Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3301 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
WRIT PETITION NO: 29260 OF 2024
Betwee n:
A.Anil Kumar, S/o. A.Guruvarah, Aged about 39 years, Occ ; Private Service, R/o.
H.No.B-1-19/5, Flat No.201, Raghavendra Nagar, Karmanghat, Ranga Reddy
District, Hall Ticket No 1767008289
.....PETITIONER
AND
'1
. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary to Gov4 tt4edical,
Health and Family Welfare Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad 5OO 022.
2. The Director of [r,4edical Education, Government of Telangana, Koti,
Hyderabad - 500 001.
3. The Telangana Public Service Commission (TGPSC), Nampally, Hyderabad 500 001 Rep. by its Secretary.
.....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 of lfie Constitution of India prayrng that in the
circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be
pleased to issue a Writ, order or direction, more particularly one in lhe nature of a
Writ of Mandamus declaring the impugned Memo No. 4671 RP- 1112017 daled
09.1O.2024 as arbitrary and illegal and set aside the sank and consequently direct
the Respondents to award five weightage marks for the contract service of
petitioner from July, 2015 to June, 2O17 as Lab Technician at Osmania Medical
College, Hyderabad and direct the respondents to consider his case for selection
and appointment to the post of Lab Technician Grade-ll pursuant to the
Notification No.6712017, daled 18.12.2017 of the third respondent.
LA.NO:1 OF 2024
Petltion Under Sectron 151 CPC praying that in ther cr lumstances stated rn
the affrdavit filed in support of the petition, the High Cor r may be pleased to
suspend impugned lt"4emo No 4671 RP- 1112017 dated 09. 1 ) 2024 and direct the
respondents to award five werghtage marks and based on lrr ; merit appoint him to
the post of Lab Technrcian Grade-ll forthwith pursua I to the Notificatron
No.67/2017, dated 18.12.2017, pending drsposal of the abo u r writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI SARASANI SATHYAM REf Dy, SENIOR
COUNSEL SRI SARASANI RAHUL REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1 & 2 : GP FOR SERVIC: j- |
Counsel for the Respondent No.3 : SRI P.S.RAJASEKHAR
The Court made the following ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE PULLA KARTHIK
1VRIT PETITION No.29260 of 2024
Dated 9th January, 2026
BETWEEN:
A. Anil Kurnar
Pe ti
tioner
.AND
The State of Telangana,
Rep. bv its Principal Secretary,
Mcdical. Health :rnd Familr. Welfarc Dcpzirtment,
Sccrctariat, Hyderabad, and two othcrs.
Respondents
ORDER:
This Writ Petition, uncler Article 226 of the Constitution o[
India, is liled sceking thc follorving relief
-...to lssuc a \\;rit, order or drrection. more particularly one
in the natLrlc of a Writ of Marldarnus declaring thc impugned
Ivleno No: 467/ RP IIil2O17 dared 09.1O.2O24 as arbitrary and
illcgal and set asidc the sanre ?u1d consequentil direct the
Respondents to award hve rveightage mar-ks for the contract
sen,ice of Petitioner from Juh', 2015 to June, 2017 as Lab
Technician .rt Osmania Medical Collcge, Hr derabad and direct the
respondents to consider his case for selcction and appointment to
thc post of Lab Tecltnicran Gra(ie II p\lrsuant to the Notification
No67 /2017, dated 18 l2.2Ol7 ol thc third rcspondent and
pass. . . "
2.
Heard Sri Sarasani Sathyam Rcddy, learned Senior Counscl,
representing Sri Sarasani Rahul Reddy, lcarned counsel for the
\
?K, .I
i).iio .)9260 o1 2024
petitioner, learnecl Govcrnment l)le:rder [or Sen,ic.:.. , appcaring on
behall of rcsp.ndent Nos. 1 a.d 2, rrnd Sri Ir.S. R:r j,i ,t:khzrr, lc:r,ted
Standing Counsel appearing for rcspondent No.3.
3.
