Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC011032562017
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY,THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION NO: 45092 OF 2017
Between:
1. Aluri Nageswara Rao, S/o late Surya Narayana, Occ: Retired APSRTC
Asst. Depot Clerk, R/o. Samatha Nagar, H.No. 136/7 Near Sailaja
Hospital, Kothapet, Nuzvid, Krishna Dist, Andhra Pradesh
...Petitioner
AND
1. The Union of India, Ministry of Labour and Employment,
Government of India, New Delhi
2. The Central Provident Fund Commissioner, HQ (Pension),
Bhavishya Nidhi Bhawan, 14, Bhikaiji Cama Place, New Delhi.
3. The Addl. Central Provident Fund Commissioner-cum-Regional PF
Commissioner, Office of the Addl. Central Provident Fund Commissioner
(Andhra Pradesh, Telangana and Orissa), 3-4-763, Bhavishyanidhi
Bhavan, Barkatpura Chaman, Hyderabad, Telangana State -500 027
4. The Vice Chairman and Managing Director of APSRTC, Vijayawada,
Krishna District, Andhra Pradesh
...Respondents
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying that in
the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court
may be pleased to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus to declare the inaction
of the respondents 3 to 4 to not consider the claim / representation dt.
02.12.2017 of the petitioner to enhance or refix his pension who retired
employee from the 4th respondent APSRTC and return is due pension
amounts from the respondents 2 and 3 EPF organization to his accounts
of the petitioner as illegal, arbitrary and unjust as well as violation of
Article 14, 19 and 21 of Indian Constitution as well as violation of Clause I
1(3) of Employees' pension scheme, 1995, and consequently direct the
respondents I to 4 to consider the claim / representation dt. 2.12.2017 of
the petitioner and return the due amount of pension amount to the
petitioner and to pass such other order or orders as this Hon'ble court
may deem fit and
IA NO: 1 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased
IA NO: 2 OF 2017
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may
be pleased to direct the respondents 1 to 4 to consider the claim /
representation dt.02.12.2017 of the petitioner and return the due amount
of pension amount to the petitioner and to pass such other •order or
orders as this Hon'ble court may deem fit and proper in
Counsel for the Petitioner: K J V N PUNDAREEKAKSHUDU
Counsel for the Respondents: T BALAJI(SC FOR EPFO)
Counsel for the Respondents: DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF
INDIA
Counsel for the Respondents: P DURGA PRASAD SC FOR APSRTC
The Court made the following order:
HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION No.45092 OF 2017
ORDER:
The instant writ petition has been filed by the petitioner under
Article 226 of Constitution of India seeking the following main prayer:
“to issue an appropriate writ, order or direction, more
particularly one in the nature of Writ of Mandamus to declare
the inaction of the respondents 3 to 4 to not consider the
claim / representation dt. 02.12.2017 of the petitioner to
enhance or refix his pension who retired employee from the
4th respondent APSRTC and return his due pension amounts
from the respondents 2 and 3 EPF organization to his
accounts as illegal, arbitrary and unjust as well as violation of
Article 14, 19 and 21 of Indian Constitution as well as
violation of Clause I 1(3) of Employees' pension scheme,
1995, and consequently direct the respondents I to 4 to
consider the claim / representation dt. 2.12.2017 of the
petitioner and return the due amount of pension amount to
the petitioner and to pass …..”
2.
The case of the petitioner is that he was appointed as
Assistant Deport Clerk in APSRTC on 20.07.1991. He worked in the
same post until 2012 and retired on 30.06.2012 while working at
Nuzvid Depot and at the time of retirement, the petitioner’s basic
salary is Rs.16,400/-. It is the further case of the petitioner that he
was a member of employees’ pension scheme, 1995 governed by
2nd respondent and the said scheme has been administered by the
3rd respondent.
The 4th respondent is the Vice Chairman and
Managing Director of APSRTC. Even prior to said employees
pension scheme, 1995 came into force, earlier there was a scheme
called as family pension scheme, 1971.
3.
It is further stated that as per the employees’ pension scheme,
1995, the petitioner has exercised an option under Section 26(6) of
the Act, as his basic salary is above Rs.6,500/- p.m. Thereafter, the
contribution to the provident fund being 12% of the total salary
deducted as employees contribution and 12% paid by the employer
were remitted to employees’ provident fund organization, who is 1st
respondent herein. As per the provisions of the pension scheme
8.33% of the contribution from the employer is to be deducted and
credited to the pension fund.
