Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/a-uma-rani-vs-the-state-of-telangana-20260326/ · Printed 18 Nov 2026
Constitutional

A. Uma Rani vs The State of Telangana

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Telangana High Court
Date
26 March 2026
Case No.
WP 36889/2025
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Justice Pulla Karthik
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

29. 11.2025, rcspcctivcly, and therefore, the writ pet [.ons arc clcvoid of merit and :rrc liable to be dismisscd. . Accordingly, thc Writ petitions are dismissed Misccllancous applications, it any, pendin: in these .u,rit petitions, shall stanrl closcd. No costs. SD/. A.I; TEENIVASA REDDY SI; STANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY/' To 8gs[''])'?'e # 2 ?ffi 33 Jiisi ?g?'#v' Hvderabad. [OUT] Triic CD CoPies PSK, \)--- r IPUCI for i ate of Telangana' at DATED:2610312026 t'(. WP.Nos.36885 AND 36889 of 20& e OF a{ a$ F d. \\ 1')/J, + q.' ' bL r,Q'- v,.- j*t-,{' ':\' -.'-----' $s +

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD [ 3301 I (Special Original Jurisdiction) THURSDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF MARCH TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK WRIT PETITION NOS: 36885 AND 36889 OF 2025 W.P.NO: 36885 OF 202s Between: Ponnam Madhavi, D/o. Satyanarayana, Aged about 49 years, School Guidance Counsellor (SA), O/o- The Director, State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT), Telangana State, Hyderabad. Rl/o. Flat No. 602, B-Block, Ridd hi's Pramukh Elegance, Kompa lly, nrd"rubl:;:f $13r* * = AND 1. The State of Telangana, rep., by its Principal Secretary, School Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 2. The Director of School Education, Telangana State, Hyderabad. 3. The Director of State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT), Hyderabad. 4. The District Educational Officer, Karimnagar District. ...RESpONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus, to declare the action of the 2nd and 3rd Respondents in issuing repatriation orders to the Petitioner vide proceedings RC No. 938/Ser,lll- 112025, dt. 2411112025, and consequential orders in RC. No. 26lEstVTSCERIl2O24, dl. 2911112025, even though, the Petitioner is not working on deputation, without verifying the records and orders of the Government in G.O.Rt.No.8'13, School Education (PE-PROG.ll) Dept., dt. 1111112011, as highly illegal, unjust, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of lndia and consequently, set aside the impugned orders and further direct the Respondents to retain and continue the Petitioner in the 3rd Respondent's office (SCERT), with all service and monetary benefits. lA NO: 1 OF 2025 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the cit< rmstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the Respondents to continue the Petitioner in the 3rd lespondent's office (SCERT), by suspending the operation of the impugned t 1)ceedings RC No' 938/Ser.lll-1/2025, dt. 24.11.2025, issued by the 2nc Respondent and consequential orders in RC. No. 26lEstt/TSCERTl2O24, dt.','-t 111/2025, issued by the 3rd Respondent and to Pass lA NO: 2 OF 2025 Between: 1. The State of Telangana, rep., by its Principal Secretary, I r;hool Education Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad. 2. Thd Director of School Education, Telangana State, Hyr'r rabad. 3. The Director of State Council of Educational Research r r d Training (SCERT)' Hyderabad. 4. rhe District Educational officer, Karimnagar District. .:FlglSt=r?t^1r, AND Ponnam Madhavi, D/o. Satyanarayana, Aged abor 49 years, School Guidance Counsellor (SA), Oio. The Director, State O uncil of Educational Research and Training' (SCERT), Telangana State, Hyj rrabad. Fi/o Flat No. 602, B-Block, Riddhi's Pramukh Elegance, Kompally, Hvr errabad - 50$131r* Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the ci ( umstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court rnay be pleased to vacate the interim orders dated. 09-12-2025 in WP.No.36BB5 of 2025 dismiss the Writ Petition. Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI PRATAP NARAYAN SANGI{ , SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI POODATTU AMARENDER,ADVOCATE Counsel forthe Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES I W.P.NO:3 6889 0F 202s Between: A.Uma Rani, D/o. Harischander Rao, Aged- about .55 .years, Science Srroervisor (sA-Phv.SC), O/o. State councrl of Educational Research and iiinino iSieiT), felanqana State, Hyderabad. R/o. Flat No 701, Block-10' Hill Rid6d Springd, Near lSB, Gachibowli, Hvderabad. ...'ET,TIONER AND '1 . The State of Telangana, rep., by its Principal Secretary, School Education Deoartment. Secretariat, Hyderabad. z. in6 oirectoi of School Edu-cation, Telangana State, Hyderabad' . 5. fne Oirector of State Council of Educational Research and Training (SCERT), Hyderabad. 4. The District Educational Officer, Adilabad District ...RESPONDENTS Petition under Article 226 of the constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction more particularly one in the nature of writ of Mandamus, to declare the action of the 2nd and 3rd Respondents in issuing repatriation orders to the Petitioner vide proceedings RC No 938/Ser.lll- 1t2O25, dt. 24.11.2025, and consequential orders in RC No' 2olEstt/TSCERTl2O24, dt. 29.1 1.2025, even though, the Petitioner is not working on deputation, without verifying the records and orders of the Government in G.o. Rt. No' 462, School Education (SER.V) Dept.' dt. 08.07.2008, as highly illegal' unjust, arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the constitution of lndia and consequently, set aside the impugned orders and further direct the Respondents to retain and continue the Petrtioner in the 3rd Respondent's office (scERT), with all service and monetary benefits. lA NO: 1 OF 2025 Petition under section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the Respondents to continue the Petitioner in the 3rd Respondent's office (SCERT), by suspending the operation of the impugned proceedings RC No' 938/Ser.lll-'t/2025, dt. 24.11.2025, issued by the 2nd Respondent and consequential orders in RC. No. 26lEstt/TSCERI12024, d|.29.11 .2025, issued by the 3rd Respondent. SENIOR Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI PRATAP NARAYAN SANGHI' COUNSEL FOR SRI POODATTU AIV ARENDER Counsel for the Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES I The Court made the following:'COMMON ORDER IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK WRIT PETITION Nos.36885 and 36889 of 202s Dated 26th March, 2026. Betwee n: Ponnam IVladhavi I)etitroncrs AND The State of 'lclangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Scl-rool liducation Departmcnt, Sccx'tariat, Ilydcrabad, and olhers. Rcspondcnts COMMON ORDER: Since the ll-s in thesc u,rit pr:titions is onc and Lhc samc, thc5r are analogousll, heard togcthcr antl :rrt' r;rkcn trp lirr disposal b-r, rvar, of this common order. 