Learned Senior Counsel for rhe petitioncr s .lr.r-rits that tl,e
petitioner, bclonging to Schedulcd Caste conu unitr,, havir.rg
posscsscd thrr qualiticittion o[ B.Sc. (\ll,T), ear-)i,. uorkcd :is ir
contract e mplovec in Osmania Nledical Collcge, H,r rl,. . lrrrd. fronr ,lulr.,
2015. As srtch, in pursuance ol Notification i\Jr, -r7,,rt11 17 O^,..,
la.]r2.2O17, issucd lt1, responclent No.3, the pctition, lLpPlied lor the
post of Lab Tcchnician Grade-ll, appeared and suc:i r ssfullr. qtralihed
in the written examination and was thus callcd for ,,r.ificarion o[ his
certificates on 08.08.2O23. It is submitted I .rt ils per the
Noiification, out of rhe total (1OO) points, a maxinrrr n o1- (70) points
were [o be arn,arded lor written examination, s,hit, (30) poir-rts lor
experience. Therefore, since the petitioner had earlir: worked as Lab
Technician on contract basis from Julv, 2015. to. .nc,2017, he is
fully entitled for award of service weightage poinrs. Iorvevcr, he was
not awarded the said points, due to u,hich, his sclt'r r on had affected.
As such, the pctitioner was constrained to file W.[:,. \.). ),9077 ol ,2024
before this Court, which was disposed ol vidc ordcr ,l rr,cd 19.07.2024.
permitting the petitioner to make a rcprcsentation n, :l thc authorities
PK, J
tv. P. No.29260
of 2024
were directed Lo consider the same and pass appropriate orders ir-r
accordar-rcc rvith lau
4.
It is further submitted that in compliance u,ith the said order ol
this Court, the pctitioner subr.rritted his representation to the
respondents on 2O.O7.2024, and his requcst for au'arding service
weightage points was illegally ar.rd arbitrarilv rcjectcd by respondent
No.3 vide impugned Memo datcd 09.1O.2024, holding that the
petitioncr had or-r11, u,orked as an outsourcing employce, u,hich is
factually incorrect, as tl-rc petitioncr's carlicr appointmcnt order dated
2I.O5.2025 categoricallY mentioned thal he rvas appointed as a
contract employee. [t is also submitted that the Principal, Osmania
Medical CoIIege, Hyderabad, issued an expericncc certil-rcate dated
30.O9.2024, which also goes to sho$, lhat the petitioncr had rendered
his services as a contractual emplol.ee since 2O15. As such, the
petitioner is fully etigible and cntitled lor awarding the service
weightage points for his contractu:rl service. Therefore, learned
Senior Counsel seeks indulgence o[ this Court to issue necessary'
directions to the respondenls for awarding the service weightage
points to the petitioner for his services during July, 2O 15 and June,
2017.
PIi,,l
V I'.Nc 29260 of 2021
5.
on thc orhe r ha11d, lea.ncd clol,ernrrrc'rt pl'rr l rr irl)llearirlg rbr
respondent N,ts. 1 :rr-rd 2 submrrs that Lhe petitiorr,; tacl prodrrcccl a
certilicatc issucd by the principal, C)smani;r ) cciii:al Oollcqc,
H1'clerabad, dated 16.O7 .2Olg, during the cer ril, :1t(. rcrilication
process, but it is nou'here mentioned thercin thal I I 3 p€,titioncr hacl
worked as Lab Technician on contract basis. Furtl ,r, (llc pelitioncr
had also failed to furnish within the stipulat.ci ti,., tl.te coyrir:s of
rclcv:u1t docuttr:nts, including his appointrn(.n1 ()r ( (,r. i Icn(.c, the
Committce has awardcd zero u'eightagc points t() t. ., p(litiun(.r : tcl
furnished thc same to respondent No.3. It is lurt ., . . su bmitted rhat
after lrling of rhe present writ petition, the relevan( r. .rds u,cre cal]cd
for and the Principal, Osmania Medical College, H].,1: :rbarl, \.idc lerrer
daled 16.I1.2O24, stated that the petitioner $.as I )poinre(i as l,ab
Technician Grade-II on a consolidated payment ot F s. 1g.360,r - for a
period of one year, from 06.07.2015, which was exl( r rlcd lor a furthcr
period of one )rear, until 05.09.2017, and he rende,r: I his contr:rctual
services at i\4DRU Lab under centrallv_ spor r s, r cd schentc bv
ICMR/DHRU Funds. However, the petitioner,s apI ( irlrntenl \r,as noL
made by a competent authority, i.e., District Sr.lc :tioI Committee
headed by the District Medical and Hcalth Officcr, I )istrict Collecror,
as was done in the cases of other contractual t.r: tlovccs, ancl his
PR, J
w P. No.29260 oJ 2A24
consolidated pay \(ras also drarr.-r'r from celt trally- spon sored scheme
funds and not from thc Sratc Goyeflrmenl iunds/ budget. As such,
the petitioner tvas not a\\'ar(lcd :utt service u,eightagc points. It is
also submitted that the petitioncr belongs to Scheduled Caste
community, and the last selcctcd candidate under the said
communit)' secured (43.757) marks, w,hereas, the petitioner has
secured only (41.237) marks. Hencc, hc ts not u,ithin the zone of
consideration. Therefore, it is prar,cd to drsntiss thc present rvrit
petition.
