisional Mines & Geology Officer, Gudur,
Tirupathi District, addressed a letter to the petitioner, on 16.04.2025, to
submit relevant documents to enter into the lease deed. Accordingly, a
lease deed was executed on 24.06.2025 and a work order was also
issued on the even date.
b.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
When a joint survey was conducted by the forest and the revenue
authorities, a joint survey report, dated 20.04.2021, was submitted
categorically observing that as per the records of the revenue
department, the entire land of Ac.269.71 cents is poramboke land and
that there is no proof or evidence produced by the forest authority that it
was handed over to the forest department.
All the authorities have
knowledge of the above joint survey report, yet, the work order was
issued on 24.06.2025. The subject matter land under lease does not
come under the reserve forest area. In a similar writ petition filed by
third party in W.P.No.1315 of 2019, the revenue authorities filed sworn
counter affidavit stating that the land in Sy.No.31/P of Veerlagunapadu
village is not within the reserve forest area. When the petitioner was
ready to start the work, the respondent No.8 issued a notice, dated
27.11.2025, to the petitioner with the averments contrary to the
permissions and facts besides law, informing to the petitioner that the
entire land of the lease given to the petitioner is within the reserve forest
notified under Section 15 of the A.P. Forest Act, 1967 (for short, “Act,
1967’),
vide
G.O.Ms.No.1815,
Food
&
Agriculture
(Forest.III)
Department, dated 05.09.1967, to an extent of 307 acres, out of which
269.71 acres in Sy.No.31 is part and described it as Veerlagunapadu-B
Reserve Forest and further stated that the District Forest Officer,
Nellore, had addressed letter to the Assistant Director, Mines &
Geology, Nellore, that it has no jurisdiction to grant any mining lease in
the said land without prior permission of the central government in
violation of the provisions of the Act, 1967 and Forest (Conservation)
Act, 1980 (for short, ‘Act, 1980’) and consequently, any trespass into the
land for non-forest activity like mining is viewed seriously and could be
prosecuted. The said notice is illegal and liable to be set aside.
3.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
The respondent No.5 filed a counter with the averments, briefly
stated, as follows:
a.
in
On the application made by the petitioner for grant of quarry lease
the
above
said
land
of
Ac.7.41
cents
in
Sy.No.31/P
of
Veerlagunapadu village on 29.05.2006, the then Assistant Director of
Mines & Geology addressed a letter to the respondent No.10 to issue
N.O.C., after conducting inspection / survey for classification and
availability of the land.
The respondent No.10 informed that vide letter
L.Dis.No.267/97, dated 23.09.1997, report was furnished that the land
to an extent of 269.17 acres in Sy.No.31 of Veerlagunapadu village was
classified as ‘Thippa Poramboke’ and that there was no objection to the
revenue authorities to grant quarry lease in the above said land. Basing
on the same, the then Assistant Director of Mines & Geology, Nellore,
submitted a combined proposal for grant of quarry lease along with
others, to the then Deputy Director of Mines & Geology, Guntur, vide
letter, dated 13.11.2006. After verification of the proposals, the Deputy
Director of Mines & Geology, Guntur, granted quarry lease to the
petitioner for ten years and accordingly, the lease deed was executed
for the period between 22.02.2007 to 21.02.2017. The petitioner carried
out mining operation and paid necessary charges to the Mines
Department. The petitioner submitted a renewal application on
11.01.2017. The Divisional Mines and Geology Officer, Gudur,
submitted a proposal duly recommending renewal for another period of
ten years.
Rules,
Meanwhile, the Andhra Pradesh Minor Mineral Concession
were
amended
vide
G.O.Ms.No.25,
Industries
&
Commerce (M-III) Department, dated 06.04.2023. Once again, the
petitioner filed another renewal application as per the amended rules.
Pursuant to the application, the District Mines and Geology Officer,
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
Nellore, issued a letter of intent, on 01.06.2024 directing the petitioner to
pay necessary differential amount and submission of statutory
clearances. Accordingly, the petitioner submitted the necessary
documents.
