The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
17. Learned counsel has also laboured to bring home the point that none of the prior arts D1-D6 disclose a similar process for depolymerization of PET using ethylene glycol salt and methanol and also do not disclose: (a) admixing PET with a first solvent comprising methanol at a temperature from 50oC to 100oC to yield a first mixture; (b) adding a glycoxide to the first mixture, wherein the glycoxide is mono sodium glycoxide suspension, wherein the ratio of mono sodium glycoxide to PET is from 1:2 to 1:20 (mol/mol); (c) adding a second solvent to form a second mixture; and (d) admixing, thereby forming the terephthalate, as recited in claim 1 of the subject application. Also that D1-D6 do not disclose mixing methanol in PET to form a first mixture and subsequently, adding mono sodium glycoxide for a depolymerization process. As a matter of fact, Respondent has not considered this aspect, which had a crucial bearing on the case. Appellant highlights that D1 relates to improving the hydrophilic properties of PET fabric and D2 follows a different route through ethylene glycolysis and teaches away from directly using methanol for PET depolymerization. D3 concerns washing and purification of polymers, while D5 also teaches away from methanolysis by stating that it requires high temperature and pressure, thereby discouraging the claimed approach and D6 uses a nonpolar solvent and hydroxi…
18. For all the aforesaid reasons and without expressing any opinion any merit on the case, this appeal is partially allowed setting aside the impugned order dated 31.03.2024 passed by the Respondent. Direction is issued to the Respondent to decide the Indian Patent Application No. 202117002258 filed on 18.01.2021 in respect of invention titled “TEREPHTHALIC ACID ESTERS FORMATION”, afresh. Needless to state that the decision will be taken after giving an opportunity of hearing to the Appellant and taking into consideration all relevant submissions made in the written submissions filed before the Respondent as also in the present appeal. The decision will be taken within four months from today.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
#
CNR No. DLHC010563962024
+
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
9449710 CANADA INC
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. Nishant Rai, Ms. Neha Ruhela,
Ms. Manisha Singh, Mr. Abhai Pandey, Mr.
Manish Aryan, Ms. Yojana Sonkusare, Ms.
Shivani Singh and Ms. Akhya Anand, Advocates.
versus
DEPUTY CONTROLLER OF PATENTS AND DESIGN
.....Respondent
Through: Ms. Shiva Lakshmi, SPC with Ms.
Pankhuri Tiwari and Mr. Prashant Kumar Sharma,
Advocates.
CORAM:
HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE JYOTI SINGH
ORDER
06.08.2026
%
1.
This appeal is filed on behalf of the Appellant under Section 117A of
the Patents Act, 1970 (‘1970 Act’) for setting aside impugned order dated
31.03.2024 passed by the Respondent, whereby Indian Patent Application
No. 202117002258 filed on 18.01.2021 has been refused as also for a
direction to the Respondent to grant the patent on the claimed invention.
2.
To the extent necessary, the facts as pleaded are that Appellant filed
PCT National Phase Application No. 202117002258 on 18.01.2021 in
respect
of
invention
titled
“TEREPHTHALIC
ACID
ESTERS
FORMATION” and the application was examined and First Examination
Report (‘FER’) was issued on 23.06.2022, to which Appellant filed a reply
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
on 16.03.2023 along with amended claims. Hearing notice was issued by the
Patent Office and after final hearing on 18.12.2023, Appellant filed posthearing written submissions on 30.12.2023 with amended claims and
additional documents. By impugned order dated 31.03.2024, Respondent
refused the grant of patent in favour of the Appellant.
3.
As per the Appellant, subject application concerns a process for
depolymerization of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) to form dimethyl
terephthalate (DMT) that is efficient, involves low energy, high yield and is
cost effective. The process comprises various steps, wherein PET is mixed
with a first solvent comprising methanol at a temperature from 50oC to
100oC to yield a first mixture. To this mixture, mono sodium glycoxide
suspension is added along with PET in a ratio from 1:2 to 1:20 (mol/mol),
wherein the mono sodium glycoxide suspension is made via a process
comprising heating mono ethylene glycol at a temperature from 70 oC to
100oC and adding sodium hydroxide to the mono ethylene glycol, thereby
forming mono sodium glycoxide. Thereafter, the mono sodium glycoxide is
dried and suspended in a suspending solvent, forming the mono sodium
glycoxide suspension to which a second solvent is added and admixing is
done, leading to formation of terephthalate.