However, without making such
deduction, provident fund organization limited it to 8.33% of the
maximum salary provided, i.e. Rs.6,500/-, the balance contribution
made by the employer for the salary is excess of Rs.6,500/- and the
same was fully retained in provident fund account itself.
4.
It is the further case of the petitioner that he is entitled to refix
or enhance the present pension under Rule 12(4) r/w Rule 10(2) of
the employees’ pension scheme, 1995 and also entitled to two years
weightage pension of Rs.1,529/- as he completed 20 years service,
i.e. 14 years prior to 1995 and further service upto his retirement
date 30.06.2012 being actual service as per the employees’ pension
scheme, 1995. It is also stated that under the 1952 Act, 10% or
12% of the basic wages including dearness allowance etc. is
required to be deposited in the provident fund account of the
employee.
Sub-section 6(A) of the Act framed for payment of
pension to the retired employees. The pension scheme deals with
the determination of pensionable salary under clause 11(3) of the
pension scheme, the maximum pension was limited to Rs.5,000/-,
which was subsequently enhanced to Rs.6,500/- w.e.f. 08.10.2001,
As per the Act, the employers contribution has to be on the basis of
actual salary but not on the basis of ceiling limit of either Rs.5,000/or Rs.6,500/- per month.
5.
It is also stated that the petitioner made several requests to
the respondents to enhance or refix his present pension and remit
his remaining pension amount to his account, which is kept with
Respondents 2 and 3. Now, the petitioner has been paying 12%
contribution on the ceiling amount of Rs.5000/- or Rs.6,500/- but, the
same has to be determined for 12% on the exact salary of the
retired employee, which was deducted and remitted to the
employees’ provident fund organization, i.e. respondents 2 and 3.
Hence, the respondents 2 and 3 are liable to return the due amount
of pension and remit the same to his account.
6.
It is further stated by the petitioner that he being the retired
employee is entitled to get pension basing on his salary, which
exceeds the ceiling amount of Rs.5000/- or Rs.6,500/- and in the
same set of facts, the Hon’ble Kerala High Court in W.P.(C) No.8854
of 2014 passed orders against the respondents 2 and 3 and
aggrieved by the same, the respondents 2 and 3 filed W.A.No.1362
of 2014. The said Writ Appeal was allowed in favour of respondents
2 and 3, thereafter, the retired employees filed S.L.P.No.19954 of
2015 before the Hon’ble Apex Court and the same was ordered in
favour of retired employees.
No.1774
of
filed
Another Special Leave Petition (C)
by
the
Regional
Commissioner was rejected by the Apex Court.
Provident
Fund
7.
The petitioner further states that he was retired from service
after completion of 20 years and hence, he is entitled to weight age
of 2 years. The petitioner made a representation dated 02.12.2017
to respondents 2 to 4 requesting them to refix his present pension
and refund the arrears of pension amount into his accounts. But the
respondents 2 to 4 did not respond to him, hence, having no other
go, the petitioner approached this Court by way of the present writ
petition.
8.
Respondent Nos.2 and 3 have filed a counter affidavit jointly,
denying the case of the petitioner and they have reiterated the list of
events that took place and requested to dismiss the writ petition.
The 4th respondent also filed counter affidavit separately.
9.
Heard
learned
counsel
for
the
petitioner,
Mr.
K.J.V.N.Pundareekakshudu, learned Standing Counsel for APSRTC
Sri Aravala Rama Rao and Sri. T. Balaji, learned Standing Counsel
for Employees Provident Fund Organization of India.
10.
During the course of arguments, learned counsel for the
petitioner, while reiterating the facts narrated in the writ petition has
raised several contentions. He further submits that the respondents
authorities have deducted the amounts from the pay of the petitioner
and credited the same to respondent Nos.2 and 3 through
respondent No.4, the respondent Nos.2 and 3 have to consider the
case of the petitioner and ought not to have rejected the claim of the
petitioner by just stating that there is a financial burden on the
Department. The said reason stated by the respondents is not
sustainable and such a stand should not have been taken after
lapse of so many years from the date of payment of the amounts i.e.
from the year 2012. The action of the respondents has resulted in
an irreparable loss to the petitioner herein and also other APSRTC
employees.
11.
While concluding his arguments, learned counsel has
requested this Court to direct the respondents to continue the higher
option scheme under Paragraph No.11(3) of Employee’s Pension
Scheme, 1995 and grant additional financial benefits to the
petitioner under the said scheme.