2. Thcsc Writ Pctitions zrrc hlcd sccl<ing to dcclare the repatriation orders dated 24.11.2O2r issued b_v rcspondcnt No.2, and thc conscqucntial rclieving ordcr dal-cd )c).1I )O25, rssucd b]. rcspondr_,nt No.3, as illegal, arbitrary, unjust, ancl violal-ive of Articlcs 14 and t6 ol the Constitution of India, arrd conscqucrlLl,v, to sct zrsidc thc said PK, ,I Iv.I,.A,.,. ti8.r & 36889 of 2025 ordcrs, with a lurthcr direction to the respondent i lo (ionlinllc thc petilioners in scrvice at thc oflicc of respondt r No.3 with all conscquclltial scrvice all(l monctar-\ bcucfits. 3. I lcard Sri l)ratap Naray.Irl Sarlghi, lcarncd Sc.' or Counst l, and Sfl Poodattu Amarender, lcartlcd counscl ap! larirlg for the pt:titioncrs, ancl learned Goverllmcnt l)leadcr for Sr:r r ,t:es I, appcaring on behalf of thc respondcnts. For the purposc ol l'ln\cnietlcc, thc pctitioncr in W.P.No.36885 oI 2025 is hercinalt I rcferrcd to as pctitioner No. 1 ar-rd Lhc pctitioner in W.P.No.36[ fj9 of 2025 as pr-'t itioncr No.2. 4. Le:rrncd cout-rscl li)r thc pctitioners submit lf i t pctltioncr No l $'as initially appointed :rs a Scc'otrdat-y Gr:]dc 'l'cach. ' orr 26 10' 1998' in thc erstwhilc f(arimnagar l)isLrict through thr' ).strict Sclcction Colnmittcc aftcr duc process of selcction, and r.l'tr s I -t.er promrlted as School Assistant (Dnglish) on 03.03.2006. Pe titiorr t No.2 u as also appointcd as a Secondary (irade Teacher on l1oil. 1998 in the crstu,hile Adilabatl I)istrlct throttgh the District Sc I clion CotnrniLtec and r,r,a s arlso promotcd as ScLrool Assistant (Plrvr i:al Science) on 20.1O.2OO2. It is submittcd that petitioner Ntr. 1 r'"as deptr[ed as Program Olflccr in tht' olfice of respondent No.3 I I ''crrns of lorcign J3 PK' .] W.P.No.36U85 & 3b889 of 2025 service, in accordance u,ith G.O.(P).No.10 dated 22.10.1993, and she joined duty as such on 21. I0.20I O. 'lhcrcaltcr, rhe Govcrnment issucd G-O.Rt.No.8lll dalcd I 1.1 l.2O l I . appoirrting hcr br- uav ol transfer as School Guidancc and Counselor in the officc of respondent No.3, in accordance with thc statutory rules issucd under G.O.Ms.No.538 dated 20.1 1.1998, which govern the appointments in SCERT. Similarly, pe[itioner No.2 u,zrs initi:rlly dcputcd to the office of respondent No.3 on 26.02.2007 but she u,as repatriatcd to her parent unit vidc proccedings datcd 05 07.2O08. Subscclucntll,, she rvas also appointed by u,ay o[ translcr:rs Scicnce Supr:r-r,isor in thc olficc of respondcnt No.3 vide G.O.llt.No.462 datcd 08.07.2008, in accorclance with thc alorcsaid G.O-l\4s.No.538 datcd 20.1 1 .1998. 5. It is further submitted that consequcnt upon bilurcation o[ thc State on O1.06.2016, the posts u,erc distributed among both the State in 58:42 ratio, and the pctitioners herein werc irtlocatcd to thc Srate of Telangana, and thcir rvorking units rr,erc shor.r rr as Director of SCtrltT, 'lelangana State, and the.1' havc continucd dischargir.rg thcir dutics. Flon,ever, on 23.O1.2024 and 25.0 ).2024. Lltc (iovcrnrncnt issued orders, instructing rcspondent No.3 to canccl ('crtain depu[zrtions and to repatriate the staff rvorking undcr his conrrol. r\ccordingly, alter thorough verification of records, respondcnt No.2 furnished a detailed PK"1 (y'202'5 W PN., . /r rll5 8 36839 rcport to lht' (iovtrrnmcnt viclc lcttcr dated 27 01 202', ' clczrrl)' statlng thiit tirc pctitlollcrs u'crc r'vorking in thc olfice ol rva1, o[ appointme nt by transfer rcsl :nclcnt No'3 by in regular and existrr I vac:rncics' and rc(lLlested the (iovcrnment to issue appropriate orrit t ; in tlle mattcr' llorr,cvcr.troordcrshavcbeenpasSedbytheGoVernl])]1tSofar, (r. lt is furth0r submittcd that basing on the r r petitioncrs cnrplclvccs uniorr. alleglng that thc arc scntertions of : ntiltuing in t hc caucelatiot ol'fir:e'oI rcsporrdcllL No 3 clcspitc t[-rc OoVernmcnt, resllondent No 3 adclressed ) -c orders ol tl-tc a lctter cl;l r c 25 01 !1025 to for canccllation of the petitiolr('s' dePul zrtton s' submitted thcir rr'l I es(lntations lo Inr mcdiatclY, thc petitioners rcsporldcnt No.2 rcsp<rt-tclctrt No.2 on 03 07 2-025, c'larilying lhat th(]i ilrc not rtorking orr dcputation bllt \\'crc appointcd by '"va1' o[ trans i r in the olficc ol r'('spondcllt No.3, in accordance with thc rulcs llor:ver' resJronclct-rt No.2 issttcd Lhc impugncd proccedings datcd rcsPoltdcnt No..] to canccl the pctitione rs' 24' 2025' directit'tg alleged r t il ut'ltions and to Clonscqucrrtl]" rcpatrialc thcnl to their parent dcpartment:i' or l':rs' botl'r dated No-3 issued thc impugned reliving rcspondcnl )g.11.2O2r, instructlng the pclitioners to rc1r liarimnargarr ar.rcl DEO, Adilabad, rcspcctively' rt befort: I)DO' -aa-r. PK, .J W.P.No.36B85 & 36889 of 2025 7. [t is further submitted that the posts of School Guidance and Counselor and Science Supervisor in SCERT are catcgorized undcr Class-[ posts under the rules issue in G_O.Ms.No.538 dated 20. 