Then, the District Mines & Geology Officer, Nellore,
granted first renewal, vide proceedings, dated 27.03.2025, for a period
of 10 years subject to the conditions imposed in the lease deed as per
the Rules, 1966. Accordingly, renewal lease deed was executed on
24.06.2025 for a period of ten years from 01.04.2023. Since then, the
petitioner carried out the quarry operations in accordance with the
Rules, 1966 without any deviation, by paying necessary charges. Apart
from the petitioner, five others were granted quarry lease in the land in
Sy.No.31 of Veerlagunapadu village based on N.O.C. issued by the
respondent No.10, vide letter, dated 23.09.1997, as the land in
Sy.No.31 to an extent of 269.17 acres was classified as ‘Thippa
Poramboke’ and the revenue department has no objection.
b.
While the things stood thus, respondent No.8 addressed a letter
vide Rc.No.25/2025, dated 02.12.2025, to this respondent that the
entire land in Sy.No.31/P of Veerlagunapadu village lies inside the
reserve forest boundary and requested to cancel the lease with
immediate effect. The leases were granted as per the revenue record.
The writ petition may be dismissed.
4.
The respondent No.7 filed a counter affidavit with the averments,
briefly stated, as follows:
a.
It is incorrect that the renewal of quarry lease was validly
granted / renewed to the petitioner. This land is an integral part of
Veerlagunapadu ‘B’ reserve forest duly notified vide G.O.Ms.No.1815,
Food & Agriculture (Forest.III) Department, dated 05.09.1967, for a total
extent of 307 acres of land.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
The joint survey conducted by the
department of forest and revenue on 20.04.2021 clarified that the entire
land in Sy.No.31 of Veerlagunapadu village is within the reserve forest
boundary.
Subsequently, a request letter, dated 24.09.2021, was
addressed by the Divisional Forest Officer, S.P.S.R. Nellore, to the
Tahsildar, Ozili Mandal, to effect changes in the entries in the revenue
record. But, there is no reply from the revenue department nor are any
changes brought up in the records.
Any quarrying / mining activity
inside the notified reserved forest, without prior approval from the Forest
Department is prohibited under the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980
(now, referred as van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam,
1980) and Rules, 2023. Therefore, any renewal of quarry lease without
complying the procedure is illegal and void ab initio. The Sub-Divisional
Forest Officer, Venkatagiri, vide Rc.No.25/2025, dated 02.12.2025,
addressed a letter to the Divisional Mines & Geology Officer, Gudur, for
cancellation of the renewal / lease as it violates the provisions of
Section 20(1)(c)(ii) and (v) of the Act, 1967 and the Act, 1980. Since
the mining lease expired in the year 2017, there is no continuity in
mining operations. It is also evident from Ex.P10 filed by the petitioner.
The inaction on the part of the revenue department to carry out mutation
in the entries in revenue records does not disentitle the forest
department to de-zone the entitlement. The petitioner or the revenue
authorities or the mining authorities are not allowed to encroach the
forest land. W.P.No.1315 of 2019 was also filed by the same counsel
who filed the present petition.
There was a joint survey held on
19.12.2018. The outcome of the joint survey is that Sy.No.31 is within
the reserve forest of Veerlagunapadu village - B block. The same result
is the outcome of another joint survey conducted on 20.04.2021.
b.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
The act of mining operations in the forest land came to the light
after conducting joint survey on 19.12.2018.
Since there was frequent
change of officers, it is not coming out why quarry operations were
allowed earlier.
But, after joint survey, the department of forest is
reminding the mining department to cancel the mining lease granted in
favour of the petitioner.
Any mining activity in the forest land destroys
the ecological and environmental balance in the sensitive ecosystem in
the subject land. As per the decision of the Supreme Court in T.N.