12.
Conversely, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the
Employees Provident Fund Organization (EPFO), while denying the
contention raised by learned counsel for the petitioner that the
petitioner is entitled to be continued the higher option scheme under
Paragraph No.11(3) of Employee’s Pension Scheme, 1995 has
referred to a judgment in R.C. Gupta and Ors. Vs. Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees' Provident Fund
Organisation and Ors1.
13.
He further submits that in the aforesaid judgment, the Hon’ble
Apex Court while dealing with the question of entitlement of
members of the pension schemes, whose pensionable salary
exceeded Rs.6,500/- per month, who exercise option in terms of the
proviso under paragraph 11(3) of the Employee’s Pension Scheme,
1995; held as under:
“7. Reading the proviso, we find that the reference to the
date of commencement of the Scheme or the date on which the
salary exceeds the ceiling limit are dates from which the option
exercised are to be reckoned with for calculation of pensionable
salary. The said dates are not cut-off dates to determine the eligibility
of the employer employee to indicate their option under the proviso to
Clause 11(3) of the Pension Scheme. A somewhat similar view that
has been taken by this Court in a matter coming from the Kerala High
Court, wherein the Special Leave Petition (C) No. 7074 of 2014 filed
by the Regional Provident Fund Commissioner was rejected by this
Court by order dated 31.3.2016. A beneficial Scheme, in our
considered view, ought not to be allowed to be defeated by reference
to a cut-off date, particularly, in a situation where (as in the present
case) the employer had deposited 12% of the actual salary and not
(2018) 14 SCC 809
12% of the ceiling limit of ' 5,000/- or ' 6,500/- per month, as the case
may be.
8. XXX XXX XXX
9. We do not see how exercise of option under paragraph 26 of the
Provident Fund Scheme can be construed to estop the employees
from exercising a similar option under paragraph 11(3). If both the
employer and the employee opt for deposit against the actual salary
and not the ceiling amount, exercise of option under paragraph 26 of
the Provident Scheme is inevitable. Exercise of the option under
paragraph 26(6) is a necessary precursor to the exercise of option
under Clause 11(3). Exercise of such option, therefore, would not
foreclose the exercise of a further option under Clause 11(3) of the
Pension
Scheme
unless
the
circumstances warranting such
foreclosure are clearly indicated.
10. The above apart in a situation where the deposit of the
employer's share at 12% has been on the actual salary and not the
ceiling
amount,
we
do
not
see
how
the
Provident
Fund
Commissioner could have been aggrieved to file the L.P.A. before
the Division Bench of the High Court. All that the Provident Fund
Commissioner is required to do in the case is an adjustment of
accounts which in turn would have benefited some of the employees.
At best what the Provident Commissioner could do and which we
permit him to do under the present order is to seek a return of all
such amounts that the concerned employees may have taken or
withdrawn from their Provident Fund Account before granting them
the benefit of the proviso to Clause 11(3) of the Pension Scheme.
Once such a return is made in whichever cases such return is due,
consequential benefits in terms of this order will be granted to the
said employees.”
14.
He further submitted that, in compliance to the orders issued
by the Hon’ble Apex Court in R.C. Gupta and Ors. Vs. Regional
Provident Fund Commissioner, Employees' Provident Fund
Organisation and Ors [referred supra], has passed a judgment in
The Employees Provident Fund Organisation and Ors. Vs. Sunil
Kumar B. and Ors. 2 , wherein he draw attention of this Court at
paragraph No.44 as follows:
“44. We accordingly hold and direct:
(i)
The provisions contained in the notification No. G.S.R.
609(E) : MANU/LABR/0034/2014 dated 22nd August 2014 are
legal and valid. So far as present members of the fund are
concerned, we have read down certain provisions of the scheme
as applicable in their cases and we shall give our findings and
directions on these provisions in the subsequent sub-paragraphs.
(ii)
Amendment to the pension scheme brought about by the
notification No. G.S.R. 609(E) : MANU/LABR/0034/2014 dated
22nd August 2014 shall apply to the employees of the exempted
establishments in the same manner as the employees of the
regular establishments. Transfer of funds from the exempted
establishments shall be in the manner as we have already
directed.
(iii)
The employees who had exercised option under the
proviso to paragraph 11(3) of the 1995 scheme and continued to
be in service as on 1st September 2014, will be guided by the
amended provisions of paragraph 11(4) of the pension scheme.
