The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
30. 11.2001 is brought, that will not have any relevance either to prove the case of the prosecution or the defence. I refrain from making any further observations in the above regard for avoiding a possible prejudice to the interest of the petitioner. I accordingly find that a report of the handwriting expert as sought by the petitioner is an irrelevant item of evidence and hence the impugned order does not require any interference. This petition is dismissed. Sd/- P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE dkr 2025:KER:30115 Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025 Annexure -I NO 25/2011 ON THE FILE OF COURT OF THE ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE, Annexure II A TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION OF PW1 IN CC NO 25/2011 ON THE FILE OF COURT OF THE ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE, THRISSUR Annexure III
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:KER:30115
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE P.G. AJITHKUMAR
MONDAY, THE 7TH DAY OF APRIL 2025 / 17TH CHAITHRA, 1947
CRL.M.C. NO. 2784 OF 2025
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 14.03.2025 IN CRLMP 348 OF 2025
IN CC NO.25 OF 2011 OF THE ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER AND
SPECIAL JUDGE (VIGILANCE), THRISSUR
CRIME NO.VC 6/2008 OF VACB, PALAKKAD
PETITIONER/ACCUSED:
A C JAILAVUDHEEN
AGED 76 YEARS
S/O A C KANNI RAWUTHER, MANCHIRA HOUSE ANAMARI
POST, KOLLENGODE, CHITTUR TALUK PALAKKAD, PIN –
678506.
BY ADVS.
S.RAJEEV
V.VINAY
M.S.ANEER
SARATH K.P.
ANILKUMAR C.R.
K.S.KIRAN KRISHNAN
DIPA V.
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
RESPONDENT/STATE:
STATE OF KERALA
REPRESENTED BY PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,HIGH COURT OF
KERALA, PIN – 682031.
SMT REKHA S, SR PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
SRI A RAJESH, SPL PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (VIG)
THIS CRIMINAL MISC. CASE HAVING COME UP FOR FINAL
HEARING ON 01.04.2025, THE COURT ON 07.04.2025 PASSED THE
FOLLOWING:
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, J.
----------------------------------------------------------Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
----------------------------------------------------------Dated this the 7th day of April, 2025
ORDER
The petitioner is the accused in C.C.No.25 of 2011 pending
before the Court of Enquiry Commissioner and Special Judge,
Thrissur. He filed Crl.M.P.No.348 of 2025 under Section 243(2) of
the Code of Criminal procedure, 1973 (Code). He wants entries
for the period from 01.09.2001 to 30.11.2001 in Ext.P9 cash
book to be examined by a handwriting expert for obtaining his
opinion as to whether the entries therein except Ext.P9(a) are in
the handwriting of the petitioner. The Special Court dismissed
that petition as per the order dated 14.03.2025. That order is
under challenge in this Crl.M.C. filed under Section 528 of the
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS).
2.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and
the learned Senior Public Prosecutor.
3.
From a copy of the case status of C.C.No.25 of
2011, which was handed over for my perusal, it is seen that
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
the evidence on the side of the prosecution was over and the
petitioner was questioned as provided under Section 313(1)
(b) of the Code. Prosecution witness No.1 was seen recalled
and examined further before such questioning. The turn of
defence evidence came and then the petitioner has filed
Crl.M.P.No.348 of 2025. The case of the petitioner is that he
did not make any entry for the period from 01.09.2001 till
30.11.2001
in Ext.P9, except Ext.P9(a) which
is
only
“handed over charge with cash balance of Rs.1,52,267.30”.
However,
PW1
during
further
re-cross-examination
on
19.02.2025, deposed that there were a few entries by the
petitioner during the period from 01.09.2001 in Ext.P9 cash
book. The petitioner would contend that in order to establish
his case that he did not make any entry in Ext.P9 ever
after 01.09.2001, a report from a handwriting expert
regarding authorship of such entries in Ext.P9 is very much
essential.
4.
The Special Court took the view that in the nature
of the charge levelled against the petitioner, a report of the
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
handwriting expert as sought by him is quite irrelevant. The
charge against the petitioner is that he obtained 200 bags of
cattle feed from the Cattle Feed Factory of Milma at
Malampuzha on 29.11.2001, which was intended to be
distributed among members of the Muthalamada West Milk
Marketing Co-operative Society, and instead of doing so, he
sold
the
same
to
a
third
person
and
thereby
he
misappropriated its cost of Rs.68,000/-.
5.
According to the learned counsel for the petitioner,
the Special Court went totally wrong in holding that the
petitioner was estopped by waiver from calling for report of a
handwriting expert, inferably, since he did not raise a similar
contention before the arbitration court where the same
question was considered. Also, it is submitted that the Special
Court took a wrong view that the handwriting or signature in
Ext.P9 did not have any relevance and the petitioner failed to
convince the court about the necessity to obtain such a report
in compliance to the provisions of Section 136 of the Indian
Evidence Act, 1872.