11.1998 and thc said posts are rcquired to bc firllecl in by transfer from School Assistants. As such, the pctitioncrs' appointmcnts are not deputations but regular appointment made by u,a1.o[ rransler in accordance rvith the statutory rules. It is furthcr submitted that the petitioners' \\rere appointed by way of transfcr b-v- virtuc of the Government orders vide G.O.Rt.No.813 dated 11.1 1.201 I and G.O.lRt.No.462 dated 08.07.2008, rcspecrively, zrnd neirhcr respondent No.2 nor respondent No.3 has the authorit_\ to canccl the said Government orders. [{os'cver, rvithout waiting lor thc orders from the Government and u,ithout vcriflring thc records, thc respondents havc issued the impugned orclers in a high,hancled and arbitrary manner, erroneously Lreating thc pctitioners appointmellt as deputation, and the same is a clear case of abuse of power and insubordination. Thus, the impugned orders are highly illegal, unjust, arbitrary, withcut application of mind, and contrary to the aforcsaid Rules. Therefore, learned counsel seek indulgence of this Court to set aside the impugncd proceedings datcd 21.1 1.2O25 and conscquential reliving orders dated 29.11.2025, \,ith a dircction to PK, ,] WP Ao. i 98.; & 36889 of2025 thc respondcnts to retain and continue the petitior-r,: s in the office of rcspondcnt No.3. 8. On tltc other hand, learned Government plea l :-, appearing on behall ol thc respondents, submits that both the tetirioners rvere initially appointcd as Secondary Grade Teachers in I e )'ear I 999 in Mar-rdal Praja Parishad School under Zilla Parish:rrl N,lanagement in tl're erstu'hilc l(arimnagar and Adilabad Districts r:spectively, ancl n'cre latcr promotcd as Schoo1 Assistants in :l ,()6 and 2OO2, rcspcctivel.v. tt is submitted that upon considering t ^ rir requests, the pctitioners \\,cre posred in thc ofl-rce of respondc No.3 only on dcputation/ tcrms of forcign service, in accordance s i tr G.O.(P).No. 10 datccl 22- 10. I993. I)etrtioner No.1 was deputed in tlr year 2010 as a Program C)lficcr, u,hile, petitioner No.2, who was orig i rall1. dcpured in thc vear 2OO7 to rvork in the Adolescence Edu: rt.ion Cell, rvas subsequentlv posted as Science Supervisor in the ,,:rrr 2008. It is submitted that thc Govcrnment issued orders vidt G.O.Rt.No.813 dated 11.11.2011 and G.O.Ms.No.462 dated O8.O7 !( ()8, p651lng ths pctitioners as School Guidauce Counselor and Sc r rLce Supervisor respectivelv, subject to the condition of implement,l iln of thc Fair Share Principlcs. PK, J W P.No.36885 & 36889 of 2025 9. It is submitted that in l-he year 2024, respondent No. I has revicrvc-d lhe deputations o[ all the crnplol,ees and issued ordcrs vidc Ir,[emos dated 23.01.2O24 and 25.01.2024, drrecting canccllarion and repatriation of all deputations beyond three years'period. As these orders rvere never modified or withdrawn, in pursuance thereof, respondent No.2 issued the impugned proceedings daLed 24.71.2025, canceling the deputation of the petitioners and consequential rclieving ordcrs dated 04.12.2025, were issued by rcspondent No.3, which u.erc con'rmunicated to thcm through WhatsApp as the pctrtioners \\'erc unavzrilable in the office oI respondenL No.3. 10. [t is fur[her submitted that the peLitioners are governed under the Unified Service Rules of Teachers working in (iovernment and Zllla Parishad Schools issued under G.O.Ms.No.538 dated t6.1 1.1998, which provides for recruitment by transler on the basis ol a criteria that may be fixed by the Govcrnment from time to time. I-lou'evcr, the said Unihed Servicc Rules were sct aside bv a Division Bench of this Court in M. Kesa.uulu qnd others u. State oJ Andhra Prad.esh and otherst, and the matter \\ras carried to the Hon,ble Apex Court. As such, once the very sourcc of the pctit-ioners'posting u,as struck down, and it is afhrmed that the services of teachers of | 2003 (6) ALD 522 (DB) PK,.I t{lPNo I t85 & .)6881) of 2025 Govcrnment sclrools ^nd zilla Parisl-rad schools arc I stinct s.rvices undcr thc Pr-csidenrral Ordcr, thc petitioncrs, bc ng local body emplovecs, citrrnot claim a righL to hold posts i1 a Statc-levcl Government institution likc SCDRT or claim any rcl r I basing on thc said G.O. It is lu rthcr submitted that aJter the Unif r I Scrvice Rules in G.O.Ms.No.538 u'crc struck dorvn, the Governnr nt issued neu, Rulcs undcr (l.O.l\,ls.Nos.95 and 96, both dated 2._<. )7.20O5, rvhich u,erc also str-ucl< dorvr-r by a Division Bench ol lhis Corrrt in Goaernment oJ A.P. and others u. P. Vemq. Red.d. r and. others2, u,hich ',vas also :rlfirmccl by t}'rc Hon'ble Apex Court. l'hereaftcr, thc Governmcnt harl issrrcd lrcsh ad hoc rules vide G.(). 4s.No.12 daLed 23.OI.2009, govcrnir-re thc tcachers o[ local body schr < ls, ar-rd there is no provision und<:r tl-rcsc rules for recruitment by trr tsfer of School Assistants to SCIEtR'l'. IIencc, there is presently no sr.l ttor).provision cnablir.tg pcrmancnt rransler of Zllla Parishad teach( -j into SCERT sen,icr:. It is further sLtbmittcd that cluring lhc State r< trganization in 2O 14, onlv thc posts s,erc provisionally allocatr_'rl and nor. the individuals, and the said allocation never converted I r:ir depulation into regular absorptron. Therefore, the petitioners (.. tnot clailn for continuation in the 0lfice of rcspondent No.3 as a : atter of right. ,2007 {4) ALD 209 (DBl W. P. No.36885 PK, J & 36a89 of2025 Hence, it is prayed to dismiss the present writ. petitions. Reliance has been placed on t-he following decisions of the Hon'ble Apex Court and thc Division Bench of the erstu'hile High Court of Judicature of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad: il Managing Director, U.P. Rajkiga. Nirtnan Nigam u. P,K. Bhatnagor and. others3 ii) Nesar Ahmed and. clnother u State oJ Jhq.rkhand. and. othersa, iii) Union o;f India u. Phq.ni Busha.n Kundu and. otherss, ivl Jgostnanna.gee Mishra u. Strrte of Od.isho. and others6, vl M. Kesavulu and others u. Stqte oJ Andhra Prad.esh and. others (referred supra), and; vll Gouernment of A.P. and others u. P. Vema Reddg and others (rclerred supra), 11. In rcply, learned counsel for the petitioners submit that although the petitioners were ini[ially appointed as Secondary, Grade Teachers in Zilla Parishad schools and u,erc subsequcntly promotcd as School Assistants, they wcre posted in the office of rcspondent No.3 against the sanctioned vacancies, and the said postings were not stop-gap arrangements, but were made through lormal Government Orders. It is lurther submitted that during the rcorganization of thc r (2007) r{ scc 498 1 (201+) 11 SCC 394 I Crvrl Appcal \o.22850 o12024 datcd l8 t2.2024 6 2025 SCC Onlrnc SC 117 PK, J W.P.Na.: ( l'35 B: 36889 of 2O25 State in 2O 14. the posts held by the petitioners I SCER'I' werc allocated to the Statc ol 'l'cl:rng:rrla Vide proceedings (L ted 01 06 2014 and Lhe pctiliorlers \\'crc contirluccl zLccordingly virlr proceedings of respondentNo.lldalcd0206.2Ol4.Assuch,the(r'rltcrltionoflhe respondents that onl]' the posts were allocated I I the State ol Telangana ancl not thc individuals is contrary to thc I rders issued by the Govcrnm(rnl vide G.O.Ms.Nos.241 and )+ ; tloth dated 01.06.2014. 