4.
Respondent has refused grant of patent on three grounds: lack of
clarity under Section 10(5); lack of inventive step under Section 2(1)(ja);
and non-patentability under Section 3(d) of 1970 Act. As per the impugned
order the claims contain the phrase ‘as claimed in any one of the claims’
which renders the scope of the claims unclear and thus the application falls
foul of Section 10(5). As per the Respondent, the subject invention lacks
inventive step owing to cited prior arts D1-D6 and is also non-patentable
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
under Section 3(d) since D1-D6 disclose a similar process for
depolymerization of PET using ethylene glycol salt and methanol as solvent
and additionally, since Appellant failed to provide any improved efficacy
data over D1-D6, the claimed invention is a mere new use of a known
process.
5.
Challenging the impugned order, learned counsel for the Appellant
submits that Respondent has erred in understanding the scope of claims with
regard to the phrase ‘as claimed in any one of the claims’ and has also failed
to provide any reasoning as to how the said phrase makes the claims unclear
in their scope. Respondent has overlooked that Section 10(5) only provides
that the claims of a complete specification must be clear and succinct but
does not provide a specific format for drafting dependent claims nor does it
place limitations on multiple dependencies that can be presented in the
claims.
6.
It is argued that the objection of lack of inventive step is
misconceived. Respondent has not followed steps 1, 3 and 5 of the five-step
test laid down by the Division Bench of this Court in F. Hoffmann-La
Roche Ltd. & Anr. v. Cipla Ltd., 2015 SCC OnLine Del 13619. Respondent
has also ignored the inventive step underlying the claims of the subject
application and has come to an erroneous conclusion that the claimed
invention is obvious to the person skilled in the art by applying a hindsight
approach. Even the most fundamental step of identifying the person skilled
in art is lacking in the instant case. This Court in Agriboard International
LLC v. Deputy Controller of Patents and Designs, 2022 SCC OnLine Del
940, has held that while considering an invention for lack of inventive step,
Controller must consider three elements: (a) the invention disclosed in the
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
prior art; (b) the invention disclosed in the application under consideration;
and (c) the manner in which subject invention will be obvious to a person
skilled in the art. Without any discussion on these three elements, it is
impermissible to arrive at a bare conclusion that the subject invention lacks
inventive step. Respondent has not carried out the said analysis and has
merely identified similarities and differences between the claimed invention
and the cited prior arts D1-D6, by simply extracting some parts and copypasting them side by side in a tabular form. No reason is assigned to explain
how a person skilled in the art would be motivated to arrive at the claimed
invention from the teachings in the prior art documents and these legal
infirmities are sufficient to set aside the impugned order.
7.
It is further argued that Respondent has erred in understanding the
scope of the claimed invention vis-à-vis. D1-D6. The claims of the subject
application provide a process of depolymerization of PET to form
terephthalate, the process comprising admixing PET with methanol to yield
a first mixture and then adding mono sodium glycoxide suspension to the
first mixture followed by a second solvent, thereby forming the
terephthalate. Use of methanol and mono sodium glycoxide demonstrates
improved yields of monomers in comparison to the known processes, where
sodium methoxide is added to a reaction mixture. Additionally, the process
provides the benefit of ensuring very high reaction yields under more
favourable reaction conditions such as low pressure, as stated in paragraphs
[00154]-[00155] of the claim specification. None of the cited documents
D1-D6 teach or suggest a process for depolymerization of PET to form a
terephthalate, where the mixture of PET with methanol yields a first mixture
and has mono sodium glycoxide therein. D1 relates to improving the
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
hydrophilic properties of PET fabric by using 5% NaOH aqueous solution
and mono sodium ethylene glycolate/ethylene glycol. D2 follows a
completely different route through ethylene glycolysis and importantly,
teaches away from directly using methanol for PET depolymerization. D3
concerns washing and purification of polymers and has no concern with PET
depolymerization. D5 also teaches away from methanolysis by stating that it
requires high temperature and high pressure, thereby discouraging the
claimed approach and D6 uses a non-poler solvent and hydroxide catalyst,
which is fundamentally different from the claimed invention and therefore,
none of the prior arts either alone or in combination teach or suggest the
features claimed in the present invention. Respondent has merely cherrypicked individual features from different references and mosaiced them
together with the benefit of hindsight, which is impermissible in law.
