Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.05
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WA No.16/2019
Date of Order: 29.11.2021
A. Murali Krishna
Coram:
Vs.
Union of India & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. D Bhattacharjee, Adv with
Mr.S Thapa, Adv
: Mr. N Mozika, ASG with
Ms. T Sutnga, Adv
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
1.
This appeal is utterly baseless and a complete waste of time by a
recalcitrant erstwhile Border Security Force (BSF) employee. What is
worse is the attempt on the appellant‟s part to mislead the court.
2.
The appellant has been dismissed from service after being found
guilty on all four charges levelled against him. The writ petition was made
out in such a manner that the papers pertaining to the first set of charges
were appended to the writ petition, but the other papers were not. The
impression that was sought to be given in the writ petition was that the writ
petitioner admitted his guilt in respect of the two minor charges but there
may not have been adjudication on the two major charges.
3.
However, what is undeniable is that upon the writ petitioner being
found guilty on admission on all four charges and being dismissed from
service, he preferred a departmental appeal which was dealt with by an
order dated May 11, 2017. A copy of the order is appended to the writ
petition. Paragraph 2 of the appellate order, in so far as it summarizes the
facts, is set out:
“2. The brief facts of the case are that Ex-Ct A Murli Krishna 123
Bn BSF, the petitioner was tried by a SSFC on two charge sheets
containing 02 charges each. The trial proceeded first on the 1 st
charge sheet containing two charges u/s 40 and 26 of the BSF Act,
1968 for an act prejudicial to good order and discipline of the
force and intoxication respectively. The particulars of the 1 st
charge sheet averred that he, on 21.02.2016, at about 2030 hrs
visited and entered the house of local female villager namely
Romola r/o Village – Ryngku and demanded the liquor. The
particulars of the 2nd charge are that he, at BOP Ryngku on
21.02.2016 at about 2030 hrs was found in a state of intoxication.
On being arraigned by the Court, petitioner pleaded „Guilty‟ to
both the charges. Thereafter, the Court complied with the
provisions of BSF Rule 142(2) wherein he was explained the
nature of charges, general effect of his plea of „Guilty‟ and
difference in procedure to be followed consequent to said plea.
After having fully satisfied that the petitioner had understood the
same and there was no need for the petitioner to withdraw his
plea, the Court accepted his plea and recorded findings of „Guilty‟
on both charges on 1st charge sheet. Thereafter, the trial proceeded
on the 2nd charge sheet containing 02 charges u/s 21(1) and 20(c)
of BSF Act for disobeying in such a manner as to show a willful
defiance of authority a lawful command given personally by his
superior officer in the execution of his office and using
insubordinate language to his superior officer respectively. The
particulars of the 1st charge averred that he, at BOP Ryngku on
22.02.2016 at about 1000 hrs when ordered by No.859110718
ASI/GD (CASIM) K K Nayak to appear before Coy Comdr as
directed by him, refused to do so stating “MURALI KISI SE
NAHI MILTA HAI JO KARNA HAI KAR LO” and did not
appear before the Coy Comdr.. The particulars of the 2 nd charge
are that he at BOP Ryngku of 123 Bn BSF on 21.02.2016 used
abusing language to No.859110718 ASI/GD (CASIM) K K
Nayak of the same unit by saying “BAHANCHOD MAI YAHI
PAR HUN KAUN BOLA AAPKO” or words to that effect. On
being arraigned by the Court, petitioner pleaded „Guilty‟ to both
the charges. Thereafter, the Court complied with the provisions of
BSF Rule 142(2) wherein he was explained the nature of charges,
general effect of his plea of „Guilty‟ and difference in procedure
to be followed consequent to said plea. After having fully satisfied
that the petitioner had understood the same and there was no need
for the petitioner to withdraw his plea, the Court accepted his plea
and recorded findings of „Guilty‟ on both the charges on 2 nd
charge sheet also. The Court also recorded his previous
convictions, character and reward etc. and sentenced him “to be
dismissed from service” on 01.04.2016. The trial proceedings
were countersigned by the DIG, SHQ BSF, Jowai on 07.10.2016.”