Godavarman Thirumulpad Vs. Union of India & Others1, the term
‘forest land’ in Section 2 of the Act, 1980 includes not only forests in
dictionary sense but also all areas recorded as forest in government
records, irrespective of ownership / classification and therefore, merely
because the revenue entries show the subject land as Thippa
Poramboke, the non-forest activities are not allowed without the
approval of the central government and Section 2 of the Act, 1980.
Hence, appropriate orders may be passed.
5.
The respondent No.10 filed a counter with the averments, briefly
stated, as follows:
a.
The
land
Veerlagunapadu
to
an
village,
extent
of
Ac.269.71
Ozili
mandal
Poramboke’, as per the village records.
is
in
classified
Sy.No.31
as
of
‘Thippa
On application filed by the
petitioner before the District Mines & Geology Officer, mining lease was
granted to the petitioner vide proceedings No.2266/02/2006, dated
22.02.2007, to an extent of Ac.7.41 cents in Sy.No.31/P of
Veerlagunapadu village for a period of ten years from 22.02.2007 to
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
21.02.2017. The lease period was extended from time to time.
Since
then, the petitioner carried out mining operation in the said land. In the
land in Sy.No.31, several others were granted mining leases. The said
land was not handed over to the forest department under afforestation
as per the records available in the office of this respondent. A detailed
joint survey was conducted along with the office of the forest
department. The officials of the forest department did not confirm that
Ac.269.71 cents in Sy.No.31 was classified as reserve forest. Land of
Ac.170.00 cents in Sy.No.31 out of Ac.269.71 cents in Sy.No.31 of
Veerlagunapadu village was under leases granted to different persons.
The leases were renewed from time to time. At the time of granting
lease to the petitioner, Sy.No.31 of Veerlagunapadu village was noted
as Sy.No.31P as sub-division was not created. Sy.Nos.31 and 31P are
one and the same (in the written instructions of this respondent, it was
reported that there is no survey number 31/P).
b.
This High Court, by order, dated 21.01.2026, in this writ petition,
directed respondent No.10 to place the connected records before this
Court for verification. Accordingly, the record was placed before this
Court. Accordingly, on 28.01.2026, this High Court ordered that the
concerned respondent shall produce the record of the Forest Settlement
Officer relating to the land notified under Section 15 of the Act, 1967
which is the subject matter of this writ petition. A detailed joint survey
was conducted along with the forest officials. It is true that in
W.P.No.1315 of 2019 filed by K.Uday Kumar S/o. Gopal Rao, the then
Tahsildar of Ozili mandal, has filed a counter stating that the land in
Sy.No.31 of Veerlagunapadu village is Thippa poramboke, but not
reserve forest. W.P.No.1315 of 2019 is pending before this Court. The
respondent No.8, without confirming that the land in Sy.No.31 is under
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
reserve forest, issued a notice to the writ petitioner. Similarly, they have
also issued notices to vacate the land to other lease holders. The land
in Sy.No.31P of Veerlagunapadu village was not handed over to the
forest department under afforestation. The reserve forest is located at a
distance of 3.78 km from the subject land. The forest department laid
stones outside the forest area by including land in Sy.Nos.32, 39, 42,
43, 44 of Veerlagunapadu village and Arimenipadu village without
having any proof that the government gave that land to the forest
department under afforestation. In between the reserve forest and patta
lands, government lands are existing. Generally, the land classified as
Adavi / reserve forest recorded as village forest is governed by Act,
1967 but the land in Sy.No.31 is not so governed as it is Thippa
poramboke. Hence, the contentions raised by the forest department are
not sustainable.
Finally, it is prayed to pass necessary orders as this
Court may deem fit and proper.
6.
The petitioner filed a reply to the counter of the respondent No.7
with the averments, briefly stated, as follows:
The respondent No.7 is misleading the Court by playing fraud on
the Court by showing sketches / maps which are not certified copies of
the original survey settlement records. The counter filed by the
respondent No.7 is trying to mislead and confuse the Court and
diverting the issue involved in the present writ petition. The respondent
No.7 is claiming the property as if it is the forest property.