8.
It is urged that Respondent has also erred in holding that present
invention falls within the scope of Section 3(d) of 1970 Act as the cited
documents disclose a similar process for depolymerization of PET using
known ethylene glycol salt and methanol as a solvent and the subject
application does not contain improved efficacy data over the cited prior art.
The error is apparent on the face of the order inasmuch as the claims of the
subject application recite a process and not a product and therefore, there
was no requirement to provide the improved efficacy data over the cited
prior arts as held in Novozymes Krogshoejvej v. Assistant Controller of
Patents and Designs, MANU/TN/5373/2023. The claimed process employs
new reactant and cannot be considered as a mere use of a known process
under Section 3(d) of 1970 Act.
9.
Ms. Shiva Lakshmi, learned SPC appearing on behalf of the
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
Respondent submits that there is no infirmity in the impugned order.
Pursuant to the objection of lack of clarity and conciseness, Appellant had
filed a revised and amended set of claims along with written submissions on
30.12.2023, however, the amended claims still contain the phrase ‘as
claimed in any one of the claims’, which renders the scope of the claims
unclear and does not meet the requirement of Section 10(5).
10.
Respondent has also rightly held that claims 1-29 lack inventive step
under Section 2(1)(ja), in view of combined teachings of documents D1-D3
and D5-D6. As the order reflects, Respondent compared the claims of the
subject application with each of the prior arts separately to look into the
similarities and differences for deciding whether the claimed invention lacks
inventive step and has given reasons to support its conclusion. D1-D6 also
disclose a similar process of depolymerization of PET using ethylene glycol
salt and methanol as solvent and therefore, claimed invention is a mere new
use of known process. Appellant has also failed to provide any improved
efficacy data over the cited prior arts and hence, the claimed invention is
non-patentable under Section 3(d) and the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
11.
Heard learned counsels for the parties and examined their
submissions.
12.
By this appeal, Appellant challenges order dated 31.03.2024 whereby
its application for grant of patent in respect of invention titled
“TEREPHTHALIC ACID ESTERS FORMATION” has been refused. Owing
to the objections raised by the Respondent, Appellant revised the claims to
1-29, wherein claim 1 is the independent claim. Application has been
rejected on three grounds i.e., lack of clarity and conciseness, lack of
inventive step and non-patentability under Section 3(d) of 1970 Act.
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
13.
Insofar as the objection under Section 10(5) is concerned, there is no
reasoning in the order as to why the scope of claims is unclear or lacks
conciseness and all that is stated is that the phrase ‘as claimed in any one of
the claims’ makes the claims unclear. As for the objection under Section
2(1)(ja), learned counsel for the Appellant is right in his submission that
Respondent has not followed the five-step test in F. Hoffmann-La Roche
(supra). Even the most fundamental step of identifying the person skilled in
the art is missing. Respondent has mechanically referred to each of the prior
arts D1-D6 and then tabulated the differences with the claims, by copying
and pasting the relevant extracts. Having done so, without any discussion,
analysis or reasoning, a conclusion is drawn that Appellant has failed to
show any technical advancement over cited prior arts.
14.
Appellant rightly points out that while examining an application for
lack of inventive step, Respondent is required to consider the invention
claimed and the invention disclosed in the prior arts as also the manner in
which subject invention will be obvious to the person skilled in the art.
‘Inventive step’ means a feature of an invention that involves technical
advancement as compared to existing knowledge or having economic
significance or both and that makes the invention not obvious to the person
skilled in the art and therefore, as held in Agriboard (supra), Respondent
was required to analyse as to what was the existing knowledge and how the
person skilled in the art would move from existing knowledge to the subject
invention. Respondent has not identified the person skilled in the art and
resultantly, there is no analysis on how the claimed invention will be
obvious to the person skilled in the art. To this extent, the impugned order is
completely contrary to the settled law laid down in respect of deciding an
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
application claiming invention for the purpose of Section 2(1)(ja).
15.