12. It is furt l-rer submitted that the Governmelrt issr'ted Memos datcd 23.O1.2024 ancl 2-->.O1.2024, directing :rrnccllation of deputations cxr:eeding tllree vcars, and re spondet: t No'2 soughl a categorical clarification about thc petitioners '" t t: Ietter dated 27.O1.2024, btrt no inlorrnaLion r'va s furnished thertr f As such' the assumption of the rcspondents that in the absen< ( of any specihc orders,theMemosdatecl230l.2024aod25'Ol'2O')'+\vouldprevailis wholly misleading atLld Lllltenal)lc. Further, lhe sai<l I\'{emos are also inalrplicablc to Lhc l)ctiti()rlcrs. since lheir posting irr SiCtrRT u'as not on deputatiott but bv u ay ol appoiLrtment by trar 'r f:r by virtue of G.O.Ms.No.813 daled 1i-11.2011 and G O NI No 462 datcd O8.07.2008. It is sLl[)mittcd that the rcsponrl' rlts themselves -Lfying that the addrcssecl communications to thc Government ,:le 71, PK, J w.P.No.36885 & 36889 of 2025 pclitioncrs' were postcd not on dcputation basis but by transfers. I?urther, ririthout artv orders of cancelling their original transfer ordcrs, respondent Nos.2 and 3 ought not to have trcatcd the pctitioners as dcpurees and issued the prescnt impugned orders. It is further submitted that the impugncd relicving orders were issued in a highly arbitrary and hasty manner, without proper service, and even during subsistencc of the sfatus quo orders ol this Court. As such, thc subsequent Government Memo dated 04.12.2025 ratifying the impugncd action is zrlso contrar),to the interim protection granted by [his Court. 13. It is further submitted that the reliance placcd upon thc applicability of the Rulcs issued in G.O.Ms.No.538 clated 20.ll.Dga, is misplaced, as the pctitioncrs were promotcd to the post of School Assistanls in purst: ance of the rules issued by the Government in G.O.Ms.No.96 dated 25.O7.2005, which provides for appointment of School Assistzrnts to thc posts in the SCtrRT, under in Rule-2, Class-1, CaLtegorS, I9 to 21 thcrein. Furthcr, para 5(2)(b) of thc Presidential Order-2O18, provides for transfer or appointment by transfer of a pcrson from any local cadrc to any ofhce or cstablishment to rvhich the said order does not apply. As such, since SCERT, being a State Ievel institution, is excludcd from the purvier,,", of the presidential PK, J W.P.itt . 6885 & 36qtl9 of 2O2S Ordcr, appointments b.y transler from local cadrl; are pcrmitted, subjcct to equitable sharing, ancl there is no prohib r on against such appointments. It is further submirted that the relial :c placed b), the respondents upon C].O.N,,ls.No. 12 dared 23.01.2OO9 ir also misplaced, as the said ad hoc rules govent onll.tcachers rvot-I.t tg in local body schools, and the,v clo no eovern thc posts in SCERT. v..hich posts are held by the pcLitioncrs. l'hcrc[or-c, leantcd counsel t( - the pctitioncrs once again pra]' this Court to sct asidc the impug: :l orders dated 29.11.2025 ernd O4. t2 2025, ancl ro direct the -3spondents to continue thc petitioners in the office o[ responde: No.3 with all consequential benefi ts. 14. [n support of thcir casc, rcliancc has been .].rced upol-r thc lollon'ing decisio.s or thc Ilon brc Apex court arrd thr' lecisions of the Jharkhand I-ligh Court: il Food Corporation of India u M/s. Kamadhe,'u Cattle Feed IndustriesT ll) Naajgoti Coop. Group Housing Societg and. t thers u. Union o;f India and othersg iir) Vinod Kumq.r u. Stdte of Haryanas iv) Secund.erabad. Club Etc. u. C.I.T.-V Etc.to 7 (1993) I I SCC 7l 3 (1992) SCC 477 e AIR 201.1 SC ,,, AIRONT_tNta 2023 S( 70, -a13 1'K, J w.P.No.36885 & 36889 oI2O25 v) S.N. Maity u. Union oJ Indial t vll Amrendra Kumar & Ors. u. Ranchi Regional Deuelopment Authorit!2, and vli) Birendra Kumar Shanna u. State of Jha.rkhanflta 15. This Court has taken note ol the rival submissions made by lcarned counsel for the rcspectivc parties and perused the material on record. 16. Admittedly, the pctitioners in Lhesc two writ petitions were initially appointed as Sccondar,y Grade Teachers on 26.10.1998 and 14.08. 1998 respectivel!, in Zllla Parishad Schools at l(arimnagar and Aditabad Districts, rcspectively, u.hich fall under local body management, and rvere subsequently promoted as School Assistants on 03.03.2006 on 20.IO.2OO2 under the same management. Thereafter, upon considcring their ou,n requests, petitioner No.1 r,l,as initially deputed ers Programme Officer in SCBRT vide Memo dated 2l.lO.2OlO, u,hilc petitioncr No.2 rvas deputed to work in thc Adolescence Educattion Ccll of rcspondcnr No.3 vide procecdings dated 26.O2.2OO7. Later, by vir[uc of G.O.Rt.No.813 dated I 1.11.2011, petitioner No- 1 L' 2006 (3) AIR JHAR R 526 r: 2014 (,r) A,JR 459 rr AIRONLINE 2020 JHA 1.10(r \'as posted as School Guidance PK, J W.P lro . -r385 & 368t19 ol2O2S counselor, and vidc (].o.Rt.No.4(r2 datcd og.07.2cr( [ . pcLitioner No.2 ,"r,as posted as Scier-lcc Su pervisor, both in rhe oll i, c of respondcnt No.3. Hcrc it is relevalt to refer to the aforesa:c r rdcrs. and the relevant portion is extracted hereunder: (i) G.O.Rt.No.813 dated 1l.l l.20 11, in respect ot pctirir rr:r No. l: "4. Govel nmen( after careful cxamination of the rr-ar r, hercby der-ldg 1o appoint br rransfnr Sm1. p l\ladlravr. Sclr,, ,\sststan t (Enghsh). u ho is ltrcsentl_r' rrorking orr dcplrtirtlon as .1 [ ,)gfaunmc Officcr ar SCDI?'I , I{r,dcrabad lo rhe poar o[ School (I ,rdance & Counsclor (School {ssistant) in th(: cxisting vacancr t SC IiRT, I ll,dcrabacl with rhc conditioD that .,Fair Sharr. pr r rrple is implem"rrt,,,l. r.o all lor al urrirs arr- r.prcsl-lltcd lll . l grving cqual oppor.tunitrcs to all Units of Appornrrnent .. proccss, (ii) C.O.RL.No..162 darcd 08.07.20O8, in respcct oI pcrrrrl r,:r No.2: " In lllc' circumstances reported b_v tlte Dircct{)l r' Sclrool Education. llyderabad in his letter 4rh reacl abovc. Cr . rrnment aftcr careful examination of the matter, hercbt, accor<l 'r mission to tlre Dircclor of School Educariorr. llvdcrabad. 