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
6.
The arbitration court might have passed an award
against the petitioner in relation to the misappropriation alleged
in this case. The findings in the said award or the defence set up
by the petitioner in that proceedings cannot control or regulate
the proceedings in the criminal prosecution. Whether or not the
petitioner raised a contention concerning the handwriting in
Ext.P9, he can certainly raise such a contention before the
Special Court and provisions of Section 243(2) of the Code
entitles the petitioner, who is the accused, to call for whatever
evidence he deems appropriate to prove his defence, subject to
relevance. The Apex Court in T.Nagappa v Y.R.Muralidhar
[(2008) 5 SCC 633] held in this regard as follows:
“9.
What should be the nature of evidence is not a matter
which should be left only to the discretion of the Court. It is
the accused who knows how to prove his defence. It is true
that the court being the master of the proceedings must
determine as to whether the application filed by the accused
in terms of sub-section (2) of Section 243 of the Code is bona
fide or not or whether thereby he intends to bring on record a
relevant material. But ordinarily an accused should be allowed
to approach the court for obtaining its assistance with regard
to summoning of witnesses etc. If permitted to do so, steps
therefor, however, must be taken within a limited time. There
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
cannot be any doubt whatsoever that the accused should not
be allowed to unnecessarily protract the trial or summon
witnesses whose evidence would not be at all relevant.”
7.
This court in Issac Thomas v. State of Kerala
[2010 (3) KLT 56] held that right to adduce evidence is a
very valuable right and it is part of fair trial. Such a right shall
not be actually denied. The view taken by this Court in
Mohammed Ashraf v. State of Kerala [2019 (2) KHC
792] in the above respect is that the limited function of the
court in the arena of defence evidence is only to ascertain
whether the evidence sought to be adduced by the accused is
in respect of the relevant fact. If the evidence proposed by
the defence is concerning a relevant fact it is the obligation of
the court to afford an opportunity to adduce that evidence.
8.
In the view of the above, the consideration is only
whether the report of a handwriting expert concerning
authorship of various entries for the period from 01.09.2001
to 30.11.2001 in Ext.P9 is a relevant evidence. The function
of the trial judge in the light of Section 136 of the Evidence
Act is also not different.
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
9.
PW1, who succeeded the petitioner as Secretary of
the Co-operative Society, proved Ext.P9. He deposed about
various entries in it. Ext.P9(a) is the entry concerning handing
over of charge by the petitioner. He does not deny authorship
of Ext.P9(a). I have gone through the entire deposition of
PW1. No question suggesting that none of the entries in
Ext.P9 during the period from 01.09.2001 to 30.11.2001 was
made by the petitioner has been put to him during the crossexamination. Only statement he has made in relation to the
entries in Ext.P9 after 01.09.2001 is the following statement
during further re-cross-examination:
“01-09-2001 മമുതൽ കകക്യാഷഷ ബമുകക്കിൽ ജയക്കിലക്യാവമുദദീനഷനന
കമുനചമു എൻടടക്കി ഉണഷ.”
10.
The said assertion by PW1 brought out at the
instance of the petitioner. The said statement, first of all, is a
general statement, which may take in even Ext.P9(a). The
petitioner did not choose to deny the said assertion of PW1,
nor he asked questions with reference to any specific entry
after 01.09.2001 in Ext.P9. In the said circumstances, even if
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
an opinion of a handwriting expert concerning the authorship
of the writings in Ext.P9 during the period from 01.09.2001 to
30.11.2001 is brought, that will not have any relevance either
to prove the case of the prosecution or the defence. I refrain
from making any further observations in the above regard for
avoiding a possible prejudice to the interest of the petitioner. I
accordingly find that a report of the handwriting expert as
sought by the petitioner is an irrelevant item of evidence and
hence the impugned order does not require any interference.
This petition is dismissed.
Sd/-
P.G. AJITHKUMAR, JUDGE
dkr
2025:KER:30115
Crl.M.C.No.2784 of 2025
APPENDIX OF CRL.MC 2784/2025
PETITIONER ANNEXURES
Annexure -I
A TRUE COPY OF THE COURT CHARGE IN CC
NO 25/2011 ON THE FILE OF COURT OF THE
ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE,
THRISSUR
Annexure II
A TRUE COPY OF THE DEPOSITION OF PW1
IN CC NO 25/2011 ON THE FILE OF COURT
OF THE ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL
JUDGE, THRISSUR
Annexure III
A CERTIFIED COPY OF THE ORDER DATED
14.03.2025 IN CRL MP NO 348/2025 IN CC
NO 25/2025 ON THE FILE OF COURT OF THE
ENQUIRY COMMISSIONER & SPECIAL JUDGE,
THRISSUR
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review