Learned counsel for the Appellant is also correct in his submission
that Respondent has not even considered the points raised by the Appellant
in response to the FER as also the post-hearing submissions, bringing forth
that the present invention falls outside the scope of Section 3(d). Respondent
has not considered the submission that the cited prior arts D1-D6 do not
disclose similar process for depolymerization of PET using ethylene glycol
salt and methanol as solvent as also that the process for depolymerization of
PET is per se novel and has a technical advancement inasmuch as it shows
an improved monomer yields compared to known processes where sodium
methoxide is added to a reaction mixture. Impugned order reflects that
Respondent has not decided the basic question whether there was any
requirement of furnishing efficacy data since the claimed invention is a
process and not a product claim.
16.
Language of Section 3(d) is clear to the effect that for a mere use of a
known process to constitute patentable subject matter, it needs to employ at
least one new reactant or must result in production of a new product as held
in Tapas Chatterjee v. Assistant Controller of Patents and Designs and
Another, 2025 SCC OnLine Del 6369. In this said decision, the Division
Bench held that in terms of Section 3(d), a patent can be granted in respect
of a known process only when it results in a new product or employs at least
one new reactant and that there is a material difference between the
terminology ‘discovery of a new form of a known substance’ and ‘mere use
of a known process’. In the former case, patent can be granted only if the
said new form results in enhancement of the known efficacy of the
substance, whereas there is no such provision for enhancement of known
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
efficacy in respect of known processes and therefore, the scope of
patentability of processes is narrower than substances. This distinction has
been completely overlooked by the Respondent while rejecting the
application holding that Appellant has failed to provide improved efficacy
data.
17.
Learned counsel has also laboured to bring home the point that none
of the prior arts D1-D6 disclose a similar process for depolymerization of
PET using ethylene glycol salt and methanol and also do not disclose: (a)
admixing PET with a first solvent comprising methanol at a temperature
from 50oC to 100oC to yield a first mixture; (b) adding a glycoxide to the
first mixture, wherein the glycoxide is mono sodium glycoxide suspension,
wherein the ratio of mono sodium glycoxide to PET is from 1:2 to 1:20
(mol/mol); (c) adding a second solvent to form a second mixture; and (d)
admixing, thereby forming the terephthalate, as recited in claim 1 of the
subject application. Also that D1-D6 do not disclose mixing methanol in
PET to form a first mixture and subsequently, adding mono sodium
glycoxide for a depolymerization process. As a matter of fact, Respondent
has not considered this aspect, which had a crucial bearing on the case.
Appellant highlights that D1 relates to improving the hydrophilic properties
of PET fabric and D2 follows a different route through ethylene glycolysis
and teaches away from directly using methanol for PET depolymerization.
D3 concerns washing and purification of polymers, while D5 also teaches
away from methanolysis by stating that it requires high temperature and
pressure, thereby discouraging the claimed approach and D6 uses a nonpolar solvent and hydroxide catalyst, which is fundamentally different from
the claimed invention. Respondent has seriously erred in not looking into the
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
issues, both factual and legal, flagged by the Appellant in respect of prior
arts which were crucial for determining the objections under Section 2(1)(ja)
as also Section 3(d). The impugned order is wholly unreasoned on material
aspects and this has put the Appellant as also the Court to a disadvantage in
knowing what factors weighed with the authority concerned to reject the
patent application. It needs no reiteration that a non-speaking order cannot
be sustained in law and in the instant case, some crucial points have escaped
the attention of the Respondent and hence, the matter deserves to be
remanded.
18.
For all the aforesaid reasons and without expressing any opinion any
merit on the case, this appeal is partially allowed setting aside the impugned
order dated 31.03.2024 passed by the Respondent. Direction is issued to the
Respondent to decide the Indian Patent Application No. 202117002258 filed
on 18.01.2021 in respect of invention titled “TEREPHTHALIC ACID
ESTERS FORMATION”, afresh. Needless to state that the decision will be
taken after giving an opportunity of hearing to the Appellant and taking into
consideration all relevant submissions made in the written submissions filed
before the Respondent as also in the present appeal. The decision will be
taken within four months from today.
19.
Appeal is disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
JYOTI SINGH, J
AUGUST 6, 2026
S.Sharma
C.A.(COMM.IPD-PAT) 69/2024
This is a digitally signed order.
The authenticity of the order can be re-verified from Delhi High Court Order Portal by scanning the QR code shown above.
The Order is downloaded from the DHC Server on 21/08/2026 at 11:27:44
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review