The burden
of proof always lies on them. They did not even produce the original
survey settlement record with sketches from the year 1963 to 1967. In
those circumstances, the Court may draw presumption against the
forest department when the revenue department as well as mining
department specifically contended that the subject land does not belong
to the forest department.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
Apart from that, the revenue department
specifically contended that the nature of land is Thippa poramboke and
was never handed over to the forest department. In the said
circumstances, the writ petitioner would not suffer by virtue of the
vexatious litigation created by the forest department. The writ petitioner
got work orders from the mining department on 24.06.2025 and in view
of the litigation created by the respondent No.8, the petitioner was
compelled to pay Rs.3,50,000/-, otherwise, the department will impose
the penalty or cancel the leasehold rights. Unless the writ petition is
allowed, the petitioner will be put to irreparable loss and great hardship.
7.
Along with the writ affidavit, copies of the following documents
were enclosed:Sl. No.
Document
Exhibit
Notice issued by the Forest Ranger Officer (FAC),
P1
Venkatagiri to the petitioner, dt.27.11.2025
Copy of application, dated 10.08.2023, for renewal
P2
lease period
Copies
of
particulars
of
work
orders
and
P3
Copy of notice issued by the 4th respondent –
P4
permission, dated 31.03.2023
Deputy Director of Mines and Geology, Nellore
Copy of letter, dated 12.07.2024, addressed to the
P5
petitioner by the District Mines & Geology Officer,
Copy of letter, dated 20.08.2024, addressed to the
Chairman,
State
Level
Environment
Impact
Assessment Authority (SEIAA), Andhra Pradesh,
by the Divisional Mines and Geology Officer
P6
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
Copy of EC approval, dated 24.01.2025
P7
Copy of approval of zonal office, Tirupathi, dated
P8
06.03.2025
Copy of letter, dated 16.04.2025, addressed to the
P9
petitioner by the Divisional Mines and Geology
Officer
Copy of renewal order, dated 27.03.2025, vide
P10
Proceedings No.1098/RQL/2024
Copy of consent orders, dated 15.05.2205
P11
Copy of work orders, dated 24.06.2025
P12
Copy of joint survey report, dated 20.04.2021
P13
Copy of letter addressed to the Chairman, State
P14
Level Environmental Impact Assessment Authority,
dated 07.11.2024
8.
Copy of counter in W.P.No.1315 of 2019
P15
Today, i.e., on 31.03.2026, the learned counsel for the petitioner
filed memo of additional documents stating that the forest authorities
have not furnished relevant records mentioned in I.A.No.1 of 2024 in
this writ petition and they have also not supplied concerned records on
the application made by the petitioner under the Right to Information
Act, 2005, and therefore, sufficient presumption may be drawn against
the forest department for non-production of the relevant records and
allow the writ petition.
9.
Along with the memo, copies of application filed under the Right
to Information Act are enclosed.
10.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
The matter was already heard on 18.03.2026 and posted today
for pronouncement of orders.
11.
During the course of arguments, the learned counsel for the
petitioner vehemently submitted that the Forest Department miserably
failed to show that the subject land is within the reserve forest and that
the notification said to have been issued under Section 15 of the Act,
1967, is not relating to the subject land. He further submitted that the
land recorded as ‘Thippa poramboke’ cannot be declared as forest land
without conversion of the land as per the letter and that there is no
record or proof that possession of the land was given by the revenue
authorities to the forest department. That apart, he argued that it is the
burden of the forest department to show that the subject land is within
forest department and till such time, the forest department cannot
interfere with the activity of the petitioner, in view of permissions already
granted by several departments as stated in the petition and it is only
renewal, whereas the lease was already granted long back about two
decades ago and since then, till now, there has been no objection from
any corner.