6.
Likewise, learned Standing Counscl :rppearing on bchalf o[
respondent No.3 submi[s that in pursuancc of Notihcation
No.67 /2017 dated 18. 12.2017 ,
rhe pctitroner parricipared in the
recr-uitment process lor the post ol Lab l'ccl.rr-rician Clirade il, and as
per the Notihcation, a ma-ximum ol (7O) poinrs r,r,ould be awardecl for
written examination and (30) points for expcrience, which inciudes a
maximum of (10) points lor serriority in re rms oI passing the
qualifying examination and (2O) lor the (lovcrnmcnt ser'.',ice on
contract basis. It is submitted that paragrapir VIII of the Norification
also clearly specihed that rhe weightage of (2O) points would be
arvarded only to the employees lvorking on contractual basis in
Government organization. However. a Committee $,its constituted by
PK,
J
\ '. P No.2926O of 2A24
the \ledical Department, which has declarecl tlr r rhc cmplo\,ces
lvorking on outsourcing bilsis arc not eligible for a,,r: r ling thc se rvicc
!\'e ightagc poinl
s. as per thc guidelincs issucd ii
G.(.r Ms. No. 166
dated 09.O9.2017.
7.
It is furthcr submitted that in compliance u,i1 h I re orciers ,f this
CourL daled 1,9.O7.2024 in W.P.No. l9OT7 of 2a24. hc r:ase of tac
pctitiolter herein r"r,trs cxamined b1r thc Comn.riss r r in dctail, ancl
I
since he was found to be working as an outsour-r.i: 1 ernployee. hrs
l
i
request for arvard of service weightage points u,as rrg I l[1, t.c.jcctccl vide
I
impugrred orrler datcd 09.1O.2024. It is furthcr sr rnitLed thilr lltc
I
I
Dircctor of llublic Health and Family Welfare. ., le lctter dared
I
i
i
I
I
09.12.2022, :rlso clarified that the petitioner,s nanr(, (\ras inch_riled in
thd list of workers, altd that his services colnc ,i. :lcr outsourcirrg
basis. As such, there is no illegality or arbitrarint.:: in rejecting Lhc
claim of the petitioner.
I
i
ll
8.
It is further submitted that the selection proc,, ;s for thc posr ol
Lab Techniciiln (lrade-ll in pursuance of Notificatiorr No.(r7l2O 17 has
I
I
i
I
I
alrcadl' bccn concluded on O9.08.2O24, and cxc,,l thr: (27) posts,
which were reserved as per the interim orders of tli { Court, only (16)
vacancies relnained unfilled, and the same were alri cat-ried [o|r.r,ard
I
I
I
i
PK,,J
tlt.P No 292(t0 oJ 2021
to the next recruitment, as per G.o.lvls.No.8L dated 22.02.1997 and
(l.O.Ms.No.544 dated 04.12.1998, dlrc to non availability of eligible
cardidates in certain catcgories. It is [urther submirrect that
Icspondent No.3 is only a recruiting agency and does not possess thc
authority to award weightage marks, and thus, the Mcdical and
Health Department and the officc ol DPH and F-W $.crc delcgatcd [h(l
authority to award weightage marks. As such, a iist of czrndidates
rvas forlvarded to respondent No.3 rvith scrvice weightage marks
arvarded to their contractual service. and in pursuance o[ the samc,
the selection process was undertakcn ernd concluded. Further, no
Scheduled Caste vacalc], remained unfilled, and the lasr sclected
candidate in the said community secured \43.757) ntarks, rvhereas,
the. petitioner secured only (41.237) nrarks ir-r the written examination.
Therefore, it is prayed to dismiss the prescnt ri rit petitrun.
9.
This Court has taken note of the nval submissions advanced by
learned counsel for the respective parties arrd perused the material
available on record.