1o 1,,,: Srnt. A. Uma Rani, School Asst., Z.p.S.S. (Cirls). Rarnal. r s hnapur, Mandamarrr Mandal, Adilabad District, prcsentl\ \, ( <ing on deputation in SCDRf in Adolcsccncc Edr-rcation. zr: Science Supcwisor in thc office of the Director, SCEIIT.. HvrlcraL rr l. in tlrc 1_ exist ing vacancy. '' 17. From a barc reacling ol the abovc, it is clcar rhaL r hc petitioncrs, \'vho were employces oi iocal body (Zilla parishad) scf )ols have bcen posted in the olflce of respondent No.3, \\,hich i a statc-lcvel institution as pcr thc prcsidential Order- 1975, orr r l.air Share Principle basis, and upon the strcngth of these orclers. Ihc petitioners claim that their scrvices were no longer utilized on d I ).ltation basis, - PR, J W.P.No.36885 & 36889 of 2025 ralher they were converLed into regular appointments by way o[ transfer. 18. To substantiate their claim' the petitioncrs heavily relied upon the Special Rulcs/Rules for the Andhra Pradesh School Educational Subordinate Service (unihed service rules for teachers working in lhc Government and Panchayat Raj tnstitutions), issued by the erstwhile Government of Andhra Pradcsh undcr G'O'Ms'No 538 dated 20. 1 1.1998 as wcll as thc Spccial Iltrlcs for the Andhra Pradesh School Educational Subordinatc Service issued subsequcntly vide G.O.Ms.No.g6daLed2S.OT.2OO5,bothoIwhich,admittedly'included a provision for transfer of local body school teachers to the state-level institutions, such as SCFIRT However, tl-re aforesaid Rules issued of this under G.O.Ms.No.538 were assailed before thc Division Bench judgment Court in M. Keso/t tlu (supra), iLnd Lhc Division Bench vide dated18.ll.2oo3hadsetasidethesaidRules.Thefollowingisthe rclevant porLion of the said decision: it is clear that thee<lucationalinstitutiorrs-urr<tertlrc|nanagcmentandcontroloftheon Mandaf Praja Parishads and Zilla I'raja Parishads are trcated the of Jiff"*", pai thougll thcy are cxpcctcd to [ollow t-tre provisions Mandal halds of in.the lies control aird management yet, their Act, ttut pi"i. p.ri"t and' Zlla Praja Paristrads as the case maybe. The "a" CoJ".,-r-",,, is obliged to relcase thc grant-in aid to the institutions undcrthetocalauthoritiesinaccordance$,iththeprovisionsreferredtoby run above. Even when the Government takes over the institutions 24.'I'herefore, from a readtng of the aforesaid provisions' the local authorities or Mandal Praja P:rrishads or Zllla Praja Parishads' PK, J W I'..\ . ( 885 &:36889 of 2025 the teachers and other employees subject to their ol)t c r becomt: Lhe employees of the Government and uice uersa also li in case of Government rnstrtutions rvhen taken over by the loc.r r rt horitY the employees of such institutions become the emplole,l ol tltc Tilla Parishads sul)ject to their option. 25. Thereforc, a clear cut distinction ls being maint;1]r .tl there. The tcachers and other employees employed in the Educatro r Ll Irrstitutiorrs maintained and controlled by the Z.P.Ps. and M.P.Ps. rtr€ rn a sepirrare slot. 94. In a similar identical situation, the Supreme Courl hrLr o decrdc another case reported in V. Jagennaahq Rao v. Slote o/ 4 i . (20o l) 10 SCC 401, hekl thus: "13) Organisation of local catlrc (1) 1'hc State Oo!.r |nrent shall, within a periocl of twelve months from the comnlen I r renL o[ thrs order, organize classes of posts in the civil services o[. : r.d classes of civil posts under the State into different local cad.(r irr clillerent parts of the State to the extent, and in the mann- hereinafter provided. (2) The posts belonging to the category of Lou,er [)rvrsir I Clcrk, and to each of the other categories equivalent to, or lo\r.er t r;tn thart of il [-ou,er Divrsron Clerk, in each department in each I) s rrct shall I)e organDed into a separate cadre. DxpLanotion..*For the purposes of this sub-p.u. I r irph. sub paragraph (1) of Paragraph 6, and sub-paragraph (l) ol ), tragr aph 8, a category shall be deemed to be equivalent to or l()\rr r than thar of [-o!r'er Division Clerk, if the rninimum of the scale (,[ I rv of a post belonging to that category or, where the post carrie,; :r lixerl pa1, such fixed pay, is equal to or lower than the minimrrrt r the sc.rle of pa_v of a Lorver Drvision Clerk. (3) 'l'he posts belonging to each non gazetted catcgor\ othcr tl)an those refer-red to in sub paragraph (2), in each deparrr ('rl t ir) eacll zone shall be organised into a separate cadrc. {4) 'l'he posls belonging to each specified Gazetted crrt., (,n, ur caclr depiirtment in each zone shall be organised rnto a sep.rr, r carlrc. (5) Notwithstanding anything contained in sub-paragr r rhs f3) and (4), the St.rte Government may, where it considers it er -:.lienr so to do and with approval of the Centrat Government, org,rl x: the posts belonging to arly of the categories referred to ther r :1, ir) an\ 1., PK, J W.P.No.36885 & 36889 of 2025 department, or a-ny cstablishment thercof, in t$'o or more continuous zoncs into a single cadre. (6) (7) in organizing a separate cadre in rcspect of anl, category of posts in any department for any part of t[]e State , nothing in this order shall be deemed to prcvent the State GovcrnmcrtL from organizinB or contlnuing more than onc cadre in respcct of such category in such department for such part of the State, (8) Where the Central Govcrnmcnt is satisfrcd that, it is not practicable or expedient to organize local cadres urlder tl.tis paragraph in respect of any non-gazetted catcBory o[ posts in any department, it may, b,y notification, urake a declirratioll, to that effect and on such declaration, thc provisions oI this paragraph shad rtot apply to such categor) of posts. 