He further submitted that there is no reference of any
survey number in the notification said to have been issued under
Section 15 of the Act, 1967, and therefore, the land in the said
notification has no connection to the subject land and moreover, the
officers of the forest department themselves could not show that it was
notified as forest land, during the time of joint inspection, as is noted in
the report itself.
As mentioned in the memo, dated 31.03.2026, he
requested, during the course of arguments also to draw an adverse
inference.
12.
The learned Assistant Government Pleaders for Revenue and
Mines & Geology submitted as in their counters.
13.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
The learned A.G.P. for Forests vehemently contended that the
notification under Section 15 of the Act, 1967, need not contain
reference to any survey number and it is sufficient to declare the land as
a reserve forest with reference to the boundaries and that the joint
survey report clearly indicated that the subject land is within the
boundaries of the forest land. She further submitted that the notification
was issued in the year 1967 and thereafter, no activity of mining is
permissible under law merely because no mutation was made in the
entries of revenue record, since law prohibits such activity. She further
submitted that there are no separate survey numbers 31 and 31P of
Veerlagunapadu village and the same was also admitted by the revenue
department and that if at all, mining is to be done in the forest area,
appropriate procedure is to secure the permission of the Central
government as per Section 2 of the Act, 1980, but without taking such a
recourse, the mining leases were illegally granted, and therefore, such
permissions or leases granted are not legally enforceable and not
binding on the department of forests. With regard to production of the
documents, she submitted that detailed counters are filed in I.A.No.1 of
2026 and that whatever record was available was already submitted
before this Court and no other record is available and no adverse
inference shall be drawn as the Forest Settlement Officer is not from the
department of forest, but he is an officer from the revenue department
and the relevant record would be available only with the office of the
District Collector concerned.
She further submitted that the map
relating to forest block ‘B’ was already enclosed to the notification
issued under Section 15 and the same holds good.
14.
As can be seen from the contentions of both the parties, the crux
of the dispute is with regard to the nature of the land. Admittedly, the
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
entries in the revenue records continued to be ‘Thippa poramboke’ in
spite of correspondence made after joint survey to mutate the nature of
the land in the relevant revenue records. It is surprising that though the
proceedings under Section 15 of the Act, 1967, have not been denied
by the revenue department, no record is placed before this Court as to
what is the entry made relating to that notified area in the revenue
records. When the joint survey was held in the presence of the officers
of the forest department and the revenue authorities, with reference to
the identity particulars in the notification and the revenue record, it was
observed that the land still continues to be shown as ‘Thippa
poramboke’ and the said land was covered within the forest area.
Therefore, merely because of the inaction of the revenue department to
maintain correct entries, the provisions of the Act, 1967 do not become
ineffective. They operate as per law. It is not once, but twice joint
survey was held and it was found that the disputed entire site was within
the boundaries of the forest area. It is for the revenue department to
take necessary steps insofar as making mutation of the entries in the
relevant records. Just because some proceedings were issued as per
the correspondence or permissions were given by then, the proceedings
do not attain sanctity in law even after noticing that they are not in
accordance with law. As such, the contention of the petitioner that the
department of forest cannot interfere in the lease already granted has
no force in law.
15.
It is a case of glaring example of inaction of the revenue
department leading to conflict of interest of the private individual on one
hand and the department of forest on the other hand.
All the
permissions accorded by the department of mining and the revenue
department are not within the purview of the department of forests.
BSB, J
W.P.No.35881 of 2025
Whatever sanctions accorded in the past were not with the consent or to
the knowledge of the department of forest. Therefore, for any number
of proceedings permitting or granting lease for mining, the department
of forest cannot be prohibited or prevented from enforcing the provisions
of law relating to the forest. As such, there is no illegality in the notice
impugned in this writ petition. Thus, there is no merit in the writ petition.
16.
In the result, the writ petition is dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs.
Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, shall stand closed.
___________________
B. S. BHANUMATHI, J
Dt.31.03.2026
Note:- Issue CC by 06.04.2026
(B/o)
RAR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review