10. Admittedly, respondent No.3 issued Notification No.67 12017
dated 18.12.2O17, for recruitment to Lhe posr ol Lab Technician
PK, J
t P.No 2926(.) of 2()24
Graclc II, and Par:r-VIII dcals with the proceclure f.r relerr:tio., u,ltich
rc:rd s as u nder
P.\l?A VIIl: I)llr)CEI)URIi IrOR SEL!]CTION
TI]I] SEI,EC'II()N OII CANDIDATES FOR APPOINTMENT 1( ]IE F'OS'I IS
.\s t.'oLt,o\\'s
'llJE ITINAL SI.)LECTION OF THESD POSTS WILL IIE
B.r- tD ())- 70
\','EI( i HTi\(] I] (POINTS) IN WRITTEN EXAMINATIC)i ANI) 3O
\VEI(;HTACI' (PO]NTS) FOR THD OOVT. SERVICE (II\
i,ut''foc[t itER.
'RIIINCEI
Tlre proccclure of selection for the post is as follo$.s
sl \",,,
I
lertr,.ulars
Wrrtte n Examinatlon
Expc rlence
Total
e ,l
loo
Tlrc clitl l;t ftrr a*arding Weightage (Marks) for Go
i[]xperie rce) rs as follows:
CrLteria
Ser.'ir c
Consisls
of
, nts) Il
Wcightage of experience of Govt.
Serr icc
\\ ( Elhtage
_l lxl lks)
Se11 ice
i)
Six Months in Tribal Area
ii)
Six Months in Rural Area
iii)
Six Months in Urban Area
(Corporations &
Grade-l
I
Munici alities
As Per the Selection of procedure, it consists of , /elghlagc ol
total 1O0 points. In which maximum 70 points \l.il le gLven t()
Written Examination conducted for lS0 marks and r rximtrrn 30
l)ornts $rl1 be given to Experience of the candidates br ed orr their
(lovernmer: r Sen'ice.
I l hose calrdrrlates rvho qualify in the Examination in o:.r ( - of lncrrt t\ lil
bc called fo. \,erification of Certificates, Community an( )ategorl !v]se
lor the vacancics available as required. The minin r m qtraliir irrg
nrar-ks for Sclection are OCs 4ool,, BCs 35% SCs, STs rnd pH 30 )i,.
'l'he minirnu m quahfying marks are relaxable in the case of
SC/ST/BC/PH at the discretion of rhe Commission.
2. 'lhc candidatcs will bc selected and a-llotted to Servicc,/ I cpartmerlt its
lter- their r;Irk in the merit list and as per Departme ) an(l l)islrL.t
PK, J
|| P. No.29260 oJ 202.1
Preference for allotment of candidates against vacancies and for the
vacancies availablc.
N.B.: Mere securing minimum qualrfying marks cloes |ot vest an,v riglrt in
a candidate for bcrng considered for sclection.
3. The appcarance in all the paper/papers at the \Vrittert ExilrnrrratioIl as
per rules is compulsory r\bsence in any of the papet /'papers \!l1l
automatically render his candidature asdisqualified.
.+ Calldidates ha\'e to produce Original documenls an(l oth.r pau-ticular s
on the day of verification rtself. Ifcandidate fails to procluce any ofthe
required certificates and i[ the particulars furnished b) him / her in
the Application do not tally q,ith the Origlnal documents 1>roduced Irrm
/ her, then his / her candidature $rll be rejecrccl,/disquahfied \\,ithout
any further correspondencc- As caldidatLlrc for tlre recruitlncnt rs
processcd through Compu fe r/ Elect ron rc cll'rLces based on thc
particulars furnished in the Apphcation I.'orm, the canclidatc is
advised to fill in all the relevant particulars carclullr.
5. The preference opted by candidates rrr respect of posts, Distnct erc. in
the apptication form are only indicatrve for being consLdered to the
extent possible but not brnding or limiting th(: Commissron's porvers
conferred under Article 315 and 320 of the Corlstitulron of In(ira.
Therefore, the Commission has thc power to assign a successful
candidate to anj of the notrfied posls for $,hich he,/she is qualified arrd
eligible, subject to fulfilling the selection crrterron. Mere claim of
preference for any Department / District for allotmerlt agarnst vacan._r
does not confer a right to sclection for that District in particular or an1
District in General.
6. The appointment of selected candidates witl be subject to their being
found medically nt in the appropriate Medical Examination, and if
he/she is of sound health, active habits free from au'ry bodill defect or
infirmity"
I 1.