5. htcal cadres and. trdnskr of persons'. (l) Enr:h part of the State, for which a local cadre has been organiscd in rcspect of any category of posts, shalt be a separate unit for purposcs of recruitment, appointment, discharge, seniority, promotion :rnd transfcr, and such other matters as may be specified by the StaLe Government, in respcct of that cateSory o[ post. (2) Nothing in this order shall prevent the Stale Govcrrltrent from making provisions fo r: (a) the transfer of a person from any local citdre to auy olficc or establishment to which this ordcr does not apply, or uiceuersa, (b) the transfcr o[ a person from a locarl cadrc comprising posts tn any office or establishmcnt excrcisiug tcrritorial jurisdiction over a part o[ the State to an]' other l<x'al cadrc comprising posts in such part, or uice-uersa; a,r<) (c) the transfer of a pcrson from onc local cadre to arlother local cadre where no qualified or suttable pcrsorl ls avarlable in the lattcr cadre or whcre such transfcr is otherwisc considered necessary in thc pubtic intcrest." Whitc tracing the object of Articlc3Tl-Dof the Constitution of India, the Suprcme Court observed thus: " 1 1. The object o[ endcttng Afiicle 37 1'D appeus to be two-fold: PK, J WP Ab . ;,185 & 368E9 of 2L)2r (l) To l)romote equal development of the backu,a; r lreas of the Slalc of Andhra Pradesh, so far as to siel l.e balanccd de\,lrlopment of the State as a whole. (2) To provide equitable opportunities to different are.rs o[ the Statc in the matter of education, employrne I an(l career prospects in public service. (12) This was observed to be so in Chief Justice of Anrln, prulesh t v. I-.V.A. Dikshttutu ((1979) 2 SCC 34 : AIR i979 sc t93). t3. It is to be noted that para 5(1) of the presidential Or(( , rs rn terms of Para. 3(3). the,reof. Pa_ra 3(3) postulates that each del)arr r,rnr in each zone shall be orgarised into a separate cadre. parir 5( speaks ol separate unit for purposes of recruitment, appointrneri) dis<.tr:rrge, seniority, prontotion and transfer and Such other ma e: :ts rna! lte specified bY rhe State Government in respect of the cat(.1 r.,,, r,t posts and each part ()f the State for which local cadre has becr rr.ganise<l in respec-t of an\. Category of posts in required to have a sepa rLte unit lbr the aloresai(l I)urposes. para 5(2) is in the nature of ,n cnablinB provision which authorizes the State Government to make r,visjons for translerin certain specified circumstances. The present cl I! )ute relatcs to Para 5(2)(cl. It speaks o[ a "transfer". Attempt ot the €rl ],lanrs is to give enlarged rneaning to the expression to include promoi (F r rl aspects It has been contended in that context that though piLra .)(l) treats promotion and transfer separately, yet that distinction \J Uld not be apphcable to c.rses covered by para 5(2). The contcntt) is clearlr u n le na ble.' Interpreting tlre words transfer in para 5(2)(c) of the presirler i.rl C)rder, the Supreme CoLrrt held that it does not take in the pronr()t c I the Supreme Court observed in para lg as follows: "18. We find that Para 5(2) of the presidential Orrl<r ;peaks of transfer an(l not of promotion. It would be hazardous t.r r ccept the contention ol the appellants that promotion is inclrLr ecl rn expressiol ltansfFr' and no assislance can be ava l,.r frorn tlre the disturctiorr rnade in Par.a 5(1) of the Order. No provisions c ' lvord II1 a statute has ro be read in isolation. In fact, the statute lr. s to bc reatd as a rvhole. .{ statllte is an edict of the Legislature. It ca r ()t be l(l tlrat lvithout any purpose the distinctio; was ma(le j. )ar.r sit 5( I ) betrveen tritDsler and promotion and such distinctirr was llot rntencled to l)e operative in para 5(2). The inrentiorr of the [-egislature is primarily to be gathers L from lhe Ianguage used, rvhiclr means that attention should be irid as to what has becn said as also to what has not been sai;. ,i( ( ',iohtl. Att ioner of weatth Tax, Neu Oem, gOozi: ;,:c sr r , fj1a1.-va_cllyrniss AIR 1997 SC I 165 aod Instttute of Chartered. Ai.Lrntrl, tl , ,,; htdict v. -- PK, J W.P.No j6885 & 36889 of 2025 Price Water House, 11997) 6 SCC 312 : AIR 1998 SC 74 As a consequence a constructlon which rcquircs for its support additiorr or substitution of words or which resorts for rejection of words zls meaningless has to b€ avoided. As stated by the Priv)' Ootrncil in Robert Wigram Crowford v. Richard Spoorter, 1846 (6) Moorc P(l l. "We cannot ajd the Legislature's dcfective phrasing of an Act. lvc cannot add or mend and, by construction make deficiencies u'hir:h are left there". The aforesaid decision was referrecl to b1'this Court in stote of Gujqrat v. Dilipbhai Na|hjibhai Palel,.JT 1998 (2) sC 253. It is contrary to all rules of construction to read words into an Acl rrnless it is absolutety necessary to do so. (See Slock v. Frattk Jones (Tlttan) Ltd., lgTA (i) All. ER 948 (l{L). Srmilarty, it is wrong arrd dangerous to proceed by substituting some other words for words oI the statute. (See Pinner v. Eueretl, 1969 (3) Att. ER 257. In othcr lvords, there shoutd be no attempt to substitute or paraphrase of general application. Attention shoutd be confined [o lvhitt is nccessarl for deciding a particular case. Much trouble is madc br- substttutirtg other phrases assumed to be equivalent, whicl't thetr ale reasonccl from as if tlley were in the Act. In U4ion of lrtlia v. Deoki NtttLdarr Aggarlaol, 1992 Supp (1) SCC 323 : AIR 1992 SC 96, it lvas observcd that the Court cannot refrain the Legislature for thc very good reason that it has no power to tegislate lt is incumbcr.lt on thc Court [o avoid the construction if reasonably permissiblc on the language which would render a part of thc statute devoid o[ an-t' nlcaning or application. In the interpretation of statutes, the Courts always pi""r-e that the Legislature inserted every part thereof for :r purpose and the legislative intention is tllat every part of tlle statutc should havc an effect." Under those circumstances, we are o[ the considered view that G.O.Ms. No. 538 is not sustainable in law and the samc is hablc to bc set aside. So also the G,O.Ms. No. 505, so far as it seeks to eulbrac(: the posts in Education Department for rvhich the local cadre has been orgitnized itr G.O.Ms- No. 529, dated 14.5.1976 uiz., in respect of the Deput! lnspector of Schools, Headmaster and Educational Officers, the posts of (iazetted Hea.lmasters, and Head Mistresses, and also Cazelled Head Masters, Headmistresses Grade-ll, in Government IIigtr Schools is declarcd as illcgal and invalid." 