4.
It is evident from the above quoted paragraph that the writ
petitioner pleaded guilty both to the two counts of charge in the first
charge-sheet and to the further two counts of charge in the second chargesheet. The first charge-sheet pertained to the writ petitioner demanding
liquor from a village woman and, later in the day, being found in an
intoxicated state. There is no dispute, as would be evident from the papers
appended to the writ petition, that the writ petitioner pleaded guilty to such
charges.
5.
What is further evident from the paragraph quoted above is that
the writ petitioner also admitted his guilt in respect of the two charges in the
second charge-sheet which were far more serious upon the writ petitioner
having disobeyed a command to meet the Company Commander and the
writ petitioner using abusive and intemperate language in connection
therewith.
6.
The writ petitioner has relied on the appellate order without the
slightness of reservation expressed in the writ petition to the effect that the
facts as recorded in the appellate order are contrary to record. Indeed, if the
facts as recorded in the second paragraph of the appellate order were
contrary to record, it was incumbent on the writ petitioner to produce the
record, copies whereof are obviously in his possession, to demonstrate that
the writ petitioner had merely pleaded guilty to the first set of charges and
other set of charges were not considered at all.
7.
As it happens, the entire effort on the part of the writ petitioner‟s
case was to emphasize on the apparently unconscionable punishment meted
out to the writ petitioner following the discovery of the writ petitioner being
intoxicated upon having obtained liquor from some village women. The
attempt by the writ petitioner was to demonstrate that despite the writ
petitioner accepting his guilt and expecting a lenient treatment, the writ
petitioner was handed out the ultimate punishment of dismissal from
service.
8.
The writ petitioner deliberately glossed over the greater counts of
default in the second charge-sheet which pertained to the writ petitioner
refusing to meet the Company Commander despite being informed that he
had been summoned and of the writ petitioner using abusive language in
connection therewith. As the second set of charges stood proved upon the
writ petitioner‟s admission, as duly recorded in the second paragraph of the
appellate order, there can be no grievance on the writ petitioner‟s part that
he had been dealt with harshly in course of the trial by the Summary
Security Force Court.
9.
At the end of the day, the writ petitioner belonged to a disciplined
force. The previous record of the writ petitioner showed that he had been
imprisoned on at least three occasions, though for short tenures. The writ
petitioner had refused to respond to the call of his Company Commander
and had used intemperate language in course of such refusal. In the light of
the writ petitioner‟s conduct, the Summary Security Force Court was well
within its rights to award the maximum punishment. The appellate authority
applied its independent mind to the matters in issue and, upon examining
the case, found that there was no ground for interference with the order of
dismissal.
10.
In the limited scope of judicial review exercised in respect of
matters of the present kind, the court cannot supplant its discretion in place
of that which has been exercised by the disciplinary authority unless the
exercise of the discretion is found to be perverse. Indeed, the court, in such
a scenario, looks into the decision-making process rather that the decision
itself. Of course, if the punishment appears to be grossly disproportionate to
the acts complained of or if it shocks the conscience of the court, the court
may interfere with the punishment awarded.
11.
In the present case, a member of a disciplined force was found to
be intoxicated and such member was also found on another occasion to
have directly refused to obey a command by his Company Commander and
used abusive language in course of such refusal. If the superiors within the
disciplined force found that it was imperative that such indiscipline be dealt
with in the harshest manner, it does not shock the conscience of the court
for the court to step in and interfere with the punishment.
12.
At any rate, the entire conspectus was duly considered by the
Single Bench while dealing with the matter and appropriate reasons have
been furnished as to why no interference was called for.
13.
For the writ petitioner‟s misadventure and attempt at misleading
the court, the writ petitioner will pay costs assessed at Rs.5,000/-.
14.
WA No.16 of 2019 is dismissed without interfering with the
judgment and order impugned dated May, 20, 2019.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
29.11.2021
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review