The main dispute in the present writ petition pertains to thc
non-awarding of the service weightage points to thc petitioner.
According to the petitioner, he had rendered his services in the
Osmania Medical College, Hyderabad, as a Lab Technician, on
contractual basis from July, 2015, to June, 2O2O, and thus, cligible
for service weightage points. However, his claim has been rejected
vide impugned proceedings dated 09.1O.2024, stating that the
petitioner rendered his services on outsourcing basis but no[ on
PK, ,J
W.P.No.29260 of 2024
contr:1ct basrs; that he l:riled to produce thc necesst -y documents a1
the reler.ant point ol lime; and that hc is Lc.:: mcrrtorious i,
Sr:hcdulcrl Citstc c:rtcgon, hcnce, ineligible for selcc r rn
12. For b(,t1cr appreciation of the case on hancl, it is apposite to
reler to the pr:tiLioncr's appointment order issur:rl rv the prir-rcipal.
Osmania Merlical College, Hyderabad, vide proceediri ,s No.MRU/proj7
oMClHyd/2r.) 15/ 1o38 crated 21.0s.2015, and the r, evar-rt lcrrns a.(r
conditions of his appointment are extracted hereunr r r:
"TI.rc C rdi(late rs informed that his/her appoini rent as Lab
Technicran on colrtracr basis is purely on temporiry bas s and is liable
to the termin.ttioD at anv time without issigning n! r.iottce or
reasons.
He/ She rr rll l:e parcl consolidated paymcnl Rs: 1g.35O per rnonth of
Lab Tecltrricran per month each for a period of one yr:i r fiom the date
of joir.ring;rs pcr DHR/ ICMR Guidelines.
Dur ing LIri: Ixrri()d of Ilrs/Her service of one year he/sh j wi be ehgibie
for leaves srrictly allo\r.s as per DHR/ tCfr4n guiaelr es sub.lect to
approval of Nodal Officcr.
Thc Tentporary service as l^ab Technician on contract ,asis does not
qualifi. hirn/hcr for anv pensioner benefits."
i3. lrrom rhe abovc, it is unequivocally clear thz t the petitioner,s
scrvices rverc Lrtilizcd on a contractual basis. Henr:c, the contention ol
thc rcspondrllts that thc petitioner worked on out;ourcing basis is
u,holly' unte.a blc, and thus, rejccting the claim o - the petitioner on
this ground cannot Lre countenanced.
I
I
li
ll
7)
PK, .I
\1,.P. No 29)i)A o12024
16. Accordingly, the Writ Petition is allowed setting asidc the
I
i
impugncd order vide Memo. No.467 / RP-ll /201 7 darecl 09.1O.2024
issucd b1. respondcnt No.3, and the respondcnts are dir(:cled to
consrder thc case of the pctitioncr for selection and appointmel]t to
the post of Lab Technician Grade II by au'arding him sert'ice
wcightage points as per his entitlement.
Miscellancous applications, if any, pending in this u'rit I)ctition,
shalI stand closed. No costs.
SDI.K .BHAVAN
ISWAMY
GI
SIS iaur ne
,ITRUE COPYII
To
SECTION OFFICER
milY Welfare
Health a
d raba d 500 022
aiate of Tela ngana at
1. The PrinctPa
elangana, Koti'
Dep artment, S ecretariat'E d ucation, Go vernmen to
2. The Director- o5f00Medical
(TGPSC)' NamPaltY'
001.
ice Commission
Hvd erabad
Serv
Public
Telang ana
at
3. The Secretary'
State of Telangana
the
0 001
for
Court
erabad
igh
Hvd
SERVICES- I' H
4. Two CCs to GP FOR
Advocate iOPUCI
Hy de iabad. [OU rl
NI RAHU L REDDY' e (oPUC)
RASA
A
S
E
On eC CTOSRI
, Advocat
P S.RAJA SEKHAR
6 One C CtoSRl
7 iwo CD CoPies
SA
BS
ovt Medical,
I Secretary, G
I
I
I
I
I
HIGH COURT
I
i
I
t
DATED:0910112026
I
t
(
I
I
jt,
o
JA
I
\ 1 fl 2 6
7-
c)
\
*
I
I
ORDER
I
!
WP.No.29260 of 2024
ALLOWING THE W.P
WITHOUT COSTS.
2o
\t
\a.b
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review