99. 19. Likewise, the Special Rules for Andhra Pradesh School Educational Subordinate Scrvice issued under G.O.Ms No.96 datcd 25.07.2OO5, were also struck down by the Division l3ench of this PK, J W.P.l.io. j385 & 36889 of 202a Court in P. Vemq Reddy (supra) vide order dated 28. !2.2OOT, holding the treatment ol tcachers in Government and local rr ,rly (Man<lal zrncl Zilla Parishad) Schools as a unified cadre, ancl a .ommon unit ol appointment, ctc., il.s unconstitutional. The relevar L portion of the said decision is extracted hereunder: 19. object oI organizing different local cadres for c flerent parls ^TIte is clear from paragraphs of the State 4 and S of the pres ( jntral Order. Under Para 4(l) persons holding posts, required to bt: r ganizcd inlo " local ca(lres, rvere to be allotted to such cadres I I the State Covernment in accordance with the principle and pror:ec l.e spectlied in the l)residential Order. Under para 5(l) each part oI r r: Stzrte, lbr rvhrch a local cadre has been organized i., ."sp.ct of an,, .ittegories posts, shall be a separate unit for puipose" o[ 1:cruitmenr.oI appornlmcnt, seniority, promotion, transfer erc. Once a lr c r cadre rvas organized rrnder para 3(1) each part of the State, for \ rch such a local cadre $:rs organized, was required to be treated I a separate unit and it is onty from amongst persons allotted I ereto rvas promotrons to be effected and their seniority determinr ( In vierv of Para 5(l), a local cadre is a distinct and sepaiate unit anl lbr mattcrs prescribed therein, persons who do not belong to the sa r ocal carlrr: or those \\'ho belong to other local cadres cannot form pt t thereol It is lor tlus reason that, both rn S. prakqsha Rao v. Co,n ntsstoner oJ Comntercial 'ltlxes, (1990) 2 SCC 259 : AIR 1990 SC !)! : and in M. Kesauulrr s cc-se (supra), the Supreme Court and the Dirisi ,rr tJench of this Court held that a local cadre, once organized, cannct be meddled with. 81. W.P. No. 17548 ot2006 filed by the Government o[t. and W.1,. No. 17628 ot 20O6 fileil by the State Teacher Unions ar '.dism issed arrd \l'.1,. Nos. 18666, t9459,23362 of 2O06 are allou cl W.P. Nos. 17051. t7o7a' and t677t of 2O06 are filed by teachen: ,t orkrng rn Government schools qLlestioning the orders tra-nsferrino I ,m to Zill.r l)arishad Scl,ools. Since the petirioners therein. teacher: .r orking in Goverrrrrrent S, hools. bel(,nB to a local cadre q,hich is a sr )irrate u nit for llrr' prrrpose o[ apporntment, seniority, promolion, rr r r sfer elr._, their transl'er to the services o[ a loca] which I.r r not [)een, "riho.lty and cannot be, organized lnto a local cadre is illegal. Cols, I uentlv all ttrese three $ rit petitions are also allowed. .- W.P.No.:1688r & 36889 of 2O2r 20. In thc above referred two judgments, it has categorically been held that the integration of teachers rvorking in rccal bocries u,irh the teachers rvorking in Government schools is unconstitutio.al. and r-he samc lrras also afhrmed by the t{on,ble Apex Court, 21. Ultimately, the Government issued G.O.Ms.No.12 datcd 23.01.2OO9, framing ad hoc servrce rulcs in rcspecr of thc local body (Mandal Prajaparishad and Zrlla prajaparishad) teachers. Horltver, thcse ad hoc Rules do not contain any provision that authorizes absorption o[ local body tcachers into state-lcvcl lnstitution. such as SCERT, as a matter of right or permancnt absorption. 22. From the above, it is clear that b1, thc time thc petitioners s,ere posted in the office of rcspondcnt No.3, the verv statutorv sollrces under G.O.Ms.No.538 dared 20.11.199g and G.O.Ms.No.96 clirred 25.07.2OO5, r'hich could have been invoked to justify their posri.u regular appointment, were struck down by thc Division Benches as this Court on 18.09.2003 and 2g.O2.2OO7 respectively, i.e., much prior ro Lhe issuance of G.O.Ms.No.g13 dated 11.11.20 11 and G.O.Ms.No.462 dated 08.O7.2OO8. No other enabling provision exrsts, in thc subsequent Rules issued undcr G.O.Ms.No.l2 dated 23.O1.2009. lor transfcr of local body school tcachers into SCIiRT. F-urther, from n PK, .] tV.P-,Vo i ti85 8; 36889 of 2025 bare perusal ol thc pctitioners' posting orders vidc l,.O.Ms.Nos.g13 and 162. rt is clear rlrat thcy \\rerc postcd in SCtrRT i- implemcntzrtion of the 'Fair Sh.re I)ri.ciplc', *,hich clearly ir-rdicat rs rotatiorl and equitablc oppor tunit\/, but not pcrmanent absorpti( I . As such, thc mcre usage o[ 'appointment b1, 1p2n"1"r, clause in ; r:titioner No.1,s transfer G.O. also cannot supersede the absen,t(, ,tf a statutory provision for rcgular appointment_ Hence, in thc rbscnce ol any statutory enabling provision, the pctitioners can r c,t claim tl-reir posting in officc o[ respondcnt No.3 as a regular on(. Thereforc, the further conLcntro, ol the pctitioners that the respond: rts Jrave Irastily issrred thc impr-rgncrl orders, cannot be countenancc 1, as thc sarnc r'r,cre issucd in pursrrance ol thc earlier Governmc I Mr:mos clated 23.O1.2024 and 25.01.2024, and the subsequcrr Mcmo rlated 04.12.2025, ralifl ing the said orders also cannot bc ft,r r.rd fault u,ith. 23. In view o[ the abovc, this Court is of the consirlt r :d opinion that thc petitioners' posrings in SCERT cannot be con:;tr red as regular appointmcnts, sincc they tv cre uoid ab initio and cor r I ery to law. As sucl-r, their colt[inuat.ion, rcgardless of the length of LLcir tenure, is Iegally unsustainable and impcrmissiblc. At best, th. r postings can be trcated as d cpu ta tion / tcnure-based arrangemcnLs. PK, J W.P No.36885 & 36889 of 2A2S 24. The Hon'ble Apex Court has been consistently holding that even a prolongcd length of service does not convcrt a dcputation into regular appointment, and the deputees would not acquire be absorbed in the borrowing department mercly becau a right ro se they ltave rendcred thcir services for several years. In p.K, Bhdtnagar (supra), thc Hon'ble Apex Court held that an employee, when on deputation, cannol claim to bc a regular employee in the deputed organization place of rvork. 