AIR 2022 SC 5634
(iv)
The members of the scheme, who did not exercise option,
as contemplated in the proviso to paragraph 11(3) of the pension
scheme (as it was before the 2014 Amendment) would be entitled
to exercise option under paragraph 11(4) of the post amendment
scheme. Their right to exercise option before 1st September 2014
stands crystalised in the judgment of this Court in the case of R.C.
Gupta (supra). The scheme as it stood before 1st September 2014
did not provide for any cutoff date and thus those members shall
be entitled to exercise option in terms of paragraph 11(4) of the
scheme, as it stands at present. Their exercise of option shall be in
the nature of joint options covering pre-amended paragraph 11(3)
as also the amended paragraph 11(4) of the pension scheme.
There was uncertainty as regards validity of the post amendment
scheme, which was quashed by the aforesaid judgments of the
three High Courts. Thus, all the employees who did not exercise
option but were entitled to do so but could not due to the
interpretation on cut-off date by the authorities, ought to be given a
further chance to exercise their option. Time to exercise option
under paragraph 11(4) of the scheme, under these circumstances,
shall stand extended by a further period of four months. We are
giving this direction in exercise of our jurisdiction Under Article 142
of the Constitution of India. Rest of the requirements as per the
amended provision shall be complied with.
(v)
The employees who had retired prior to 1st September
2014 without exercising any option under paragraph 11(3) of the
pre-amendment scheme have already exited from the membership
thereof. They would not be entitled to the benefit of this judgment.
(vi)
The employees who have retired before 1st September
2014 upon exercising option under paragraph 11(3) of the 1995
scheme shall be covered by the provisions of the paragraph 11(3)
of the pension scheme as it stood prior to the amendment of 2014.
(vii)
The requirement of the members to contribute at the rate
of 1.16 per cent of their salary to the extent such salary exceeds
Rs. 15000/- per month as an additional contribution under the
amended scheme is held to be ultra vires the provisions of the
1952 Act. But for the reasons already explained above, we
suspend operation of this part of our order for a period of six
months. We do so to enable the authorities to make adjustments in
the scheme so that the additional contribution can be generated
from some other legitimate source within the scope of the Act,
which could include enhancing the rate of contribution of the
employers. We are not speculating on what steps the authorities
will take as it would be for the legislature or the framers of the
scheme to make necessary amendment. For the aforesaid period
of six months or till such time any amendment is made, whichever
is earlier, the employees' contribution shall be as stop gap
measure. The said sum shall be adjustable on the basis of
alteration to the scheme that may be made.
(viii)
We do not find any flaw in altering the basis for
computation of pensionable salary.
(ix)
We agree with the view taken by the Division Bench in the
case of R.C. Gupta (supra) so far as interpretation of the proviso to
paragraph 11(3) (pre-amendment) pension scheme is concerned.
The fund authorities shall implement the directives contained in the
said judgment within a period of eight weeks, subject to our
directions contained earlier in this paragraph.
(x)
The Contempt Petition (C) Nos. 1917-1918 of 2018 and
Contempt Petition (C) Nos. 619-620 of 2019 in Civil Appeal Nos.
10013-10014 of 2016 are disposed of in the above terms.”
15.
After hearing both sides and after perusing the various
material provided by both the learned counsel for the petitioners and
learned
Standing
Counsel
for
Employees
Provident
Fund
Organization, this Court has come to a conclusion that the Hon'ble
Apex Court in The Employees Provident Fund Organisation and
Ors. Vs. Sunil Kumar B. and Ors., after considering the reasons
given by the EPFO for issuance of their circular dated 31.05.2017
and after detailed discussion, has issued guidelines to be followed
by the EPFO regarding the grant of pension as per their actual
salary paid by the employees as pension.
16.
In view of the above, and also as submitted by the learned
counsel for the petitioner as well as learned counsel for the
respondents that this Court already passed a
detailed order in
W.P.No.30608 of 2015 and batch, the instant writ petition is also
liable to be disposed of in similar lines.
17.
Accordingly, following the directions issued in paragraph
No.44 of the judgment of the Hon’ble Apex Court in The Employees
Provident Fund Organisation and Ors. Vs. Sunil Kumar B. and
Ors., as detailed in preceding paragraph No.14, the present writ
petition is disposed of.
There shall be no order as to costs. Miscellaneous petitions
pending if any, shall stand closed.
______________________________
MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM, J
Date:12.02.2026
Rns
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM
WRIT PETITION No.45092 of 2017
Date: 12.02.2026
Rns
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review