1'he tollowing is lhe relevant cxcerpt or of thc sili.i dccision 11. In ou.r oprnion, Respondent 1 cannot, by reason ol atlrlude adop(ed b\ the Slate Covernment. (laim lo .on,,,,l-,aanv ,r, scrvice rvith the appcllant. The records of thc case clcarlv shorr that Respondent I ar all material trmes u,as." a"fri"i_"'rilitr., ,r," appcllant- Thc State Covernrrrcnt had senr nl,"pr"J."i f." deputation to the appcllant and also passed the o.a.. of rcpatriation on the basis that Respondent I rvas an .^oio1,." of the State covernment. If the Srate Government d;";;" ;;;;" ..ry otlter stand at this stage that \vould have to be a".ia.O-in tt. proceedings other than these. For the purposes oi tflrc .""" have no hesitation in holding that Responient "r,," f *,." 1f," Stut. uovernment's employcc and rvas sent on deputation to the Now rhar rhe reparriation order has 1r."" p."."a'fx tn" :I)p."-111", Jratre,(,ovcrnmenl, Respondent I cannot clatm lo l_re irr sclnrrc \rrrn Ule appellant.'l'he mere lact that he has spent in sen,ice of the appelant wilt not alrer R"ilil;;;l;" several \ears ;;;il,, from that of a dcputationist to.-1^regular emplovee 'Siore lSee o7 8 scc s?2 : rees a'cc ria,sr 5+t r r" 3]r:,r-:l:111:. rrc clrcumstances "rnshllteez) ol thc case, thc appeal is allorred anci dccisiorl o[ the High Court is sct aside. TIc Starc Cor,.r.,-.r,t the gite,cffecr ro.the orders passcd bv thc Statc C n"",-rr.",ri'""',,." "n.if i ," Dl Ur. appcuanl on lg_1.1994. l4 9 1994 and 2g I lg93 f PK, ,] l,Y /'.No..J( I 15 & 36889 ol'2025 25- ln Phoni Bhusan Kundu (supra), the Hon'blc -\ >:x Court. hcld as under "8. In our oprnron. the ricrt exprcsscd bl, the CAT, ar i uphcld bl, the High CoLrrt. is con[ran' to the larv and is unsrr t iinable. The scopc and mcaning of the word 'deputation'in sen,i; aw was explaincd bl this Court in State of Punjab and others v. lq l,?r Sngh and Others. mcans service outside the cadre or outsid,l t ( parent departrnen[. that rs. rn anothcr department on a tempo-r ry basis. Aftcr thc cxpin of thc pcriod of dcputation, such an 'r n ployce reverts to his parcnt dcpartmcnt to occupv thc sarne fosition unless, irr rhe rnr.an,.r,hile. hc earnecl a prornotion in-t s parent departnrcnr as In'r rccrultntcnt rulcs. Thc deputee l,)es not becorlc a rcgul:rr cmplovec rn the borrowed servrce/C,:t artment. The depurccs licn on the post ir1 the parent departmcr.tt C ,lltlnues. Deputation docs not resLrlt in absorption in th,-- xrrrorvcd dcpartmcnt / se n'i( c- 9. Thc exPrcssron 'appoltltlnent on deputation" ant[ 'ransfer on dcput:rtrou rn?r\ I)c cliflircnt. l)ut this docs not mea I t ]at any vcstcd righL,.rotrld accruc lo respoltdcnt no. 1, Phirrit lhrLsan Kundu, unlcss hc rs absorbcd in the I trrorvrng departmc n t/ sen icc. 15. ln vicrr of thc aforesairi position, the impugned j ] Illment is set asidc and thc appcal is allorved. Resultantll ().A. No. 35O/O1256 ol 2O1.1 preferrcrl by respondent nd. I, Pht.r i Bhusan Kun<lu. till bc uc:lLcd as <lismisscd. Ilowcver. responl nt no. 1, Phani llhusan l(r.Lndu. rlill contrnuc to get his pcnsio-r i; payable undcr the \\'B l)ensron RLrlcs.' 26. In view o[ thc abovc, sincc the petitioners'posti.r l,i in the olfice of rcspondcnt No.3 arre not on rcgular basis, but .,r 3 deputation/ tenure based arrangcments, the further contention ()1 he petitione rs that, having rcndered more than (14) and (17) yea s of serviccs, respcctively, in the oflicc o[ respondent No.3, they ].rrr (: a legitimate expcctation for continuation, also cannot be countenarr, (d- iiffii*r', -a PK, ,I W.P.No.s6885 & 36869 ol 2O2S I 27. Further, it is to be noted that deputation cannot be continued indefinitely. As per G.O.(P).No. t0 dated 22.01. 1993, the period of deputation is restricted to three years. extendable for a further period of two years. Hou,ever, in the instant case, the petitioners have been discharging their services in the office of respondent No.3 for over a deceLdc, which is totally impermissible under law. 24. The othcr contention of the petitioners is thaL during bifurcation, they werc allotted to the State of Telangana, and u,ere postcd in the olfice of respondent No.3. However, from a perusal ol the proceedings in Rc.No. 187 lF1-2 /2014 dated O 1.06.2014 and Proc.Rc.No.I /A/,SCERT/TS i20t4 d.aLed, 02.06.2Oi4, it is clear that the said allotments and postings u.cre only provisionai in nature. ancl there is a clear indication in the said proceedings that the flna.l allocation of employees would be made at the appropriate times, as per the guidclincs issued by rhc Government. Therefore, the aforesaid contention of the petitioners also cannot be accepted. Further, though the petitioners also relied upon certain Government orders, viz., G.O.Ms.Nos.24l and 245, both dated 01 .06.2014, no material has been placed berore this court to demonstrate their claim. As such, this Court is not inclined to express an opinion on the same. PK, J W.P ^'o. i985 & 36889 of2025 29. In the light ol thc abo'e made discussion, thr Cecisions relied upon b1' thc r)ctitio.crs arc distinguishable .rr facts ancr are inapplicable to llte prcsent case. 30. In vicvr, ol thc above, this Court does not hnd r ny infirmities in the impugnccl rcpatriation and reliving orders daterl I,.4.I I .2025 and 29.11.2025, rcspcctivcly, and therefore, the writ pet [.ons arc clcvoid of merit and :rrc liable to be dismisscd. . Accordingly, thc Writ petitions are dismissed Misccllancous applications, it any, pendin: in these .u,rit petitions, shall stanrl closcd. No costs. SD/. A.I; TEENIVASA REDDY SI; STANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY/' To 8gs[''])'?'e # 2 ?ffi 33 Jiisi ?g?'#v' Hvderabad. [OUT] Triic CD CoPies PSK, TKS \)--- SECTION OFFICER r IPUCI for i ate of Telangana' at CC TODAY HIGH COURT DATED:2610312026 t'(. COMMON ORDER WP.Nos.36885 AND 36889 of 20& e OF a{ a$ F d. \\ 1')/J, + q.' ' DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONS WITHOUT COSTS bL r,Q'- v,.- j*t-,{' ':\' -.'-----' $s +

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All Telangana HC judgments →
LegalFirms.in Directory
Find an advocate for this matter
Dealing with a similar case? Find an advocate who handles this kind of matter on LegalFirms.in.
Find an advocate →